The First Computational Theory of Mind and Brain: A Close Look at Mcculloch and Pitts's “Logical Calculus of Ideas Immanent in Nervous Activity”

  title={The First Computational Theory of Mind and Brain: A Close Look at Mcculloch and Pitts's “Logical Calculus of Ideas Immanent in Nervous Activity”},
  author={Gualtiero Piccinini},
Despite its significance in neuroscience and computation, McCulloch and Pitts's celebrated 1943 paper has received little historical and philosophical attention. In 1943 there already existed a lively community of biophysicists doing mathematical work on neural networks. What was novel in McCulloch and Pitts's paper was their use of logic and computation to understand neural, and thus mental, activity. McCulloch and Pitts's contributions included (i) a formalism whose refinement and… Expand
70th Anniversary of Publication: Warren McCulloch & Walter Pitts - A Logical Calculus of the Ideas Immanent in Nervous Activity
In 1943, a paper by Warren McCulloch & Walter Pitts [6] entitled “A logical calculus of the ideas immanent to nervous activity“ was published, which is now considered as one of the seminal papersExpand
Your Brain Is Like a Computer: Function, Analogy, Simplification
It is argued that much of the popularity of the brain-computer comparison can be explained by their utility as ways of simplifying the brain, and that the relation between brain and computer should be understood as one of analogy. Expand
Walter Pitts and “A Logical Calculus”
Details regarding Pitts’s interest in problems of circularity, regenerative activity in closed loops of neurons, and modular mathematics, and the way in which they relate to “A Logical Calculus” are filled in. Expand
Computation in cognitive science: it is not all about Turing-equivalent computation
Abstract It is sometimes suggested that the history of computation in cognitive science is one in which the formal apparatus of Turing-equivalent computation, or effective computability, was exportedExpand
  • 2005
Andy Clark is perhaps best known for his defense of an embodied philosophy of mind: cognition—and the mind more broadly—cannot be properly understood without a deep recognition of the role played byExpand
The Computational Theory of Cognition
Cognitive capacities are explained by the processing of spike trains by neuronal populations, and the processingof spike trains is a kind of computation that is interestingly different from both digital computation and analog computation. Expand
OF THE DISSERTATION On the Matter of Memory: Neural Computation and the Mechanisms of Intentional Agency by ALEXANDER D. MORGAN Dissertation Directors: Frances Egan & Robert Matthews Humans and otherExpand
Does the Principle of Computational Equivalence Overcome the Objections against Computationalism
Computationalism has been variously defined as the idea that the human mind can be modelled by means of mechanisms broadly equivalent to Turing Machines. Computationalism’s claims have been hotlyExpand
Rudolf Carnap–The Grandfather of Artificial Neural Networks: The Influence of Carnap’s Philosophy on Walter Pitts
The importance and relevance of philosophy for the development of the AI is often neglected. By revealing the influence of Rudolf Carnap on Warren McCulloch’s and especially Walter Pitts’ work onExpand
The notion of computation is fundamental to an autonomous neuroscience
This commentary will show how the notion of computation in neuroscience differs from that of other fields that investigate complex systems and argue that computation at various levels of neural organization is the paramount goal of neuroscientific explanation. Expand


Integrating mind and brain: Warren S. McCulloch, cerebral localization, and experimental epistemology.
Warren S. McCulloch's early laboratory work during the 1930s addressed the problem of cerebral localization: localizing aspects of behaviour in the cerebral cortex of the brain, and can be expressed as a search for a physiological a priori, an integrated mechanism of sensation. Expand
From Logical Neurons to Poetic Embodiments of Mind: Warren S. McCulloch’s Project in Neuroscience
  • L. E. Kay
  • Medicine, Psychology
  • Science in Context
  • 2001
It is argued that the neural nets project of Warren S. McCulloch, in frequent collaboration with Walter Pitts, spearheaded this cognitivist turn in the 1940s, and his work within a larger historical trend, when cybernetics, information theory, systems theories, and electronic computers were coalescing into a new science of communication and control with enormous potential for industrial automation and military power in the Cold War era. Expand
Logical neurons: the enigmatic legacy of Warren McCulloch
  • D. Perkel
  • Psychology, Medicine
  • Trends in Neurosciences
  • 1988
The intellectual legacy of McCulloch is examined, in the light of the current recrudescence of his ideas and programs, and certain branches of his work have flourished mightily, but others have withered. Expand
Computations and Computers in the Sciences of Mind and Brain
This dissertation is divided into a historical part which traces the early history of computationalism up to 1946, and a philosophical part, which offers an account of computing mechanisms, which can be used to identify computing mechanisms and the functions they compute. Expand
Warren McCulloch's Search for the Logic of the Nervous System
  • M. Arbib
  • Philosophy, Medicine
  • Perspectives in biology and medicine
  • 2000
Warren Sturgis McCulloch was concerned with computer technology, as is reflected in his concerns for reliable computing from unreliable neuronlike elements and for redundant, distributed computing by larger modules, but throughout his life he was driven less by the demands of technology than by the quest to understand how the authors think. Expand
Embodiments of Mind
Preface by Jerome Y. LettvinWarren S. McCulloch was an original thinker, in many respects far ahead of his time. "Of all our contemporaries in brain research McCulloch is the most personal,Expand
(Physio)logical circuits: the intellectual origins of the McCulloch-Pitts neural networks.
  • Tara H. Abraham
  • Sociology, Medicine
  • Journal of the history of the behavioral sciences
  • 2002
Examining the intellectual backgrounds of McCulloch and Pitts as individuals will show that besides being an important event in the history of cybernetics proper, the McCulloch-Pitts collaboration was an important result of early twentieth-century efforts to apply mathematics to neurological phenomena. Expand
Discussion: McCulloch-Pitts and related neural nets from 1943 to 1989
The McCulloch-Pitts neuron is an extremely simplified representation of neural properties, based simply on the existence of a threshold for the activation of an action potential. Expand
The Computational Brain
The Computational Brain addresses the foundational ideas of the emerging field of computational neuroscience, examines a diverse range of neural network models, and considers future directions of the field. Expand
Is the Church-Turing thesis true?
It is argued that mundane procedures can be said to be effective in the same sense in which Turing machine procedures can been said toBe effective, and that mundane Procedures differ from Turing machine Procedures in a fundamental way, viz., the former, but not the latter, generate causal processes. Expand