The Mating Game Isn't Over: A Reply to Buller's Critique of the Evolutionary Psychology of Mating

  title={The Mating Game Isn't Over: A Reply to Buller's Critique of the Evolutionary Psychology of Mating},
  author={Andrew W Delton and Theresa E Robertson and Douglas T. Kenrick},
  journal={Evolutionary Psychology},
Eager undergraduates who are just learning about critical thinking will often raise their hand in class and say something like: " Wait, it can't be true that men prefer young women! The frat guys I know all date 20-year-old sorority sisters, but my widower grandfather dates a 45-year-old kindergarten teacher! " They fail to understand the ceteris paribus qualification that goes with all research—that is, that all else is held equal. In Adapting Minds, philosopher David Buller makes just such a… Expand
It takes two: sexual strategies and game theory.
  • Armin W. Schulz
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Studies in history and philosophy of biological and biomedical sciences
  • 2010
David Buss's Sexual Strategies Theory is one of the major evolutionary psychological research programmes, but its theoretical and empirical foundations cannot yet be seen to be fully compelling. Expand
The evolutionary psychology of human mating: a response to Buller's critique.
  • John Klasios
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Studies in history and philosophy of biological and biomedical sciences
  • 2014
This paper rebuts David Buller's criticisms of Evolutionary Psychology regarding women's long-term mating preferences for high-status men, and rebuts the sex-differentiated evolutionary theory of human jealousy. Expand
Mating Preferences in Choosing a Future Partner. Does Georgia Repeat the Same Worldwide Trend
ABSTRACT Georgian market of dating ads was studied using a sequential exploratory strategy, to see whether it repeats the worldwide trend: men look for attractive and younger women, and women lookExpand
Mating Intelligence, Moral Virtues, and Methodological Vices
According to the “mating intelligence” theory by evolutionary psychologist Geoffrey Miller, human morality is a system of sexually selected traits which serve as costly signals to the other sex aboutExpand
Psychology: a Giant with Feet of Clay.
It is suggested that evolutionary psychology must be intended as a pluralistic approach rather than a monolithic one, and that its main strength is its capacity to resolve the nature-nurture dialectics. Expand
Essay Review: Debunking Adapting Minds*
David Buller’s recent book, Adapting Minds, is a philosophical critique of the field of evolutionary psychology. Buller argues that evolutionary psychology is utterly bankrupt from both a theoreticalExpand
Hybrid Vigor: Coherence and Correspondence Criteria for Heuristics
The ecological approach to rationality involves evaluating choice processes instead of choices themselves, and there are good reasons for doing this. Proponents of the ecological approach insist thatExpand
Experimental Evidence for Sex Differences in Sexual Variety Preferences: Support for the Coolidge Effect in Humans
Evidence is found that men showed a greater preference for variety in potential short-term mates than did women, lending support to the idea that sex differences in preferences for sexual variety and novelty are a salient sex-specific evolved component of the repertoire of human mating strategies. Expand
The Evolutionary Explanation of What? A Closer Look at Adaptationist Explanations of Risk Preferences
The paper examines evolutionary explanations of risk preferences. First, the paper argues that evolutionary psychology is illsuited for explaining prospect theory risk preferences since the empiricalExpand
A Cultural and Macroeconomic Perspective on Mate Selection
This thesis uses cultural dimensions and macroeconomics to analyze six competing evolutionary psychology theories on human mating selection for 23 westernized countries and finds the social structural model received the most support from the data. Expand


Book Review: Buller Does to Evolutionary Psychology What Kitcher Did to Sociobiology
Just as Kitcher's Vaulting Ambition (1985) tried to undermine the paradigm of sociobiology, so David Buller attempts to undermine the paradigm of evolutionary psychology. This book, also written by aExpand
Evolutionary Personality Psychology
THIS CHAPTER IS divided into four principal sections. The first reviews several major current evolutionary psychological theories of personality. The next two cover empirical evidence for theseExpand
The Adapted mind : evolutionary psychology and the generation of culture
Although researchers have long been aware that the species-typical architecture of the human mind is the product of our evolutionary history, it has only been in the last three decades that advancesExpand
The evolution of human mating: Trade-offs and strategic pluralism
During human evolutionary history, there were “trade-offs” between expending time and energy on child-rearing and mating, so both men and women evolved conditional mating strategies guided by cuesExpand
Evolution, traits, and the stages of human courtship: qualifying the parental investment model.
Males had lower requirements for a sexual partner than did females, but were nearly as selective as females when considering requirements for an long-term partner, and females were more selective overall, particularly on status-linked variables. Expand
Mate Selection Criteria: A Trait Desirability Assessment Study of Sex Differences in Serbia
This paper examines predictions from evolutionary and socio-structural perspectives on sex differences in mate selection criteria on a sample of 127 respondents from Serbia. The respondents, mainlyExpand
Evolutionary Psychology -- The New Science of the Mind
PART ONE - FOUNDATIONS OF EVOLUTIONARY PSYCHOLOGY Chapter 1. The Scientific Movements Leading to Evolutionary Psychology Chapter 2. The New Science of Evolutionary Psychology PART TWO - PROBLEMS OFExpand
Age preferences in mates reflect sex differences in human reproductive strategies.
Social psychologists have held that when selecting mates women prefer older men and men prefer younger women. In a form of economic exchange based on conventional sex role norms both men and womenExpand
Can one ever be too wealthy or too chaste? Searching for nonlinearities in mate judgment.
Across studies, income and desirability were linked exponentially, particularly for male targets and marriage partners, and the authors discuss how nonmonotonic functions may suggest competing underlying processes. Expand
Sexual strategies theory: an evolutionary perspective on human mating.
A contextual-evolutionary theory of human mating strategies is proposed, hypothesized to have evolved distinct psychological mechanisms that underlie short-term and long-term strategies between men and women. Expand