The Collective Construction of Scientific Memory: The Einstein-Poincaré Connection and its Discontents, 1905–2005

@article{Gingras2008TheCC,
  title={The Collective Construction of Scientific Memory: The Einstein-Poincar{\'e} Connection and its Discontents, 1905–2005},
  author={Yves Gingras},
  journal={History of Science},
  year={2008},
  volume={46},
  pages={114 - 75}
}
  • Y. Gingras
  • Published 1 March 2008
  • Physics
  • History of Science
One of the side effects of commemorations is often to reactivate old debates that had been forgotten or were lying dormant. While this is obvious for political commemorations, it is no less true of scientific ones, and the UNESCO international year of physics in 2005, celebrating Einstein’s annus mirabilis of 1905, revived the old ghost of Poincare’s contribution to relativity. In this context of contested memories, Olivier Darrigol proposed a kind of “peace treaty” on the basis that “it seems… 

Figures and Tables from this paper

Whittaker, Einstein, and the History of the Aether: Alternative interpretation, blunder, or bigotry?
  • J. Navarro
  • Physics
    History of science; an annual review of literature, research and teaching
  • 2020
TLDR
New light is shed on this controversy by taking into consideration the abundant correspondence between Whittaker and his son preserved in the archives of the Fisher Library, University of Toronto, and shows that the problematic status quo of general relativity in the early 1950s was very influential in the historical treatment he gave to Einstein.
Voigt transformations in retrospect: missed opportunities?
The teaching of modern physics often uses the history of physics as a didactic tool. However, as in this process the history of physics is not something studied but used, there is a danger that the
Revisiting the “Quiet Debut” of the Double Helix: A Bibliometric and Methodological note on the “Impact” of Scientific Publications
  • Y. Gingras
  • Computer Science
    Journal of the history of biology
  • 2010
TLDR
How large scale bibliometric data can be used in a sophisticated manner to provide information about the dynamic of the scientific field as a whole instead of limiting the analysis to a few major actors and generalizing the result to the whole community is shown.
One more essay on the Einstein-Poincaré priority dispute
It is not surprising that reading today a paper written more than a hundred years ago, we can extract much more of it than was actually thought or dreamed by the author himself. We demonstrate this
Reflections on the concept of ‘precursor’: Juan de Vilanova and the discovery of Altamira
Considering the case of Juan de Vilanova y Piera, often celebrated as the first scientist to accept the prehistoric antiquity of palaeolithic paintings, we explore some of the problems related to the
Naming without Necessity
The recent discussions on the label “historical epistemology” provide us with an interesting example of branding of concepts, ideas and methods. Given this recent interest in the meaning of the
A comparison between qualitative and quantitative histories: the example of the efficient market hypothesis
ABSTRACT This paper uses the example of the history of the efficient market hypothesis (EMH) and citation analysis in order to investigate some differences between qualitative history and a
L’historien dans la Cité : l’objectivation contre l’instrumentalisation
Citer cet article Gingras, Y. (2014). L’historien dans la Cité : l’objectivation contre l’instrumentalisation. Bulletin d'histoire politique, 22(3), 265–286. https://doi.org/10.7202/1024160ar Ce
Du mauvais usage de faux indicateurs
Depuis quelques ann?es, le monde acad?mique europ?en semble atteint d'une v?ritable fi?vre d'?valuation de la recherche et des universit?s. En France en particulier, la Loi sur l'autonomie des
Laurent schwartz (1915-2002) et la vie collective des mathématiques
Ce travail se saisit de la figure de Laurent Schwartz (1915-2002) pour etudier la vie collective des mathematiques dans la seconde moitie du XXeme siecle.Il vise a montrer comment les pratiques
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 124 REFERENCES
Henri Poincaré : The Movie. The Unintended Consequences of Scientific Commemorations
We have become accustomed to the outbreak of “memory wars” at commemorations of major political events that are perceived as foundations of a national identity (the American Civil War, the French
Focus: the elusive icon: Einstein, 1905-2005. Introduction.
  • P. Galison
  • Art
    Isis; an international review devoted to the history of science and its cultural influences
  • 2004
TLDR
Einstein remains and will remain a magnet for historians, philosophers, and scientists; the essays assembled here represent a strong sampling--but only a sampling--of a fascinating new generation of work on this perennial figure.
Einstein's Jury: The Race to Test Relativity
'I know very well that my theory rests on a shaky foundation. What attracts me to it is that it leads to consequences that seem to be accessible to experiment, and it provides a starting point for
ORIGIN AND CONCEPT OF RELATIVITY (PARTS I AND II): REPLY TO PROFESSOR DINGLE AND MR LEVINSON
  • G. H. Keswani
  • Philosophy
    The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
  • 1966
which is both undeniably true and undeniably algebraic. The difference between I and (Re) is hardly noticeable in English, and this explains Professor Mackie's intuitive conviction that I is true.
Constructing a ‘revolution in science’: the campaign to promote a favourable reception for the 1919 solar eclipse experiments
A patriot fiddler-composer of Luton Wrote a funeral march which he played with the mute on, To record, as he said, that a Jewish-Swiss-Teuton Had partially scrapped the Principia of Newton. Punch, 19
Poincaré’s Relativistic Physics: Its Origins and Nature
Abstract.Henri Poincaré (1854–1912) developed a relativistic physics by elevating the empirical inability to detect absolute motion, or motion relative to the ether, to the principle of relativity,
On the Histories of Relativity: The Propagation and Elaboration of Relativity Theory in Participant Histories in Germany, 1905-1911
This essay explores the history and historiography of relativity through a study of the earliest, participant, histories of the subject. The author argues that participant histories from Einstein,
Albert Einstein, 1879-1955
TLDR
Albert Einstein ceased to accept Judaism as a transcendental religion, while retaining its humanitarian principles, and was a keen Zionist and a Governor of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
Intimations Of Relativity Relativity Before Einstein
In this paper we try to disentangle the development of two connected strands of thought, associated respectively with Maxwell and Poincare, so as to throw light on several questions connected with
The Search for Autonomy in History of Science
In fall 1984, I had the good fortune to meet Sam Schweber when I arrived at Harvard University’s Department of History of Science as a visiting scholar with a postdoctoral fellowship from the Social
...
...