The Justification of Bicameralism

@article{Riker1992TheJO,
  title={The Justification of Bicameralism},
  author={William H. Riker},
  journal={International Political Science Review},
  year={1992},
  volume={13},
  pages={101 - 116}
}
  • W. Riker
  • Published 1 January 1992
  • Economics
  • International Political Science Review
The main disadvantage of unicameral legislatures operating by simple majority rule is that, when politics is two-dimensional, they allow the adoption of out-of-equilibrium policies. Since in such cases a majority opposed to what a majority has adopted, the result is majority tyranny. To minimize such tyranny, it is necessary to delay action until a true majority in society is arrived at. Of the several methods of delay — supermajorityism, multipartyism, multicameralism — the best is… 

Figures from this paper

The political economy of secession: The case of Quebec

In the absence of oppression, citizens of a sub-unit who contemplate secession carefully weigh the benefits and costs of different outcomes. Here these costs are shown to be highly variable: they

On the Merits of Bicameral Legislatures: Policy Stability within Partisan Polities

Some “democrats” have argued that bicameral systems are undemocratic, insofar as voters in different regions or member states have disproportionate representation in one of the chambers. Others have

The Constitutional Choice of Bicameralism

We take a garden-variety instance of distributive politics-- a divide-the-cake stage game -- and explore dynamic extensions in different institutional settings: (i) repeated play of the stage game in

The Strange Revival of Bicameralism

The turn of the twenty-first century witnessed a surprising reversal of the long-observed trend towards the disappearance of second chambers in unitary states, with 28 countries – all but one of them

Bicameral Legislatures and Fiscal Policy

Early and modern scholars both presume that bicameral chambers limit the exploitation of minorities by the ruling majority similar to supermajority voting rules. We explain theoretically why

An Experimental Test

While the primary problem confronting democratic theorists in the past several decades has been majority rule instability, recent formal results suggest that this problem is diminished by

Divided Politics: Bicameralism, Parties, and Policy in Democratic Legislatures

▪ Abstract This article surveys the rationales for and effects of legislative bicameralism. At heart, second chambers facilitate representation for groups or interests that otherwise might be

The Institutional Effect on Majority Rule Instability: Bicameralism in Spatial Policy Decisions

The purpose of this paper is to report on experiments that test for an independent effect of bicameralism on legislative stability. The experiments are designed to test the theory of the bicameral

Supermajority rule and bicameral bargaining

This paper revisits the claim that supermajority rules and bicameral legislative structures restrain excessive government spending and taxation. Our analysis suggests that the extension effect of a

The Dynamics of Lawmaking in a Bicameral Legislature

This article analyzes legislative performance in a nascent presidential bicameral democracy, taking Brazil as a case. The author argues that the timing and outcomes of legislative production are
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 21 REFERENCES

CONDORCET'S THEORY OF VOTING

Condcrcet's criterion states that an alternative that defeats every other by a simple majority is the socially optimal choice. Condorcet argued that if the object of voting is to determine the “best”

The Impossibility of a Paretian Liberal

  • A. Sen
  • Philosophy
    Journal of Political Economy
  • 1970
The purpose of this paper is to present an impossibility result that seems to have some disturbing consequences for principles of social choice. A common objection to the method of majority decision

On the Rationale of Group Decision-making

  • D. Black
  • Economics
    Journal of Political Economy
  • 1948
When a decision is reached by voting or is arrived at by a group all of whose members are not in complete accord, there is no part of economic theory which applies. This paper is intended to help

Majority Decision-Making with Partial Unidimensionality

  • R. Niemi
  • Economics
    American Political Science Review
  • 1969
A major dilemma for majority decision-making occurs when the summation of transitive individual preference orderings results in an intransitive social ordering. The problems posed by this phenomenon,

The borda and condorcet principles: Three medieval applications

We report three medieval works, hitherto unknown to social choice, which discuss procedures for elections when there are more than two candidates. Two of the three propose Borda methods and the third

Social Choice and Individual Values.

Originally published in 1951, Social Choice and Individual Values introduced "Arrow's Impossibility Theorem" and founded the field of social choice theory in economics and political science. This new

The art of political manipulation

In twelve entertaining stories from history and current events, a noted political scientist and game theorist shows us how some of our heroes we as well as ordinary folk have manipulated their

A mathematical solution for the probability of the paradox of voting.

TLDR
Through the use of this model, a general solution for the probability of the paradox is derived, together with an approximation for computational convenience, and some numerical results are given.

The Probability of a Cyclical Majority

Consider a committee or society attempting to order the alternatives (X_1, X_2, X_3) by use of majority rule. Each individual is assumed to have a strong ordering (called a profile) on the

Analysis of Congressional Coalition Patterns: A Unidimensional Spatial Model

This article proposes stochastic, spatial model of roll-call voting as a benchmark for evaluating more complex models of congressional behavior. On the basis of several evaluative criteria, this