The Intrastate Security Dilemma: Ethnic Conflict as a `Tragedy'?

  title={The Intrastate Security Dilemma: Ethnic Conflict as a `Tragedy'?},
  author={Paul Roe},
  journal={Journal of Peace Research},
  pages={183 - 202}
  • P. Roe
  • Published 1 March 1999
  • Engineering
  • Journal of Peace Research
This article seeks to pull together the main body of work on the security dilemma and that concerning the relatively recent move in international relations in reconceptualizing and operationalizing the concept away from its usual interstate setting. First, it will discuss some of the ways in which the security dilemma has been defined. Second, it will concentrate on the work of those writers who have conceived of `ethnic security dilemmas' and `insecurity dilemmas' occurring at the intrastate… Expand
Dilemmas of Security in Iraq
This article suggests that much of the violence that has ravaged Iraq since the country's occupation by the US-led coalition in 2003 can be explained by focusing on the interplay between domestic andExpand
Former Yugoslavia:
This article provides a critical examination of recent attempts by International Relations theorists to apply the security dilemma concept to the intra-state level to explain the outbreak of ethnicExpand
The Cycle of Insecurity: Reassessing the Security Dilemma as a Conflict Analysis Tool
This article critically reassesses one of the classic ideas in International Relations, the security dilemma. It argues that the key insight of security dilemma theory has been obscured – byExpand
The ‘Security Dilemma’ and South Asian Nuclear Relations: India-Pakistan
The term Security Dilemma was first used by John Herz in 1951 to explain a situation that has long been understood in international politics. Through history its conception has evolved and itsExpand
Refining the Line of Distinction between Ethnic Conflict and Security Dilemma: Towards a Theory of Identity Driven Ethnic Conflict
ABSTRACT The concept of security dilemma has been widely applied to ethnic conflicts in former Yugoslavia and the post-Soviet space. This paper argues that for both methodological clarity and policyExpand
The security dilemma and ethnic conflict: toward a dynamic and integrative theory of ethnic conflict
Abstract I critically examine the existing literature on the security dilemma in ethnic conflict, thus laying part of the foundation for constructing a dynamic and integrative theory of ethnicExpand
Living with Security Dilemmas: Triggers of Ethnic Conflicts The Case of Georgia
In today’s contemporary world it is almost impossible to find an ethnically homogenous state. Relations between ethnic groups are also rarely harmonious and without any friction. However, it wouldExpand
Rebel group identity and international relations : how the illogic of appropriateness prolongs civil conflict
Despite the growing literature on the causes of intrastate conflict, little attention has been paid to the identity of rebel groups. Where rebel groups are introduced, they are represented asExpand
`Societal Security', the Baltic States and EU Integration
The concept of `societal security' has been formulated to account for the phenomenon of societal identity as a source of instability. This article discusses the concept as articulated by Buzan et al.Expand
Abolishing the security dilemma: Why we need to integrate the militaries
This article argues that the Security Dilemma can in fact be abolished by integrating the militaries into one common global organisation, possibly under one common command. The existence and workingsExpand


The Interregnum: the South's Insecurity Dilemma
This article investigates the ‘insecurity dilemma’ facing many Third World states arising from the fact that multiple ethnic communities reside within their borders. In terms of analysing the typesExpand
Rethinking Security after the Cold War
This paper examines aspects of the debate amongst traditionalist, widening and critical approaches to Security Studies. It looks at how the security agenda has expanded away from the narrow militaryExpand
Spiraling to Ethnic War: Elites, Masses, and Moscow in Moldova's Civil War
  • S. Kaufman
  • Political Science
  • International Security
  • 1996
I T h e continuing spread of ethnic violence seems set to replace the spread of communism as the central security concern in western capitals. Ethnic wars in Bosnia, Rwanda, Chechnya, and elsewhereExpand
Self and Other in International Relations
The study of identity offers a possibility to theorize on the human collectives of world politics, to give them an ontological status, and to discuss how they are constituted and maintain themselves.Expand
The security dilemma and ethnic conflict
The end of the Cold War has been accompanied by the emergence of nationalist, ethnic and religious conflict in Eurasia. However, the risks and intensity of these conflicts have varied from region toExpand
Identity, Migration and the New Security Agenda in Europe
This book argues that threats to ethno-national identity are replacing military concerns as the central focus of European insecurity. In Western Europe societal insecurity has replaced stateExpand
Explaining the Kashmir Insurgency: Political Mobilization and Institutional Decay
On December 8, 1989, members of the Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front kidnapped Dr. Rubiya Sayeed, the daughter of the Indian Minister of Home Affairs, as she left a government hospital in Srinagar.Expand
Cooperation Under the Security Dilemma
International anarchy and the resulting security dilemma (i.e., policies which increase one state's security tend to decrease that of others) make it difficult for states to realize their commonExpand
No Common Power: Understanding International Relations
I. INTRODUCTION: THE CONTEXT OF WORLD POLICTICS. 1. Understanding International Relations. 2. The International System and the Modern State. II. CONFLICT IN THE INTERNATIONAL SYSTEM. 3. The East-WestExpand
An ‘international’ theory of inter-ethnic war
Over the years, a number of scholars have noted that ethnic groups in violent conflict act much like states in the international system; James O'Connell describes the dynamics as ‘internationalExpand