The Impact of Race and Ethnicity on the Identification Process for Giftedness in Utah

  title={The Impact of Race and Ethnicity on the Identification Process for Giftedness in Utah},
  author={Russell T Warne and Braydon Anderson and Alyce O. Johnson},
  journal={Journal for the Education of the Gifted},
  pages={487 - 508}
Many gifted education experts have found that Black, Hispanic, and Native American students are less likely to be identified for gifted programs than Asian American and White students. A study was conducted to ascertain the degree of underrepresentation of these groups in gifted programs in Utah. Using state-collected data from 14,781 students in six representative school districts in Utah, it was found through multiple logistic regression analysis that there was no statistically significant… 

Tables from this paper

A Meta-Analysis of Gifted and Talented Identification Practices

Researchers consider the underrepresentation of Black, Hispanic, and Native American students is largely due to the use of traditional methods of identification (i.e., IQ and standardized achievement

Underrepresentation in Gifted Education in the Context of Rurality and Socioeconomic Status

Proportional identification of students for gifted services in Florida school districts is an important goal. A multi-level model was used to analyze school district data from the Florida Department

Recruiting and Retaining Underrepresented Gifted Students

Students from low-income and ethnic minority backgrounds are frequently underrepresented in gifted and talented education (GATE) programs. In this chapter, we contest the typical definition of

Gifted Students.

This review begins by acknowledging some of the larger debates in the field of gifted education and provides brief summaries of major conceptual frameworks applied to gifted education, dividing them into three categories: frameworks focused on ability, framework focused on talent development, and integrative frameworks.

A Single Case Study of the Impact of Policy Changes on Identification for Gifted Programs

The annals of gifted education research contain few educational policy studies and even fewer studies on the impacts of changes in policy. To partially fill this gap, the authors performed an ABA

The effect of poverty on the verbal scores of gifted students

Abstract A nonexperimental design was used to determine whether the verbal scores of low-income gifted fifth graders (n = 38) differed from those of their higher income peers (n = 83). The

School Integration Limits the Ability of Local Norms to Diversify Gifted Programs: A Mathematical Analysis with Implications Related to the Achievement Gap

It is shown that local building-level norms are best at diversifying gifted programs when schools are highly segregated, whereas when achievement gaps are present and a uniform admissions cutoff is applied, building- level norms in highly integrated schools produce highly segregated gifted programs.

Experiences of Elementary Teachers Using Inclusion Models to Serve Gifted Students

Gifted education has undergone recent changes because of the decrease in funding set aside for gifted students in the public school system. The use of inclusion to provide gifted education within the

Money over Merit? Socioeconomic Gaps in Receipt of Gifted Services

In this essay, Jason A. Grissom, Christopher Redding, and Joshua F. Bleiberg investigate the receipt of gifted services based on the socioeconomic status (SES) of elementary school students and their

Exploring learning and behavior problems of gifted children in Indonesia: A content analysis study

Although gifted children have talents and positive traits in academic area that already been supported, little empirical evidence addresses the need of support for gifted children in non-academic



Racial and Ethnic Representation in Gifted Programs

The Elementary and Secondary School Survey data and Civil Rights Data Collection of the Office for Civil Rights (OCR) were analyzed to describe the issue of overrepresentation of gifted Asian

Examining the Probability of Identification for Gifted Programs for Students in Georgia Elementary Schools: A Multilevel Path Analysis Study

This study focused on the analysis of a large-scale data set (N = 326,352) collected by the Georgia Department of Education using multilevel path analysis to model the probability that a student

Recruitment Is Not Enough: Retaining African American Students in Gifted Education

In public school systems all around the country, educators—teachers, counselors, and administrators—have made significant progress in identifying and recruiting diverse populations in gifted and

A Descriptive Analysis of Referral Sources for Gifted Identification Screening by Race and Socioeconomic Status

A dataset containing demographic information, gifted nomination status, and gifted identification status for all elementary school students in the state of Georgia (N = 705,074) was examined. The

Addressing Underrepresentation of Gifted Minority Children Using the Naglieri Nonverbal Ability Test (NNAT)

A persistent problem in education is the underrepresentation of diverse students in gifted education programs. Many educators attribute the poor participation of diverse students in gifted programs

Identification of Gifted Students in the United States Today: A Look at State Definitions, Policies, and Practices

Definitions of what constitute students who are gifted and talented as well as policies and procedures to identify these high-ability students play a critical role in determining which individuals

Multigroup Construct Validity Evidence of the HOPE Scale: Instrumentation to Identify Low-Income Elementary Students for Gifted Programs

Students with exceptional academic potential who come from low-income families are frequently not identified for and consequently are underrepresented in gifted and talented programs. Because of

More Than One Gap: Dropout Rate Gaps Between and Among Black, Hispanic, and White Students

The achievement gap, traditionally measured by test scores, also can be documented by dropout behavior. Examining dropout behavior among Black, White, and Hispanic students, with a particular focus

Comparing Tests Us ed To Ide ntify Ethnically Diverse Gifted Children : A Critical Response to Lewis

Recently Multicultural Education published a research article examining the effectiveness of three different tests in identifying ethnically diverse gifted and talented children (Lewis,

The Underrepresentation of Minority Students in Gifted Education

Concerns over recruiting and retaining minority students in gifted education programs have persisted for several decades, and, although many educators, policymakers, and researchers have deliberated