# The Motives behind Cantor's Set Theory – Physical, Biological, and Philosophical Questions

@article{Ferreirs2004TheMB, title={The Motives behind Cantor's Set Theory – Physical, Biological, and Philosophical Questions}, author={Jos{\'e} Ferreir{\'o}s}, journal={Science in Context}, year={2004}, volume={17}, pages={49 - 83} }

The celebrated “creation” of transfinite set theory by Georg Cantor has been studied in detail by historians of mathematics. However, it has generally been overlooked that his research program cannot be adequately explained as an outgrowth of the mainstream mathematics of his day. We review the main extra-mathematical motivations behind Cantor's very novel research, giving particular attention to a key contribution, the Grundlagen (Foundations of a general theory of sets) of 1883, where those…

## 12 Citations

### Paradox, Natural Mathematics, Relativity and Twentieth-Century Ideas

- Physics
- 2008

Here we examine the influence of the new set theory historiography - in particular the works of Garciadiego, Grattan-Guinness and Ferreiros - on our understanding of major twentieth-century ideas,…

### Preface to the Second Edition M. Hallett, Too, Has Contributed Much to a Better Understanding of Hilbert's Foundational Work with Numerous Papers

- History
- 2008

Happily, Labyrinth of Thought has been very well received among the communities of mathematicians, historians of mathematics, logicians, and philosophers of mathematics. For a number of reasons,…

### PHILOSOPHICAL METHOD AND GALILEO'S PARADOX OF INFINITY

- Philosophy
- 2008

We consider an approach to some philosophical problems that I call the Method of Conceptual Articulation: to recognize that a question may lack any determinate answer, and to re-engineer concepts so…

### Gödel’s Cantorianism

- Philosophy
- 2018

Godel’s philosophical conceptions bear striking similarities to Cantor’s. Although there is no conclusive evidence that Godel deliberately used or adhered to Cantor’s views, one can successfully…

### Voevodsky's unfinished project: Filling the gap between pure and applied mathematics

- MathematicsBiosyst.
- 2021

### Theological Underpinnings of the Modern Philosophy of Mathematics.

- Philosophy
- 2016

Abstract The study is focused on the relation between theology and mathematics in the situation of increasing secularization. My main concern is nineteenth-century mathematics. Theology was present…

### Voevodsky's Unachieved Project.

- Mathematics
- 2020

In a series of lectures given in 2003 soon after receiving the Fields Medal for his results in the Algebraic Geometry Vladimir Voevodsky (1966-2017) identifies two strategic goals for mathematics,…

### An Algorithmic Approach to Solve Continuum Hypothesis

- PhilosophyAcademic Journal of Applied Mathematical Sciences
- 2020

It is shown that when people extend mathematics into new systems (such as Force Axioms), experts can solve important mathematical problems (CH) and there are differ-ent types of such mathematical systems, similar to ancient mathematical notation.

### ¿Un doble vínculo? Reflexiones sobre historia, ciencia y cultura

- Philosophy
- 2010

The aim of this paper is to explore the double bind between science and culture through the analisys, from the history and philosophy of science perspective, of various scientific activities, in…

### Achieving the Lowest Effective Antipsychotic Dose for Patients with Remitted Psychosis: A Proposed Guided Dose-Reduction Algorithm

- Medicine, PsychologyCNS Drugs
- 2019

The preliminary findings suggest that patients with remitted psychosis can do well along a guided dose-reduction algorithm that follows a set of clear precautions and instructions, and it is anticipated that this approach can help optimize the risk–benefit ratio and instill a hope in patients with schizophrenia that they can maintain in stable remission under a lower antipsychotic dose without an increased risk of relapse.

## References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 58 REFERENCES

### "What Fermented in Me for Years": Cantor's discovery of transfinite numbers

- Mathematics
- 1995

Transfinite (ordinal) numbers were a crucial step in the development of Cantor's set theory. The new concept depended in various ways on previous problems and results, and especially on two questions…

### On the relations between Georg Cantor and Richard Dedekind

- Mathematics
- 1993

This paper gives a detailed analysis of the scientific interaction between Cantor and Dedekind, which was a very important aspect in the history of set theory during the 19th century. A factor that…

### Towards a biography of Georg Cantor

- History
- 1971

Summary The great influence of Georg Cantor's theory of sets and transfinite arithmetic has led to a considerable interest in his life. It is well known that he had a remarkable and unusual…

### From the calculus to set theory, 1630-1910 : an introductory history

- Mathematics
- 1985

From the Calculus to Set Theory traces the development of the calculus from the early seventeenth century through its expansion into mathematical analysis to the developments in set theory and the…

### Romanticism and the Sciences

- Art
- 1990

List of illustrations Notes on contributors Preface Introduction: the age of reflexion Part I. Romanticism: 1. Romanticism and the sciences David Knight 2. Schelling and the origins of his…

### Lebesgue's theory of integration: Its origins and development

- Mathematics
- 1970

Riemann's theory of integration The development of riemann's ideas: 1870-80 Set theory and the theory of integration The end of the century: A period of transition The creation of modern integration…

### The role of the absolute infinite in Cantor's conception of set

- Mathematics
- 1995

L'A. etudie la distinction etablie par Cantor entre les multiplicites consistantes et les multiplicites inconsistantes, a la lumiere de sa theorie des ensembles, de ses definitions actuelle et…

### Scientific Materialism in Nineteenth Century Germany

- History
- 1977

1. Background.- I. Ludwig Feuerbach: Father of German Materialism.- II. Reaction in the Fifties.- 2. The Scientific Materialists and their Works.- III. Karl Vogt: Sounding the Alarm.- IV. Jacob…

### Robert Mayer and the conservation of energy

- HistoryMedical History
- 1995

Interesting as the book is in its treatment of the politics of medicine, it would have been stronger still if the author had paid more attention to the biology and less to Foucault.