The Limits of Evolutionary Explanations of Morality and Their Implications for Moral Progress*

@article{Buchanan2015TheLO,
  title={The Limits of Evolutionary Explanations of Morality and Their Implications for Moral Progress*},
  author={Allen E. Buchanan and Russell Powell},
  journal={Ethics},
  year={2015},
  volume={126},
  pages={37 - 67}
}
Traditional conservative arguments against the possibility of moral progress relied on underevidenced assumptions about the limitations of human nature. Contemporary thinkers have attempted to fill this empirical gap in the conservative argument by appealing to evolutionary science. Such “evoconservative” arguments fail because they overstate the explanatory reach of evolutionary theory. We maintain that no adequate evolutionary explanation has been given for important features of human… 
Evolutionary arguments against moral realism: Why the empirical details matter (and which ones do)
TLDR
It is concluded that the empirical considerations relevant for the strongest empirically driven argument against moral realism go beyond the strictly evolutionary realm; debunkers are best advised to draw upon other sources of genealogical knowledge as well.
Against moral judgment. The empirical case for moral abolitionism
ABSTRACT In this paper, I argue that recent evidence regarding the psychological basis of moral cognition supports a form of (moderate) moral abolitionism. I identify three main problems undermining
Explaining historical moral convergence: the empirical case against realist intuitionism
Over the course of human history there appears to have been a global shift in moral values towards a broadly ‘liberal’ orientation. Huemer (Philosophical Studies 173: 1983–2010, 2016 ) argues that
Slavery, Carbon, and Moral Progress
My goal in this paper is to shed light on how moral progress actually occurs. I begin by restating a conception of moral progress that I set out in previous work, the “Naïve Conception,” and explain
On the use of evolutionary mismatch theories in debating human prosociality
TLDR
It is recommended that moral philosophers interested in the evolutionary literature also engage with dispositions such as xenophilia and social tolerance to counterbalance the focus on psychological mismatches adopted so far.
Old Wine in New Bottles
Evolutionary debunking arguments (EDAs) purport to show that robust moral realism, the metaethical view that there are non-natural and mind-independent moral properties and facts that we can know
Survival of Defeat : Evolution, Moral Objectivity, and Undercutting
Evidence from biology and psychology suggests that our moral views depend on our evolutionary history. To use an extreme example, if we humans would have evolved to live like hive bees, we would
Moral progress: Recent developments
Abstract Societies change over time. Chattel slavery and foot‐binding have been abolished, democracy has become increasingly widespread, gay rights have become established in some countries, and the
The dynamics of moral progress
Assuming that there is moral progress, and assuming that the abolition of slavery is an example of it, how does moral progress occur? Is it mainly driven by specific individuals who have gained new
Butchering Benevolence Moral Progress beyond the Expanding Circle
  • H. Sauer
  • Psychology
    Ethical Theory and Moral Practice
  • 2019
Standard evolutionary explanations seem unable to account for inclusivist shifts that expand the circle of moral concern beyond strategically relevant cooperators. Recently, Allen Buchanan and
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 13 REFERENCES
The Open-ended Normativity of the Ethical
Abstract In The Ethical Project, Kitcher has throe main aim: (1) to provide a naturalistic explanation of the rise of morality and of its subsequent development, (2) to supply an account of moral
Parochial altruism in humans
TLDR
Punishment experiments, which allow ‘impartial’ observers to punish norm violators, with indigenous groups in Papua New Guinea, show that these experiments confirm the prediction of parochialism and indicate the need to explicitly examine the interactions between individuals stemming from different groups in evolutionary models.
Evolution and the psychology of intergroup conflict: the male warrior hypothesis
TLDR
How male coalitional aggression could have affected the social psychologies of men and women differently is described and preliminary evidence from experimental social psychological studies testing various predictions from the ‘male warrior’ hypothesis is presented.
The Coevolution of Parochial Altruism and War
TLDR
It is shown that under conditions likely to have been experienced by late Pleistocene and early Holocene humans, neither parochialism nor altruism would have been viable singly, but by promoting group conflict, they could have evolved jointly.
Hierarchy in the Forest
Are humans by nature hierarchical or egalitarian? "Hierarchy in the Forest" addresses this question by examining the evolutionary origins of social and political behavior. Christopher Boehm, an
The spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian paradigm: a critique of the adaptationist programme
  • S. Gould, R. Lewontin
  • Biology
    Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B. Biological Sciences
  • 1979
TLDR
The adaptationist programme is faulted for its failure to distinguish current utility from reasons for origin, and Darwin’s own pluralistic approach to identifying the agents of evolutionary change is supported.
Utilitarianism, Integrity and Partiality
Etude de l'objection de l'integrite opposee par B. Williams a la these utilitariste. Definissant les obligations morales qui resultent de la notion d'integrite objective, l'A. souleve le probleme du
The exaptive excellence of spandrels as a term and prototype.
  • S. Gould
  • Art
    Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
  • 1997
TLDR
The concept of biological spandrels-including the examples here given of masculinized genitalia in female hyenas, exaptive use of an umbilicus as a brooding chamber by snails, the shoulder hump of the giant Irish deer, and several key features of human mentality-anchors the critique of overreliance upon adaptive scenarios in evolutionary explanation.
Hen's Teeth and Horse's Toes
TLDR
Exploring the "peculiar and mysterious particulars of nature," Gould introduces the reader to some of the many and wonderful manifestations of evolutionary biology.
Demonic Males: Apes and the Origins of Human Violence.
Demonic Males: Apes and the Origins of Human Violence. Richard W. Wrangham and Dale Peterson. Boston: Houghton- Mifflin, 1996. 350 pp.
...
...