The Case of Paul Kammerer: Evolution and Experimentation in the Early 20th Century

@article{Gliboff2006TheCO,
  title={The Case of Paul Kammerer: Evolution and Experimentation
in the Early 20th Century},
  author={Sander Gliboff},
  journal={Journal of the History of Biology},
  year={2006},
  volume={39},
  pages={525-563}
}
To some, a misguided Lamarckian and a fraud, to others a martyr in the fight against Darwinism, the Viennese zoologist Paul Kammerer (1880–1926) remains one of the most controversial scientists of the early 20th century. Here his work is reconsidered in light of turn-of-the-century problems in evolutionary theory and experimental methodology, as seen from Kammerer’s perspective in Vienna. Kammerer emerges not as an opponent of Darwinism, but as one would-be modernizer of the 19th-century theory… Expand

Paper Mentions

Orthogenesis versus Darwinism
TLDR
The pre-history of the concepts of directed evolution is represented by treatises of the authors who worked in the first half of the nineteenth century, which contained ideas related to spontaneous evolution, constraints on variation and the similarity of lifecycles of species and those of individuals. Expand
Between holism and reductionism : organismic inheritance and neo-Kantian biological tradition in Britain and the USA, 1890-1940
Anglophone biology at the start of the twentieth century tends to be remembered as ambitiously reductionist. Yet it was also a time that saw the flourishing of a now largely forgotten Kantian Expand
Freud’s Lamarckism’ and the Politics of Racial Science
  • Eliza Slavet
  • Philosophy, Medicine
  • Journal of the history of biology
  • 2008
TLDR
This article re-contextualizes Sigmund Freud’s interest in the idea of the inheritance of acquired characteristics in terms of the socio-political connotations of Lamarckism and Darwinism in the 1930s and 1950s in a larger post-War cultural reaction against Communism and against any scientific concepts of race in the wake of World War II. Expand
Hermann J. Muller, Theodosius Dobzhansky, Leslie Clarence Dunn, and the Reaction to Lysenkoism in the United States
This article outlines the response of three U.S. geneticists—Hermann Muller, Theodosius Dobzhansky, and Leslie Dunn—to the anti-genetics campaign launched by the Soviet agronomist Trofim Lysenko. TheExpand
Paul Kammerer and epigenetics – a reappraisal of his experiments
TLDR
Although the exact contents of Kammerer’s writings remain controversial and must be regarded with caution, his writings need to be treated objectively and accurately to avoid historical record distortion and to render the performance of adequate replications of his experiments possible. Expand
An Epigenetic Perspective on the Midwife Toad Experiments of Paul Kammerer (1880–1926)
TLDR
A model of possible epigenetic mechanisms underlie parent-of-origin effects in Kammerer's experiments, an effect of parental sex on dominance that suggests authenticity in the midwife toad results. Expand
Alternatives to Darwinism in the Early Twentieth Century
Julian Huxley claimed that the period around 1900 experienced an ‘eclipse of Darwinism’ when natural selection was rejected in favour of alternative mechanisms of evolution. These included theExpand
Darwin without borders? Looking at 'generalised Darwinism' through the prism of the 'hourglass model'
This article critically analyzes the arguments of the 'generalized Darwinism' recently proposed for the analysis of social-economical systems. We argue that 'generalized Darwinism' is bothExpand
"Protoplasm...is soft wax in our hands": Paul Kammerer and the art of biological transformation.
TLDR
The Kammerer story shows a great deal about early 20th-century biology: the range of new ideas about heredity and variation, competing theories of biological and cultural evolution and their applications in eugenics, new kinds of laboratories and professional roles for biologists, and changing standards for documenting experimental results. Expand
Darwin without borders? Looking at ‘generalised Darwinism’ through the prism of the ‘hourglass model’
TLDR
This article critically analyzes the arguments of the ‘generalized Darwinism’ recently proposed for the analysis of social-economical systems and presents the vision of the history of evolutionary biology with the help of the‘hourglass model’ reflecting the internal dynamic of competing theories of evolution. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 92 REFERENCES
Neo-Lamarckian Experimentalism in America: Origins and Consequences
  • G. Cook
  • Biology, Medicine
  • The Quarterly Review of Biology
  • 1999
TLDR
The 1890s and the first decades of the twentieth century saw a vigorous debate about the mechanisms of evolutionary change and the importance of methodological and institutional innovation and theoretical pluralism to the progress of science is illustrated and underscored. Expand
Evolution: The Modern Synthesis
TLDR
This definitive edition brings one of the most important and successful scientific books of the twentieth century back into print and includes the entire text of the 1942 edition, Huxley's introduction to the 1963 second edition (which demonstrates his continuing command of the field), and the introduction tothe 1974 third edition, written by nine experts from different areas of evolutionary biology. Expand
The origins of Soviet genetics and the struggle with Lamarckism, 1922–1929
TLDR
As a separate branch of biology, genetics began to develop in the USSR only during the Soviet period, and Russian scientists made a valuable contribution to understanding the processes of fertilization, especially in plants. Expand
Prof. Paul Kammerer
I REGRET to have to announce the death of Prof. Dr. Paul Kammerer, who shot himself on the Hochschneeberg, near Vienna, on September 23. In a letter (received after his death) he accuses himself ofExpand
Morphology and twentieth-century biology: a response.
I am gratified to find that ideas I published a few years ago in Life Science in the Twentieth Century have stimulated a controversy about some important issues in the history of biology. In theExpand
Dr. Kammerer's Testimony to the Inheritance of Acquired Characters
TLDR
When the author was engaged in writing those chapters of his book, “Problems of Genetics” (1913), which deal with the effects of changed conditions in producing genetic variation, he endeavoured to form an opinion as to the validity of the cases usually claimed in recent years as having given positive results. Expand
Talking Of Modernity: The Viennese ‘Vortrag’ As Form
As part of his project to define the meaning of modernity in fin de siecle Vienna, Adolf Loos (1870–1933) held lectures in cities throughout Europe. Although the lecture represented an importantExpand
Shifting assumptions in American biology: Embryology, 1890–1910
TLDR
Historians of biology in particular have come increasirigly to adopt the view that scientific change has been rapid and discontinuous, though not all historians have adopted the view. Expand
E. W. MacBride's Lamarckian eugenics and its implications for the social construction of scientific knowledge.
  • P. Bowler
  • Sociology, Medicine
  • Annals of science
  • 1984
TLDR
It is suggested that MacBride's example shows that there are no intrinsic links between scientific theories and social views, and that those who insist on the social character of scientific knowledge must recognize that a theory may acquire different ideological links in different social environments. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...