Testing the enemy release hypothesis: a comparison of foliar insect herbivory of the exotic Norway maple (Acer platanoides L.) and the native sugar maple (A. saccharum L.)

  title={Testing the enemy release hypothesis: a comparison of foliar insect herbivory of the exotic Norway maple (Acer platanoides L.) and the native sugar maple (A. saccharum L.)},
  author={Christine Cincotta and J. M. Adams and Claus Holzapfel},
  journal={Biological Invasions},
Norway maple (Acer platanoides) is a Eurasian introduced tree species which has invaded the North American range of its native congener, sugar maple (A. saccharum). One hypothesis used to explain the success of an invasive species is the enemy release hypothesis (ERH), which states that invasive species are often particularly successful in their new range because they lack the enemies of their native range. In this study, we hypothesized that Norway maple would have less insect damage than… 

A Comparison of Herbivore Damage on Three Invasive Plants and Their Native Congeners: Implications for the Enemy Release Hypothesis

This study tested whether the three exotic plant species, Rubus phoenicolasius, Fallopia japonica, and Persicaria perfoliata, suffered less herbivory or pathogen attack than native species by comparing leaf damage and invertebrate herbivore abundance and diversity on the invasive species and their native congeners.

Tar Spot Disease on Norway Maple in North America: Quantifying the Impacts of a Reunion between an Invasive Tree Species and Its Adventive Natural Enemy in an Urban Forest

A strong link is found between the outbreak of the disease and a very sharp decline in sapling and tree growth, together with high mortality of Norway maple saplings that could not be attributed to normal senescence or detrimental climatic conditions, which suggest that the invasion potential of Norway Maple could be reduced by the exotic disease.

Acer rubrum (red maple) growth is negatively affected by soil from forest stands dominated by its invasive congener (Acer platanoides, Norway maple)

Competition between two Acer species is studied to better understand the mechanisms and characteristics associated with invasive success, and found A. rubrum growth was negatively affected by soil from the invaded stand, as it had lower above-ground and below-ground biomass, and number of leaves than in the native soil.

Enemy pressure exerted on alien and native plants may differ between montane and lowland regions

The assumptions of the ERH hypothesis do not always hold true, and the invasion success of alien species may depend on several factors, including specific local conditions.

Increased seedling establishment via enemy release at the upper elevational range limit of sugar maple.

While some effects of enemies are magnified beyond range edges, others are dampened at and beyond the range edge, such that understanding the net outcome of different biotic interactions within, at and within the edge of distribution is critical to predicting species' responses to global change.

Levels of Leaf Damage by Phyllophages in Invasive Acer negundo and Native Betula pendula and Salix caprea

The validity of some concepts underlying the enemy release hypothesis was tested using the example of Acer negundo, an invasive tree species in Eurasia, and the level of leaf damage by phyllophagous invertebrates in A. negundo growing in the Southern Urals proved to be lower than in tree species native to this region.

Multitrophic enemy escape of invasive Phragmites australis and its introduced herbivores in North America

It is suggested that complex interactions can result from the co-introduction of plants and their herbivores, and that a multitrophic perspective is required for investigating how biotic interactions influence invasion success.

No Evidence for Enemy Release during Range Expansion of an Evergreen Tree in Northern Europe

There was no evidence that enemy release facilitates the current range expansion of I. aquifolium, and small-scale distance to existing adult plants influenced the activity of the insect on the transplants, and oviposition density was negatively correlated with distance to adult plants.

Damage levels from arthropod herbivores on Lonicera maackii suggest enemy release in its introduced range

Levels of herbivory experienced by L. maackii are relatively consistent across sites, vary slightly with habitat and branch identity, but are likely too low to impact fitness of shrubs.



Response of native and exotic maple seedling banks to removal of the exotic, invasive Norway maple (Acer platanoides).

To test the efficacy of restoration strategies and to probe dynamics of this tree's seedling bank, trees and seedlings were removed in 1997 from a mixed maple forest carpeted by an even mix of exotic Acer platanoides and native Acer saccharum seedlings.

The myth of the resilient forest: Case study of the invasive Norway maple (Acer platanoides)

Research in the Drew Forest Preserve shows that the forest is not a tight, resilient unit that repels invasions, and intervention is urgently needed to weather the onslaught of intentional and accidental introductions.

Understory influence of the invasive Norway maple (Acer platanoides).

A surprising paucity of Fagus grandifolia reproduction seems unrelated to the biological invasion, and Acer saccharum has some prospects for self-replacement judging from sapling distributions but has sparse reproduction under the other canopy species relative to its exotic congener.


Significant effects of herbivores and fungal pathogens may be limited to particular habitats, and for Clidemia hirta, its absence from forest understory in its native range likely results in part from the strong pressures of natural enemies.


The results suggest that invasion of Acers is enhanced by soil biota associated with dominant native species and that the soilBiota effect becomes more inhibitory as the Acers establish, and suggests that mutualists are relatively more beneficial to Acers in their nonnative ranges than in their native ranges.

An experimental field study of different levels of insect herbivory induced by Formica rufa predation on sycamore(Acer pseudoplatanus).III.Effects on tree growth.

It is concluded that moderate levels of herbivory on sycamore can significantly reduce tree performance and this is reflected in substantially reduced timber increments.

Norway Maple (Acer platanoides) Invasion of a Natural Forest Stand: Understory Consequence and Regeneration Pattern

The success of Norway maple regeneration and the reductions in total stem density beneath Norway maples is most likely the result of its strong competitive abilities, notably its high shade tolerance and abundant seed crops.

Variation in Herbivore Damage to Invasive and Native Woody Plant Species in Open Forest Vegetation on Mahé, Seychelles

In the Seychelles invasive woody plants profit from herbivore release relative to the native species and that the amount of herbivory, and therefore its effect on species invasiveness or habitat invasibility, may be dependent on local community structure and composition.

Does enemy release matter for invasive plants? evidence from a comparison of insect herbivore damage among invasive, non-invasive and native congeners

It was found that introduced Eugenia, both invasive and non-invasive, sustained less herbivore damage, especially damage by oligophagous and endophileous insects, than native EugenIA, however, the difference in insect damage between introduced invasive and introduced non- invasive Eugenian species was not significant.

Ecophysiological attributes of the native Acer saccharum and the exotic Acer platanoides in urban oak forests in Pennsylvania, USA.

Field net photosynthesis (mass basis) and photosynthetic light response curves (area basis) indicated significantly greater carbon assimilation, and nitrogen and phosphorus use efficiencies in A. platanoides, suggesting that it utilizes light, water and nutrients more efficiently than A. saccharum.