The Chinese Room Argument Reconsidered: Essentialism, Indeterminacy, and Strong AI

  title={The Chinese Room Argument Reconsidered: Essentialism, Indeterminacy, and Strong AI},
  author={Jerome C. Wakefield},
  journal={Minds and Machines},
I argue that John Searle's (1980) influential Chinese room argument (CRA) against computationalism and strong AI survives existing objections, including Block's (1998) internalized systems reply, Fodor's (1991b) deviant causal chain reply, and Hauser's (1997) unconscious content reply. However, a new ``essentialist'' reply I construct shows that the CRA as presented by Searle is an unsound argument that relies on a question-begging appeal to intuition. My diagnosis of the CRA relies on an… CONTINUE READING
Highly Cited
This paper has 25 citations. REVIEW CITATIONS


Publications referenced by this paper.
Showing 1-10 of 10 references

The Philosophy of Psychology: Classical Computationalism

  • N. Block
  • in A. C. Grayling,
  • 1998
Highly Influential
10 Excerpts

Minds, Brains, and Programs

  • J. R. Searle
  • Academic Publishers,
  • 1980
Highly Influential
10 Excerpts

Alan Turing: The Enigma, New York: Simon and Schuster. Pinker, S

  • A. Hodges
  • Machines
  • 1983
Highly Influential
3 Excerpts

The Rediscovery of Mind

  • J. R. Searle
  • 1992

Has Artificial Intelligence Research Illuminated Human Thinking ? ’

  • J. R. Searle, S. Papert
  • Annals of the New York City Academy of Arts and…
  • 1984

Fodor on inscrutability

  • J. C. Dissertation. Wakefield
  • Mind and Language. Wilks, Y
  • 1982

Similar Papers

Loading similar papers…