The Death of Vitalism and The Birth of Organic Chemistry: Wohler's Urea Synthesis and the Disciplinary Identity of Organic Chemistry

@article{Ramberg2000TheDO,
  title={The Death of Vitalism and The Birth of Organic Chemistry: Wohler's Urea Synthesis and the Disciplinary Identity of Organic Chemistry},
  author={Peter J. Ramberg},
  journal={Ambix},
  year={2000},
  volume={47},
  pages={170 - 195}
}
Cet article est une etude exploratoire non exhaustive des origines et de l'histoire mythique de Wohler et de sa synthese d'uree. L'auteur montre l'introduction de cette histoire aux manuels de chimie organique et le role important qu'il a joue dans le maintien et la progression de cette discipline. 
From the Dawn of Organic Chemistry to Astrobiology: Urea as a Foundational Component in the Origin of Nucleobases and Nucleotides
TLDR
This chapter provides a historical perspective on the prebiotic chemistry of urea, from Wohler’s synthesis in the early nineteenth century to the most recent works.
The Return of Vitalism: Canguilhem, Bergson and the Project of a Biophilosophy
The eminent French biologist and historian of biology Francois Jacob once notoriously declared, “On n’interroge plus la vie dans les laboratoires” (Jacob, La logique du vivant, discussed in
The New Identity of Chemistry as Biomimetic and Nano- science
This paper aims at characterising the distinct features of the recent trends of biomimetic chemistry within the long tradition of chemistry challenging nature through the artificial creation of life.
Prebiotic Chemistry and Chemical Evolution of Nucleic Acids
TLDR
Over the last 65 years, many potentially prebiotic synthetic mechanisms have been experimentally demonstrated for nucleobases, and their presence in extraterrestrial materials has been extensively verified, suggesting some of these are valid explanations for how the environment produces them.
Recent advances in urea- and thiourea-containing compounds: focus on innovative approaches in medicinal chemistry and organic synthesis.
TLDR
An overview of the state-of-the-art of urea and thiourea-containing pharmaceuticals is provided and the diverse approaches pursued for (thio)urea bioisosteric replacements in medicinal chemistry applications are reviewed.
Grasping the nature of the cell interior: from Physiological Chemistry to Chemical Biology
TLDR
It is called for interdisciplinary collaboration in grappling with the complex cell interior, starting from the vitalist framework established by early natural philosophers and extracting important lessons for the bioinspired chemists of today.
Synthesis and Biosynthesis of Polyketide Natural Products
Traditionally separate disciplines of a large and broad chemical spectrum, synthetic organic chemistry and biochemistry have found in the last two decades a fertile common ground in the area
Static to Dynamic: Kazan Chemists and the Transformation from Chemical Structure to Reaction Regiochemistry.
During the sesquicentennial of the first publication of Markovnikov's Rule, it is appropriate to re-visit the development of A. M. Butlerov's version of the theory of chemical structure, and its
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 63 REFERENCES
Wöhler's ‘Synthetic’ Urea and the Rejection of Vitalism: A Chemical Legend
THAT Wöhler synthetized urea in 1828 and there by rang the death-knell of vitalism in organic chemistry seems to be as firmly established a legend as that Galileo let fall at one and the same time
Wohler's preparation of urea and the fate of vitalism
Organic chemistry as we know it was not immediately established with Wohler's preparation of urea, nor was it solely responsible for overthrowing vitalistic doctrine.
Wöhler's Synthesis of Urea: How Do the Textbooks Report It?
Most general chemistry and organic chemistry textbooks describe Friedrich Wohler's synthesis of urea as the moment when modern organic chemistry was born. We surveyed 35 modern and classic texts to
Organic Synthesis and the Unification of Chemistry—A Reappraisal
  • J. Brooke
  • History
    The British Journal for the History of Science
  • 1971
Proclaiming Louis Pasteur as the “Founder of Stereochemistry”, the distinguished Scottish chemist, Crum Brown, addressing a late nineteenth-century audience of Edinburgh savants, drew attention—as
The Rise and Development of Organic Chemistry
FOR some time this excellent historical survey of the development of organic chemistry has been out of print, and students of chemistry will heartily welcome the appearance of a second edition, which
The Quiet Revolution: Hermann Kolbe and the Science of Organic Chemistry
Organic chemist Hermann Kolbe (1818-1884) is the subject of this vigorously contextualized biography, which combines the approaches of cognitive and social history of science. Kolbe was one of the
An Introduction to Organic Chemistry
THE book provides an admirable general introduction to the subject and will commend itself both to student and teacher for its simplicity of approach. The latter is achieved by concentrating
Principles of Organic Chemistry
THE author states, in the preface that the object of this book is to provide a course in organic chemistry which a student may be expected to cover in about three years from starting the subject, and
Basic principles of organic chemistry
Introduction what is organic chemistry all about?; Structural organic chemistry the shapes of molecules functional groups; Organic nomenclature; Alkanes; Stereoisomerism of organic molecules; Bonding
...
...