The Medicalization of Race: Scientific Legitimization of a Flawed Social Construct

@article{Witzig1996TheMO,
  title={The Medicalization of Race: Scientific Legitimization of a Flawed Social Construct},
  author={Ritchie Witzig},
  journal={Annals of Internal Medicine},
  year={1996},
  volume={125},
  pages={675-679}
}
  • R. Witzig
  • Published 15 October 1996
  • Medicine
  • Annals of Internal Medicine
Use of race as a way to classify large divisions of Homo sapiens originated with Carl von Linne (Linnaeus) [1]. Johann Blumenbach [2] was the first to use the word race, and use of this word has remained largely unchanged in common and medical contexts. Von Linne, the Swedish taxonomist and botanist, was the first to place humans in a taxonomy of animals, in his Systema Naturae in 1758. He divided humans into four main groups on the basis of physical and psychological impressions: Europeans… 

Skin color and race

  • N. Jablonski
  • History
    American journal of physical anthropology
  • 2020
TLDR
The history of the use of skin color is reviewed to show how the imprint of history in connection with a single trait influenced subsequent thinking about human diversity and the influence of color memes and race ideation in general on human behavior and the conduct of science.

‘Race’ as a social construction in genetics

Racial and ethnic categories have appeared in recent scientific work in novel ways and in relation to a variety of disciplines: medicine, forensics, population genetics and also developments in

Racial classification in the evolutionary sciences: a comparative analysis.

  • M. Billinger
  • Education
    History and philosophy of the life sciences
  • 2007
TLDR
The central argument of this paper is that race is not a specifically human problem, but one that exists in evolutionary thought in general, by providing a comparative analysis of the use of racial classification in evolutionary biology, genetics, and anthropology.

The Future of Ethnicity Classifications

In the first decade of the twenty-first century, ‘diversity’ has emerged as a key value in its own right, celebrated through human rights and similar policies promoting identity and providing an

Revitalizing Difference in the HapMap: Race and Contemporary Human Genetic Variation Research

  • J. Hamilton
  • Biology
    Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics
  • 2008
TLDR
Post-HGP genetic science has seen a substantial shift toward the use of race variables in genetic research and, according to a number of prominent scholars, is re-invoking the specter of earlier forms of racial science in some rather discomfiting ways.

Race categorization and the regulation of business and science.

TLDR
The study suggests the utility of a comparative cultural sociology of the politics of legal regulation, particularly when understanding race-related regulation and the importance of examining legal regulations for exploring how the meaning of race or ethnicity are contested and constructed in law.

Stratifying a Population by Race

TLDR
It is argued that the sciences should treat race as a variable whose value can vary from one health risk to another and, in particular, how race is used in the biomedical sciences to describe or explain differences within the U.S. population in health status or outcomes.

Odds and Ends: Trust and the Debate over Medical Futility

  • A. Caplan
  • Medicine
    Annals of Internal Medicine
  • 1996
TLDR
Medical futility must be understood as referring to both the probability and the desirability of attaining a particular diagnostic, therapeutic, or palliative goal, and practitioners must be alert to both dimensions in dealing with patients, colleagues, students, and families.

SISIS ABSTRACT This essay examines the efforts of social scientists and humanities

scholars to teach students at a major US medical school about 'race'. The objectives were to explain that race is no longer considered a biologically legitimate concept and to demonstrate that race

The cradle to the grave

Despite a constitutional and oft-stated political commitment to an undefined notion of non-racialism, South Africans continue to operate in formal and informal ways with ‘race’ as the common-sense
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 48 REFERENCES

The Mind of Primitive Man

A FAMOUS psychological novelist has asserted that racial differences are irreducible, and that even when love unites two members of distinct races their life, however harmonious, is lived over a

We Europeans:

THIS book, the result of a happy collaboration, comes as an opportune prophylactic against the spreading virus of racialism. Its nine chapters contain a historical survey of the development of

Identifying Ethnicity in Medical Papers

  • E. Huth
  • Medicine
    Annals of Internal Medicine
  • 1995
TLDR
The Perspective essay by Caldwell and Popenoe recommends that simplistic racial terms such as black and white be dropped and that more attention be paid to detailed history taking that can yield invaluable information on ethnic background and possible risks for certain diseases and potentially important cultural information.

Perceptions and Misperceptions of Skin Color

TLDR
It is argued that the use of these terms in the opening statements of routine, day-to-day case presentations implies that the terms have an importance and a scientific validity beyond their real merit, and that ethnicity is thought to be pertinent to the case in question.

Referential Ambiguity in the Calculus of Brazilian Racial Identity

  • M. Harris
  • Biology
    Southwestern Journal of Anthropology
  • 1970
Categorizations elicited from 100 Brazilian informants through the use of a standardized deck of facial drawings suggests that the cognitive domain of racial identity in Brazil is characterized by a

Race, ethnicity, culture, and science

Race and ethnicity are commonly used variables in medical research. Each year about 2500 papers are indexed under the headings “ethnic groups” or “racial stocks” on Medline1; many more control for

Changes in Bodily Form of Descendants of Immigrants

  • E. S.
  • Political Science
    Nature
  • 1913
IN the year 1908 Prof. Boas, at the request of the United States Immigration Commission, began an investigation into the physical characteristics of immigrants. The volume under review contains an

The Geography of Non-Infectious Disease

TLDR
This small book, by two well-experienced authors, is not only a 'good read' but it provides all that most young doctors should know about the geography of a wide range of chronic diseases.

The history and geography of human genes

  • R. Cann
  • Biology
    The Journal of Asian Studies
  • 1995
TLDR
The author examines the history of human evolution in Africa, Europe, and Asia through the lens of genetic, archaeological, and linguistic information.

The Genetic Basis of Common Diseases

TLDR
The introduction points out that the simply inherited mendelian disorders (dominant, recessive, and Xlinked) and chromosome abnormalities are uncommon or rare but that there are important genetic aspects of common disorders (loosely defined as occurring at least once in 1000 individuals).