The Ethics of Eliminating Harmful Species: The Case of the Tsetse Fly

@article{Bouyer2019TheEO,
  title={The Ethics of Eliminating Harmful Species: The Case of the Tsetse Fly},
  author={J{\'e}r{\'e}my Bouyer and Neil H. Carter and Chelsea Batavia and Michael Paul Nelson},
  journal={Bioscience},
  year={2019},
  volume={69},
  pages={125 - 135}
}
Abstract Wildlife species harmful to humans are often targets of control and elimination programs. A contemporary example is the tsetse fly, a vector of sleeping sickness and African animal trypanosomosis. Tsetse flies have recently been targeted by a pan-African eradication campaign. If it is successful, the campaign could push the entire tsetse family to extinction. With the emergence of effective and efficient elimination technologies, ethical assessment of proposed elimination campaigns is… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Environmental impact of tsetse eradication in Senegal
TLDR
It is shown that the eradication campaign had very limited impacts on the apparent densities of the most frequent species as well as three diversity indexes during the reduction phase involving insecticides but reverted to pre-intervention levels as soon as the release of the sterile male insects started.
Epidemiology of tsetse flies in the transmission of trypanosomiasis: technical review of The Gambia experience
Climate change has posed serious health threats on both man and animals. This ranges from effects of progressive temperature rises from global warming to extreme weather events and anthropogenic
The impact of vector migration on the effectiveness of strategies to control gambiense human African trypanosomiasis
TLDR
The results suggest that the WHO 2030 goal of G-HAT elimination is, at least in theory, achievable, but the presence of tsetse migration may reduce the probability of interrupting g-H AT transmission in moderate and high transmission foci.
Big Baby, Little Mother: Tsetse Flies Are Exceptions to the Juvenile Small Size Principle
TLDR
It is suggested that the extreme reproductive strategy of tsetse is enabled by feeding solely on highly nutritious blood, and producing larval offspring that are soft and malleable, and warrants their preservation in the areas where human and animal health is not threatened.
Human African trypanosomiasis: current status and eradication efforts.
TLDR
Despite the progress, the danger of disease resurgence is well-known for HAT and continued surveillance and treatment availability is essential, and many uncertainties regarding HAT transmission remain and combine to make potential disease eradication a complete unknown.
The potential economic benefits of controlling trypanosomiasis using waterbuck repellent blend in sub-Saharan Africa
TLDR
The WRB is a new technology that pushes trypanosomiasis-transmitting tsetse fly away from animals, improving animals’ health and increasing meat and milk productivity, and the benefits suggest that investing in WRB can contribute to nutrition security and sustainable development goals.
In defence of the world’s most reviled invertebrate ‘bugs’
  • E. Small
  • Environmental Science
    Biodiversity
  • 2019
TLDR
This paper shows that most invertebrate species highlighted have at least some compensating values, their harm has often been exaggerated and all have related species that are good citizens, and to improve invertebrates conservation it is advisable that efforts be made to educate the public regarding their importance.
Sustainable Elimination (Zero Cases) of Sleeping Sickness: How Far Are We from Achieving This Goal?
TLDR
The available resources are examined and recommendations for improvement are made to ensure the sustenance of the already achieved gains to keep the trend moving towards elimination of HAT.
Staff Joint FAO/IAEA Division of Nuclear Applications in Food and Agriculture Insect Pest Control Subprogramme
TLDR
A newly concep-tualised tool, the ‘Kamikaze Wasp Technique’ (KWT), which uses a novel combination of CBC and SIT in an eradication to avoid impacts on non-target organisms is described.
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 84 REFERENCES
Tsetse Flies in Africa: Bane or Boon?
: This paper examines the changing perception of the role of the tsetse fly in the development of tropical Africa. The trypanosomiases transmitted by this group of vector insects historically
License to Kill?—Disease Eradication Programs May Not be in Line with the Convention on Biological Diversity
TLDR
The conflicts between biodiversity conservation and disease eradication are discussed, and a strong consideration of environmental issues is argued for when applying vector control measures, especially the aerial applications of insecticides.
Treating Cattle to Protect People? Impact of Footbath Insecticide Treatment on Tsetse Density in Chad
TLDR
The impact of footbath treatment as a vector control tool within an integrated strategy to manage AAT and HAT is discussed in the framework of the “One Health” concept.
Is vector control needed to eliminate gambiense human African trypanosomiasis?
TLDR
Human African Trypanosomiasis, or sleeping sickness, is a neglected tropical parasitic disease of humans due to trypanosomes transmitted by tsetse flies in sub-Saharan Africa and treatment is still long and difficult to administer despite recent improvements.
Aiming to eliminate tsetse from Africa.
  • J. Kabayo
  • Medicine, Biology
    Trends in parasitology
  • 2002
The Atlas of human African trypanosomiasis: a contribution to global mapping of neglected tropical diseases
TLDR
Although efforts are still needed to reduce the number of undetected and unreported cases, the comprehensive, village-level mapping of HAT control activities over a ten-year period ensures a detailed and reliable representation of the known geographic distribution of the disease.
...
...