The Comprehensive System for the Rorschach: A Critical Examination

@article{Wood1996TheCS,
  title={The Comprehensive System for the Rorschach: A Critical Examination},
  author={James M Wood and M. Teresa Nezworski and William J. Stejskal},
  journal={Psychological Science},
  year={1996},
  volume={7},
  pages={10 - 3}
}
The Comprehensive System (Exner, 1993) is widely accepted as a reliable and valid approach to Rorschach interpretation However, the present article calls attention to significant problems with the system First, contrary to common opinion, the interrater reliability of most scores in the system has never been demonstrated adequately Second, important scores and indices in the system are of questionable validity Third, the research base of the system consists mainly of unpublished studies that… 

The reliability of the comprehensive system for the Rorschach: A comment on Meyer (1997)

Elsewhere the authors have called attention to fundamental problems with the Comprehensive System for the Rorschach (CS). G. Meyer (1997) attempts to refute the authors' criticisms of CS interrater

The Rorschach A Comprehensive System

The Rorschach-John E. Exner 2005 For the last three decades, Dr. John Exner's Comprehensive System has been the leading approach worldwide to administering and interpreting the Rorschach Inkblot

Interobserver Agreement, Intraobserver Reliability, and the Rorschach Comprehensive System

TLDR
Reliability was analyzed at multiple levels of Comprehensive System data, including response-level individual codes and coding decisions and ratios, percentages, and derivations from the Structural Summary.

Temporal Stability in the Rorschach Method : A Meta-Analytic Review

TLDR
The temporal stabilities of the Rorschach method scoring systems were investigated, and the Comprehensive System consistently shows higher stability than other systems, whereas increasing retest intervals leads to decreasing stability.

Field Reliability of Comprehensive System Scoring in an Adolescent Inpatient Sample

TLDR
The reliability of both response-level codes and protocol-level scores among 84 adolescent psychiatric inpatients in a clinical setting is evaluated, indicating reliable scoring is possible even in field settings.

Thinking Clearly About Reliability: More Critical Corrections Regarding the Rorschach Comprehensive System

  • J.
  • Psychology
  • 2001
In this brief comment on J. M. Wood, M. T. Nezworski, and W. J. Stejskal's (1997) response to his article (Meyer, 1997a), the author documents how J. M. Wood et al. continue to make allegations based

Thinking clearly about reliability: More critical corrections regarding the Rorschach Comprehensive System.

In this brief comment on J. M. Wood, M. T. Nezworski, and W. J. Stejskal's (1997) response to his article (Meyer, 1997a), the author documents how J. M. Wood et al. continue to make allegations based

An Overview of the Rorschach Performance Assessment System (R-PAS)

We provide an overview of the Rorschach Performance Assessment System (R-PAS; Meyer, Viglione, Mihura, Erard, & Erdberg, 2011). After providing a general introduction to Rorschach-based assessment,

The validity of individual Rorschach variables: systematic reviews and meta-analyses of the comprehensive system.

TLDR
The findings are less positive, more nuanced, and more inclusive than those reported in the CS test manual, and the implications for research and clinical practice, including the importance of using different methods in order to improve the understanding of people.

Narcissism in the Comprehensive System for the Rorschach

The Egocentricity Index (ECOI) is the oldest clinical index in the Comprehensive System for the Rorschach. According to Exner's 1993 edition of The Rorschach: A Comprehensive System the ECOI,
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 51 REFERENCES

A conceptual critique of the EA:es comparison in the Comprehensive Rorschach System.

Despite its empirical and normative strengths, the underlying conceptual base of the Comprehensive Rorschach System at times lacks clarity and an overarching theory of personality that can help

Narcissism in the Comprehensive System for the Rorschach

The Egocentricity Index (ECOI) is the oldest clinical index in the Comprehensive System for the Rorschach. According to Exner's 1993 edition of The Rorschach: A Comprehensive System the ECOI,

Combining the Rorschach and the MMPI in the assessment of adolescents.

TLDR
E empirical findings related to the integration of the Rorschach and the MMPI in assessing adolescents leave open the possibility that combining data from the two instruments may increase incremental validity, an issue that should be assessed by using multivariate analyses.

Response frequency problems in the rorschach: clinical and research implications with suggestions for the future.

  • G. Meyer
  • Psychology
    Journal of personality assessment
  • 1992
TLDR
Clinical and research problems associated with response frequency (R) being a variable in the Rorschach are focused on to more thoroughly determine whether R measures anything of substantial clinical importance and to evaluate systematically the relative merits of making R a constant rather than a variable through use of an R-controlled method of RORSchach administration.

Rorschach Depression indices with children and adolescents: concurrent validity findings.

TLDR
There were no significant relationships between the original form and the revised form of the DEPI and clinical elevations on the Depression scale of the Personality Inventory for Children in the outpatient sample or treatment team diagnostic judgments in the inpatient sample.

R in Rorschach research: a ghost revisited.

  • J. Exner
  • Psychology
    Journal of personality assessment
  • 1992
TLDR
Although the issue of R can be critical when some variables are included in a data matrix, most analyses can proceed without partialing or normalization, and intercorrelations between R and most parametric Rorschach variables are not significant among groups of nonpatients, schizophrenia, and depressives.

A Coefficient of Agreement for Nominal Scales

CONSIDER Table 1. It represents in its formal characteristics a situation which arises in the clinical-social-personality areas of psychology, where it frequently occurs that the only useful level of

Usefulness of structural Rorschach data in identifying inpatients with depressive symptoms: a preliminary study.

TLDR
Results indicated that the Comprehensive System, Rorschach Depression Index did not identify many of these individuals as depressed, but did identify most of the extratensive depressed individuals.

Incremental Validity : a Recommendation

distinction is to be made between convergent and discriminant validity. It is necessary to demonstrate not only that a measure covaries with certain other connotatively similar variables, but that

Reporting Errors in Studies of the Diagnostic Performance of Self-Administered Questionnaires: Extent of the Problem, Recommendations for Standardized Presentation of Results, and Implications for the Peer Review Process.

TLDR
In reviewing the literature on the performance of self-report questionnaires to screen for depression, it is found errors in several published articles in which these statistics were computed.
...