The Confused Compass: From Self-determination to State-determination

@article{Abulof2015TheCC,
  title={The Confused Compass: From Self-determination to State-determination},
  author={Uriel Abulof},
  journal={Ethnopolitics},
  year={2015},
  volume={14},
  pages={488 - 497}
}
  • Uriel Abulof
  • Published 11 August 2015
  • Political Science
  • Ethnopolitics
Abstract Self-determination, a prime justificatory principle of the international society, has become a confused, and confusing, compass. At the heart of this confusion, I argue, lies the tacit submersion of self-determination in state-determination. In principle, self-determination entails the ‘moral double helix' of duality (personal right to align with a people, and the people’s right to determine their politics) and mutuality (the right is as much the other’s as the self’s). In practice… 
View on Taylor & Francis
8 Citations
Background Citations
4
Methods Citations
1

8 Citations

Taming self-determination: The trials of a political speech-act

The right of peoples to self-determination lies at the heart of the modern quest for statehood. This century-old principle warrants a world of true nation-states, where national boundaries make state…

We the peoples? The strange demise of self-determination

The self-determination of peoples is a fundamental legitimating principle of the international system; it justifies the system’s very existence. Through a vast diachronic corpus and pertinent data…

Beyond self-determination: norms contestation, constituent diplomacies and the co-production of sovereignty

Abstract: The idea of a perfect national political community, entirely confined within the contours of a corresponding state, is one of the foundational fictions of global modernity. Its formal…

The criteria for self determination and recognition as a sovereign state: Case of Kosovo

Self-determination is a controversial issue in public international relations as well as in international law. The rise of groups of people in different geographical locations of the world, seeking…

The Right to Secession: Remedial or Primary?

Abstract The Scottish referendum, and the Kurdish and Catalan endeavours to organise unilateral independence referenda has made secession, once again, a prominent political issue. Understanding what…

Nationalism as legitimation: the appeal of ethnicity and the plea for popular sovereignty

Making Prussians, Raising Germans: A Cultural History of Prussian State-Building after Civil War, 1866-1935

National Self-determination in Times of Shared Sovereignty: Goals and Principles from Catalonia to Europe in the 21st Century

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 59 REFERENCES

The self-determination trap

Abstract This article deconstructs the classical doctrine of self-determination, asserting that it serves to disenfranchise populations, instead of enfranchising them. Accordingly, self-determination…

The right to self-determination in international politics: six theories in search of a policy

  • M. Freeman
  • Political Science
    Review of International Studies
  • 1999
The principle of the self-determination of peoples is enshrined in the United Nations Charter and based on liberal and democratic values. However, the international community has, until recently,…

G.W.F. Hegel on Self‐Determination and Democratic Theory

This article claims that the major alternative models of contemporary democratic theory—the aggregative, deliberative, and agonistic models—are grounded on a norm of self-determination, but each…

A critical analysis of the self-determination of peoples: a cosmopolitan perspective

Over the last few years, the demand for the self-determination of peoples has once more acquired considerable force. In consolidated states no less than in states that are falling apart, more or less…

Transcendence: On Self-Determination and Cosmopolitanism

Notions of self-determination are central to modern politics, yet the relationship between the self-determination of individuals and peoples has not been adequately addressed, nor adequately allied…

Sovereignty, Nationalism, and Self-Determination

Sovereignty, we are repeatedly told, is not what it used to be. Indeed, according to Professor Falk, the concept is in such deep trouble that its use should be left to politicians but discarded in…

International Law and Self-Determination:The Interplay of the Politics of Territorial Possession with Formulations of Post-Colonial National Identity

he principle of self-determination has at heart the achievement of true representation and democracy based on the idea that the consent of the governed alone can give government legitimacy. The…

Escaping the Self-Determination Trap

Preface Acknowledgements I. Introduction II. A Concept with Multiple Meanings III. The Classical Right to Self-determination IV. Constitutional Self-determination V. Remedial Self-determination VI.…

Territorial integrity and the right to self-determination: an examination of the conceptual tools

he determination and demarcation of fixed territories and the subsequent allegiance between those territories and the individuals or groups of individuals that inhabit them is arguably the prime…

The Wilsonian Moment: Self-Determination and the International Origins of Anticolonial Nationalism

During the Paris Peace Conference of 1919, while key decisions were debated by the victorious Allied powers, a multitude of smaller nations and colonies held their breath, waiting to see how their…
...