The Lasting Effects of Crime: The Relationship of Discovered Methamphetamine Laboratories and Home Values

Abstract

This study estimates a household’s willingness to pay to avoid the stigma of crime while minimizing concerns of omitted variable bias. By assuming methamphetamine producers locate approximately at random within a narrowly defined neighborhood, this study is able to use hedonic estimation methods to estimate the impact of the discovery of a methamphetamine laboratory on the home values near that location. Specifically, the analysis designates those closest to the site as the treated, while those slightly farther away act as the comparison group. The discovery of a methamphetamine laboratory has a significant effect on the property values of those homes close to the location that peaks from six to 12 months after each lab’s discovery. The estimates found in this study range from a decrease in sale prices of ten to nineteen percent in the year following a laboratory’s discovery compared to the prices for homes that are farther away but still in the same neighborhood. Surprisingly, the impact does not appear to depend on intensity as both the discovery of a second lab and being very close to the discovered lab do not adversely impact home values. JEL Classification Codes: H41, H76, K42, R32

11 Figures and Tables

Cite this paper

@inproceedings{CongdonHohman2011TheLE, title={The Lasting Effects of Crime: The Relationship of Discovered Methamphetamine Laboratories and Home Values}, author={Joshua Congdon-Hohman and Charlie Brown and Jeff M. Smith and Tom Buchmueller}, year={2011} }