The Asian Values Thesis Revisited: Evidence from the World Values Surveys

@article{Welzel2011TheAV,
  title={The Asian Values Thesis Revisited: Evidence from the World Values Surveys},
  author={Christian Welzel},
  journal={Japanese Journal of Political Science},
  year={2011},
  volume={12},
  pages={1 - 31}
}
  • C. Welzel
  • Published 21 February 2011
  • Economics, Sociology
  • Japanese Journal of Political Science
Abstract The thesis that ‘Asian’ cultures oppose the ‘Western’ emphasis on emancipative values and liberal democracy has mostly been criticized for its political instrumentality. By contrast, the empirical claim about most Asians’ dismissal of emancipative values and liberal democracy has not been tested on a broadly cross-cultural basis. Filling this gap, this article uses data from the World Values Surveys to put the values of Asian populations into global perspective. As a result, the… 
Popular Value Perceptions and Institutional Preference for Democracy in “Confucian” East Asia
Abstract:A democratic recession coupled with China’s rise has reopened the Asian values debate between modernizers in favor of Western liberal democracy and traditional adherents to Confucianism.
Road to good governance and modernization in Asia: ‘Asian values’ and/or democracy?
Democracy is often considered a constitutive part of ‘good governance’, especially under the auspices of Western hegemony. Asian leaders have posed ‘Asian values’ as an alternative to democracy.
Values Change and Support for Democracy in East Asia
  • Y. Zhai
  • Political Science
    Social Indicators Research
  • 2021
The Asian values thesis describes the cultural exceptionalism and alternative political development of East Asia. This study used four rounds of Asian Barometer Survey (ABS) datasets (spanning
The Myth of Asian Exceptionalism
In a series of contributions, Welzel describes modernization as human empowerment: a process that emancipates people from external authority. Human empowerment theory (HET) posits two sequential
Liberal democracy as the end of history
A growing number of political scientists have recently advocated the theses that democracy has emerged as a universal value and that it is also becoming the universally preferred system of
Contextual Effects and Support for Liberalism: A Comparative Analysis
This dissertation examines how variation in political freedom shapes individuals’ liberal attitudes and challenges existing explanations on value change. I begin by demonstrating that mainland China
Regional Commonalities and Regional Identities: Forging a Normative Understanding of Southeast Asian Identity
In the last two decades, most of the IR academia's attention on Southeast Asian regionalism utilised constructivism and/or realism and has focused on ASEAN and its derivatives. This article aims to
When Sage Speaks: Political Communication in Taiwan, Confucian Style
Back to the 1990s, a few Asian politicians galvanized a debate on Asian values, contending that democracy is not compatible with Confucian culture in East Asia. Echoing this view, Huntington (1991)
Culture, Citizenship Norms, and Political Participation: Empirical Evidence from Taiwan
  • Wen-Chun Chang
  • Political Science
    Japanese Journal of Political Science
  • 2016
Abstract This study investigates the role of religion in shaping the norms of citizenship from a cultural perspective for an East Asian country that exhibits fundamental differences in social
Cultural change in Asia and beyond
In their classic, The Civic Culture, Almond and Verba (1963) define the ideal democratic citizen as an allegiant, trustful, and modestly participatory person. This ideal has shaped how scholars think
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 45 REFERENCES
Whatever Happened to "Asian Values"?
The discourse contrasting the defects of “Western” individualism and democracy with the virtues of “Asian” communitarianism and good governance, which blossomed during East and Southeast Asia’s
Beyond Liberal Democracy: Political Thinking for an East Asian Context
Beyond Liberal Democracy: Political Thinking for an East Asian Context. By Daniel A. Bell. Princeton, New Jersey and Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2006. Hardcover and softcover: 379pp. The
The Effect of Confucian Values on Support for Democracy and Human Rights in Taiwan
Recent years have seen a great deal of interest in the extent to which ”Asian values,” or Confucian ideology, inhibit a country's acceptance of liberal-democratic values. Much of that research,
Value Change and Democratic Reform in Japan and Korea
This study explores the underlying causes of the processes of democratic reform in Japan and Korea over the past decade. In both nations, elite-challenging pressures from below have been the stimulus
Pacific Asia after ‘Asian values’: authoritarianism, democracy, and ‘good governance’
The 1997 Asian economic crisis discredited the international discussion about ‘Asian values’ in Pacific Asia, replacing it with a globalised ‘good governance’ discourse. The financial breakdown
The theory of human development: A cross-cultural analysis
This article demonstrates that socioeconomic development, emancipative cultural change and democratization constitute a coherent syndrome of social progress - a syndrome whose common focus has not
Popular Conceptions of the Meaning of Democracy: Democratic Understanding in Unlikely Places
This paper addresses the question of whether ordinary people express a reasonable understanding of the meaning of democracy, and what are the contents of their definitions? Do people focus on the
Do Asian Values Deter Popular Support for Democracy in South Korea
This article examines whether Confucian Asian values are incompatible with liberal democracy. Analyses of the East Asia Barometer Survey conducted in South Korea reveal that attachment to those
Confucianism and Democracy
The caning for vandalism last year of American high-school student Michael Fay by the Singaporean authorities underscored the challenge now being put forth by Asian societies to the United States and
"Asian Values" and the Universality of Human Rights
Orientalist scholarship in the nineteenth century perceived Asians as the mysterious and backward people of the Far East. Ironically, as this century draws to a close, leaders of prosperous and
...
1
2
3
4
5
...