The Law and Economics of Contract Interpretation

  title={The Law and Economics of Contract Interpretation},
  author={Richard A. Posner},
  journal={Texas Law Review},
  • R. Posner
  • Published 1 November 2004
  • Economics
  • Texas Law Review
Contract interpretation is an understudied topic in the economic analysis of contract law. This paper combines simple formal analysis of the tradeoffs involved in interpretation with applications to the principal doctrines of contract interpretation, including the four corners rule, mutual mistake, contra proferentum, and what I call the (informal but very important) rule of extrinsic nonevidence. Gap filling is distinguished, and the relativity of interpretive doctrine to the interpretive… 

On the Writing and the Interpretation of Contracts

The major theme of this article is that the interpretation of contracts -- their possible amplification, correction, and modification by adjudicators -- is in the interests of contracting parties.

Interpretive Risk and Contract Interpretation: A Suggested Approach for Maximizing Value

The Article offers a theory of judicial intervention and interpretation in Contracts. It posits that the principal objective of courts interpreting, supplementing, or overriding terms is to ask


The chapter surveys recent developments in economics of contract interpretation. First, we point out the relevance of issue of contract interpretation to contracting problems. We then introduce a

Interpretation and Implied Terms in Contract Law

This essay will appear as an entry in the forthcoming Encyclopedia of Law and Economics (2d ed.), published by Edward Elgar. The essay surveys the law and economics literature on interpretation and

Contracting in the Shadow of the Law

I propose the view that the law affects economic efficiency by shaping contractual litigation and contracting as a result. I build a model where judges subject to personal biases try to distort

Rules of Evidence and Liability in Contract Litigation: The Efficiency of the General Dynamics Rule

We study the effects of different rules of evidence and liability in con- tract litigation. When a contracting firm fails to perform, it may blame the buyer for withholding private information. We

Conceptualizing Contractual Interpretation

Many litigated written contracts require interpretation, but few formal treatments of the interpretive process exist. This paper analyzes welfare-maximizing interpretive rules. It shows that (1)

Interpreting Contracts via Surveys and Experiments

Interpreting the language of contracts is the most common and least satisfactory task courts perform in contract disputes. This article proposes to take much of this task out of the hands of lawyers

Contract Interpretation and Contextual Asymmetry

A problem in economic contract theory is to know when parties can create efficient investment incentives with contracts. A problem in legal contract theory is to develop rules to guide courts in

Policy considerations in contract interpretation: the contra proferentem rule from a comparative law and economics perspective

The “default rule paradigm” Freedom of contract implies the principally non-mandatory nature of contract law. Parties are free to determine their mutual rights and obligations; provisions of contract




This chapter examines the economic arguments for textualism and contextualism, the two primary methodologies used by courts to determine the intentions of contracting parties with respect to their

Judicial Competence and the Interpretation of Incomplete Contracts

IN recent years writers in both economics and law have recognized the prevalence and importance of incomplete contracting in the design of markets and organizations. Each discipline has focused on

Contract Theory and the Limits of Contract Law

This article sets out a normative theory to guide decisionmakers in the regulation of contracts between firms. Commercial law for centuries has drawn a distinction between mercantile contracts and

Rigidity, Discretion, and the Costs of Writing Contracts

In this paper we model contract incompleteness "from the ground up," as arising endogenously from the costs of describing the environment and the parties' behavior. Optimal contracts may exhibit two

The Tentative Case Against Flexibility in Commercial Law

Well-rooted in modern commercial law is the idea that the law should reflect the performance practices formed among the parties throughout their interaction. The reality of the relationship can

Form and Substantive in Contract Interpretation

  • 2004


  • 2004