The Myth of the “Military Model” of Leadership in Law Enforcement

@article{Cowper2000TheMO,
  title={The Myth of the “Military Model” of Leadership in Law Enforcement},
  author={Thomas Cowper},
  journal={Police Quarterly},
  year={2000},
  volume={3},
  pages={228 - 246}
}
Law enforcement is generally understood to be a paramilitary pursuit based on a specific “military model” of leadership and organization. This article analyzes the so-called military model in law enforcement and dispels the notion that police officers and their departments are patterned after the real military. It draws on the author's personal experience as well as on historical works and military doctrinal publications. It illustrates the problems caused within policing by the false… 

Figures from this paper

Changing Uniforms

Most academic attention regarding military influence on policing has focused on critiques of the military model of policing and police militarization and has neglected to examine the relationship

Police Managers' Attitudes towards a US Marine Corps Military Model: Responses to Corps Business

Historically, police departments have been modelled both structurally and operationally on quasi-military lines. This paper presents reactions of police managers who attended the Administrative

Conflict and compatibility

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to compare and analyze perspectives of law enforcement officers with combat deployment experience, other military background, and no military service

Women in policing: changing the organizational culture by adopting a feminist perspective on leadership

Issues of leadership identified in the current literature, with particular reference to leadership found in all organizations, are discussed in an attempt to identify aspects of classical leadership

Developing effective leadership in policing: perils, pitfalls, and paths forward

Purpose – Leadership plays a key role ensuring the achievement of desired outcomes in both formal and informal groups. Insufficient leadership in policing can result in significant negative

Myths, militarism and the police patrol rifle

Violence and force have played an important role in the establishment and defence of democratic values, and myths are used to justify the violence. The use of state-sanctioned violence by the police

The place of civilians in policing

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to examine the correlates of job satisfaction among civilian employees of law enforcement agencies, to assess how features of the policing workplace influence

Police managerial perceptions of organizational democracy: a matter of style and substance

This paper re-examines an organizational democracy initiative that was undertaken in a suburban police department in the southwestern United States in 2003. In 2005, a study confirmed positive

Predicting the effects of military service experience on stressful occupational events in police officers

A review of the literature suggests that law enforcement agencies adopted a paramilitary model of management based on little empirical evidence supporting the suitability of this model. Moreover,

Disrupting the “Heroic” Male Within Policing: A Case of Direct Entry

This article drives forward a more critical insight into the position of women within policing. In focusing on women as police leaders, it problematizes taken for granted representations of gender
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 12 REFERENCES

Doctrinal Publication (MCDP)-1 Warfighting

  • DC: Department of the Navy, Headquarters United States Marine Corps
  • 1997

[Self-destruction].

  • J. Lönnqvist
  • Medicine
    Duodecim; laaketieteellinen aikakauskirja
  • 1977

In referring to the "police agent" concept, Buerger referenced The Task Force Report on the Police of The President's Commission on Law Enforcement and Administration of Justice

  • 1967

Professional knowledge gained from operational experience in Vietnam Department of the Navy, United States Marine Corps. FM 100-14: Risk management

  • Professional knowledge gained from operational experience in Vietnam Department of the Navy, United States Marine Corps. FM 100-14: Risk management
  • 1967

Reprinted from The functions of the police in modern society

  • Touchstone readings
  • 1970

Police and society: Touchstone readings (2nd ed.)

  • Prospect
  • 1999

Chevy Chase, MD: National Institute of Mental Health

  • 1970

Warrior cops: The ominous growth of paramilitarism in American police departments (CATO Institute Briefing Papers No

  • 50). Washington, DC: CATO Institute. Thomas J. Cowper is a captain with the New York State Police and a graduate student at Marist College. He is a former Marine officer and has served in a
  • 1999