The Aesthetics of Theory Selection and the Logics of Art

  title={The Aesthetics of Theory Selection and the Logics of Art},
  author={Ian O'Loughlin and Kate McCallum},
  journal={Philosophy of Science},
  pages={325 - 343}
Philosophers of science discuss whether theory selection depends on aesthetic judgments or criteria and whether these putatively aesthetic features are genuinely extra-epistemic. As examples, judgments involving criteria such as simplicity and symmetry are often cited. However, other theory selection criteria, such as fecundity, coherence, internal consistency, and fertility, more closely match those criteria used in art contexts and by scholars working in aesthetics. Paying closer attention to… 
3 Citations

The Art Experience

Art theory has consistently emphasised the importance of situational, cultural, institutional and historical factors in viewers’ experience of fine art. However, the link between this heavily

Disagreement and Agonistic Chance in Peer Review

The purpose of grant peer review is to identify the most excellent and promising research projects. However, sociologists of science and STS scholars have shown that peer review tends to promote



Unmasking the Truth Beneath the Beauty: Why the Supposed Aesthetic Judgements Made in Science May Not Be Aesthetic at All

In this article I examine the status of putative aesthetic judgements in science and mathematics. I argue that if the judgements at issue are taken to be genuinely aesthetic they can be divided into

Truth and beauty in scientific reason

A rationalist and realist model of scientific revolutions will be constructed by reference to two categories of criteria of theory-evaluation, denominated indicators of truth and of beauty. Whereas

The Omniscienter: Beauty and scientific understanding

Science has more to offer than just knowledge of nature; it can give us understanding of nature as well. Epistemology of science is usually focused on knowledge and the criteria of justification,

Encyclopedia of aesthetics

This reference surveys the breadth of critical thought on art, culture, and society - from classical philosophy to contemporary critical theory. Featuring 600 original articles by distinguished

Beauty in Proofs: Kant on Aesthetics in Mathematics

It is a common thought that mathematics can be not only true but also beautiful, and many of the greatest mathematicians have attached central importance to the aesthetic merit of their theorems,

Symmetry and asymmetry in aesthetics and the arts

Symmetry and beauty are often claimed to be linked, particularly by mathematicians and scientists. However philosophers and art historians seem generally agreed that although symmetry is indeed

Beauty Is Not Simplicity: An Analysis of Mathematicians' Proof Appraisals

What do mathematicians mean when they use terms such as 'deep', 'elegant', and 'beautiful'? By applying empirical methods developed by social psychologists, we demonstrate that mathematicians'

The Weight of Simplicity in the Construction and Assaying of Scientific Theories

  • M. Bunge
  • Philosophy
    Philosophy of Science
  • 1961
One of the most difficult and interesting problems of rational decision is the choice among possible diverging paths in theory construction and among competing scientific theories-i.e., systems of

Dreams of a final theory : the search for the fundamental laws of nature

An understanding of nature's final laws may be within our grasp - a way of explaining forces and symmetries and articles that does not require further explanation. 'This starting point, to which all