The East Asian Challenge for Democracy: Political Meritocracy In Comparative Perspective

  title={The East Asian Challenge for Democracy: Political Meritocracy In Comparative Perspective},
  author={Daniel A. Bell and Chenyang Li},
Part I. The Theory of Political Meritocracy: 1. Political meritocracy and meritorious rule: a Confucian perspective Joseph Chan 2. A Confucian version of hybrid regime: how does it work and why is it superior? Tongdong Bai 3. Confucian meritocracy for contemporary China Ruiping Fan 4. The liberal critique of democracy John Skorupski 5. Meritocratic representation Philip Pettit Part II. The History of Political Meritocracy: 6. Between merit and pedigree: evolution of the concept of 'elevating… 
Can meritocracy replace democracy? A conceptual framework
Influenced by the example of China, a literature is emerging that advocates a modernized version of Confucian meritocracy, often as an alternative to liberal democracy and even democracy itself. We
Political meritocracy and its betrayal
  • F. Mang
  • Political Science, Sociology
  • 2020
Some Confucian scholars have recently claimed that Confucian political meritocracy is superior to Western democracy. I have great reservations about such a view. In this article, I argue that so long
More than good executives: The teaching mission of Confucian political leaders
Emboldened by the rise of China, a meritocratic trend has surged in recent Confucian political theory. Confucian meritocracy is upheld as an equally viable alternative, if not a superior one, to
Political participation as self-cultivation: Towards a participatory theory of Confucian democracy
Challenging the popular perception that Confucianism provides mostly a moral defense of political hierarchy, this article demonstrates that Confucianism is more than compatible with democracy and
Towards an Analytical Framework of Constitutionalism in East Asia: The Case of Taiwan
  • Chien-Chih Lin
  • Sociology
    Economics, Law, and Institutions in Asia Pacific
  • 2019
Recent years have witnessed the reemergence of discussions on Confucian constitutionalism, communitarian constitutionalism, and Asian values. Despite the differences of these concepts, all reject
Towards Confucian democratic meritocracy
In the past two decades, Confucian meritocrats have justified the unequal distribution of political power by appeal to the ideal of Confucian virtue politics. In this article, I demonstrate that at
Liberal democracy as the end of history
A growing number of political scientists have recently advocated the theses that democracy has emerged as a universal value and that it is also becoming the universally preferred system of
Do People in East Asia Truly Prefer Democracy to its Alternatives ? Western Theories versus East Asian Realities
What type of political systems do people in East Asia truly prefer most? Is it democracy, as the Western theses of universal and liberal democratization suggest? If this is not the case, what other
Pragmatic Confucian Democracy: Rethinking the Value of Democracy in East Asia
  • Sungmoon Kim
  • Political Science, Sociology
    The Journal of Politics
  • 2017
In contemporary Confucian political theory, there is surprisingly little effort among the theorists to illuminate the value of democracy. When they do on rare occasions, their focus is largely on
Confucian Democracy in East Asia: Theory and Practice
Part I. Beyond Thick Confucian Communitarianism and Meritocratic Elitism: 1. The Confucian social self and its discontent 2. Toward civil Confucianism 3. Against meritocratic elitism Part II. A