The Influence of Niels Bohr on Max Delbrück

@article{McKaughan2005TheIO,
  title={The Influence of Niels Bohr on Max Delbr{\"u}ck},
  author={Daniel J. McKaughan},
  journal={Isis},
  year={2005},
  volume={96},
  pages={507 - 529}
}
The impact of Niels Bohr’s 1932 “Light and Life” lecture on Max Delbrück’s lifelong search for a form of “complementarity” in biology is well documented and much discussed, but the precise nature of that influence remains subject to misunderstanding. The standard reading, which sees Delbrück’s transition from physics into biology as inspired by the hope that investigation of biological phenomena might lead to a breakthrough discovery of new laws of physics, is colored much more by Erwin Schr… 
Quantum Explorers: Bohr, Jordan, and Delbrück Venturing into Biology
TLDR
The contributions of three physicists who in the 1930s were protagonists of the quantum revolution and explorers of the field of biology are looked at: Niels Bohr, Pascual Jordan, and Max Delbrück; it is proposed that Bohr's perspective on biology was related to his epistemological views, as Jordan’s was to his political positions.
Complementarity in biology
TLDR
The principle of complementarity was formulated to explain the fact that, in quantum physics, two theories regarded as mutually exclusive are required to explain a single phenomenon, and was applied to contexts other than quantum mechanics and the realm of subatomic particles.
Complementarity in biological systems: A complexity view
TLDR
System biology and complexity theory reveal that, as in the quantum realm, experimental observations themselves limit the authors' capacity to understand a biological system completely because of scale-dependent ‘horizons of knowledge,’ a form of biological complementarity as predicted by Bohr and Delbruck.
Toward a More General Understanding of Bohr's Complementarity: Insights from Modeling of Ion Channels.
TLDR
It is concluded that Bohr's complementarity might find applications in these complex modeling setups but only through its realistic phenomenological interpretation that allows applying different modes of description regardless of the nature of the underlying ion channel opening process.
How was teleology eliminated in early molecular biology?
  • P. R. Sloan
  • Philosophy, Medicine
    Studies in history and philosophy of biological and biomedical sciences
  • 2012
TLDR
This paper examines responses of three theoretical physicists who engaged boundary questions between the biological and physical sciences in this period in response to Bohr-Ernst Pascual Jordan, Erwin Schrödinger, and Max Delbrück.
Bohr’s Complementarity Framework in Biosemiotics
This paper analyses Bohr’s complementarity framework and applies it to biosemiotic studies by illustrating its application to three existing models of living systems: mechanistic (molecular) biology,
Visions of Revolutions: Microphysics and Cosmophysics in the 1930s
By 1930, at a time when the new physics based on relativity and quantum theory had reached a state of consolidation, problems of a foundational kind began to abound. Physicists began to speak of a
Biología y filosofía de la complementariedad en Niels Bohr
This article discusses Niels Bohr's philosophy of complementarity in the field of biology. To do this, it shows how the concept of complementarity arises in quantum physics and how Bohr generalizes
Creating a Borderless Platform for Scientific Research in Canadian Chemical Transactions
of atoms”. In this editorial, we explore how a borderless philosophy shaped scientific research in near past and will shape the future endeavors in science and technology. An aspiration for
The Meanings of the Gene and the Future of the Phenotype
  • Lenny Moss
  • Psychology
    Genomics, society, and policy
  • 2008
Grasping at Complexity How does one analyze a living organism? It’s not as easily settled a question as it may sometimes appear. For all the indisputable success of reductionist approaches in biology
...
1
2
3
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 14 REFERENCES
Niels Bohr’s Words and the Atlantis of Kantianism
How should we read Bohr? The answer to this question is by no means clear, not least because for a long period of time Bohr has not been read but rather mythologized, and his views “almost
Kant, teleology, and evolution
This essay examines Kant's idea of organic teleology. The first two sections are devoted to Kant's analysis and justification of teleological conceptions in biology. Both the idea of teleology and
The Philosophy of Niels Bohr: The Framework of Complementarity
Introduction. 1 . What is complementarity? 2 . Bohr's philosophical orientation. 3 . Quantum theory and the description of nature. 4 . The birth of complementarity. 5 . The refinement of
Once more: Bohr-Høffding
L'A. se defend contre les attaques de Favrhold et donne des arguments legitimant l'idee que la pensee scientifique de Bohr se comprend mieux a partir de celle de son professeur Hoffding
Kant's Critique of Teleology in Biological Explanation: Antinomy and Teleology
Kant's "Critique of Teleological Judgment" is read as a reflection on philosophical methodological problems that arose through the constitution of an independent science of life - biology. This work
The Systematic Unity of Kant's Idea of Nature
  • 1983
) at a conference held in Copenhagen in 1963 to commemorate Bohr's first papers on atomic constitution and was
Francis Crick, Salvador Luria, and Seymour Benzer also acknowledge the excitement stirred by What Is Life? as a part of their intellectual development
  • The Molecular Configuration of Nucleic Acids
...
1
2
...