The Functional Role of Balinese Water Temples: A Response to Critics

@article{Lansing2012TheFR,
  title={The Functional Role of Balinese Water Temples: A Response to Critics},
  author={J. Lansing and T. D. Vet},
  journal={Human Ecology},
  year={2012},
  volume={40},
  pages={453-467}
}
In earlier publications we have proposed a model to explain the functional role of water temple networks in the agro-ecology of wet rice irrigation on the island of Bali. We argued that the key ecological effects of temple networks are best understood as emergent properties of a complex adaptive system. This argument implies that important aspects of the temple system are largely opaque from the perspective of conventional social science. We proposed that the Green Revolution created a real… Expand

Figures and Tables from this paper

THE PERSISTENCE OF AN ECOLOGICAL SOCIETY: IN-DEPTH CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE COMMUNITY MOVEMENT IN GERIANA KAUH, KARANGASEM
This research investigates the tenacity of the villagers of Geriana Kauh in the Regency of Karangasem, Bali in preserving their culture and nature. Balinese are facing immediate threats due toExpand
The Enchantment of Agriculture: State Decentering and Irrigated Rice Production in Bali
This article explores state involvement in the ‘enchanted’ aspects of irrigated rice production in Bali, Indonesia. Modernising states invariably forward what Max Weber called the rationalisation andExpand
Adaptive self-organization of Bali’s ancient rice terraces
TLDR
An evolutionary game is proposed, based on local farmers’ decisions that predicts specific power laws in spatial patterning that are seen in a multispectral image analysis of Balinese rice terraces, which triggers a transition from local to global-scale control of water shortages and rice pests. Expand
Re-examining balinese subaks through the lens of cultural multilevel selection
TLDR
Evidence from the literature and hypothetical scenarios are used to show how the CMLS framework can be used to understand the emergence and persistence of sustainable social–ecological systems and outline cultural transmission mechanisms that can explain the spread of group-beneficial traits in Bali. Expand
The Role of Archaeological Remains in Water Sources Traditional Conservation
Archaeological remains can be found everywhere. The archaeological remains in Pelaga and Belok Sidan Village, Badung Regency, Bali found in several temples and near water sources. The villagersExpand
Acts of citizenship? rulers and ruled in traditional Bali
ABSTRACT Recent understandings of indigenous leadership and governance have reframed earlier dualistic depictions of precolonial Balinese governance in terms of despotic kingship on the one hand andExpand
Sanitizing Jakarta: decolonizing planning and kampung imaginary
ABSTRACT This article offers a critical view of the water and sanitation sector within the broader trajectory of Jakarta’s spatial development and planning. Its territorial focus is on kampungs andExpand
Local Wisdom Of Subak As A Model Of Character Building For Social Studies Learning In Schools
This study aimed to trace back any character values contained in local wisdom of the Balinese traditional irrigation system called Subak and to construct it as a model of character building forExpand
EXPLORING COMMUNITY CAPITAL OF THE BALINESE SUBAK CULTURAL HERITAGE: A CONTENT ANALYSIS OF PARTICIPATORY MAPS
This paper explores the community capital (CC) of participatory maps and discusses their potential to stimulate community engagement, particularly for the conservation of cultural heritage. SurveysExpand
The Effect of Regional Development on The Sustainability of Local Irrigation System (A Case of Subak System in Badung Regency, Bali Province)
This study was aimed at investigating the sustainability of subaks in the dynamics of regional development in the metropolitan area of Badung Regency, Bali Province. The data on subak sustainabilityExpand
...
1
2
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 49 REFERENCES
Emergent Properties of Balinese Water Temple Networks: Coadaptation on a Rugged Fitness Landscape
For over a thousand years, generations of Balinese farmers have gradually transformed the landscape of their island, clearing forests, digging irrigation canals, and terracing hillsides to enableExpand
A robust budding model of Balinese water temple networks
Abstract Ethnohistory, genetics and simulation are used to propose a new ‘budding model’ to describe the historical processes by which complex irrigation communities may come into existence. WeExpand
Niche construction on Bali: the gods of the countryside
  • J. Lansing, K. M. Fox
  • Biology, Medicine
  • Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
  • 2011
TLDR
The creation of the engineered landscape of Balinese rice terraces offers a test case to investigate whether this phenomenon emerged historically from trial and error by generations of farmers, or alternatively was designed by Bali's rulers. Expand
On Modeling Balinese Water Temple Networks as Complex Adaptive Systems
adaptive systems has enabled him to develop a computer simulation model that represents the likely evolution of cooperative networks of Balinese rice farmers.2 Lansing attributes both theoretical andExpand
Land Donations and the Gift of Water. On Temple Landlordism and Irrigation Agriculture in Pre-Colonial Bali
TLDR
From a socio-political and economic perspective the implications of this form of temple landlordism and its combination with ritual water control, particularly for the peasants and the portion of their annual surplus that they were obliged to deliver to this temple are explored. Expand
A DNA signature for the expansion of irrigation in Bali
Archaeologists infer changes in social structure indirectly from the distribution of artifacts in space. But the chain of assumptions required for such inferences can sometimes become tenuous.Expand
Dams and Dynasty, and the Colonial Transformation of Balinese Irrigation Management
TLDR
This article takes issue with Stephen Lansing’s bottom-up model of Balinese irrigation management and argues that in pre-colonial days large scale irrigation depended largely on dynastic involvement. Expand
The precolonial Balinese state reconsidered: A critical evaluation of theory construction on the relationship between irrigation, the state, and ritual
The social organization of irrigation agriculture is an important part of many theories of the origin of the state. Ever since Marx described the organization and control of irrigation agriculture asExpand
Cooperation, Games, and Ecological Feedback: Some Insights from Bali1
For centuries Balinese rice farmers have been engaged in cooperative agricultural practices (Christie 1992; Scarborough, Schoenfelder, and Lansing 1999, 2000). This remarkable achievement inExpand
Balinese Babad as historical sources - a reinterpretation of the fall of Gelgel
Towards the end of the seventeenth century, the centralized Balinese kingdom of G?lg?l, which according to Balinese tradition had held sway since the fourteenth century, was overthrown. It wasExpand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...