Teleology’s long shadow

@article{Werth2020TeleologysLS,
  title={Teleology’s long shadow},
  author={Alexander J. Werth and Douglas Allchin},
  journal={Evolution: Education and Outreach},
  year={2020},
  volume={13},
  pages={1-11}
}
We describe the ubiquity of teleological language and thinking throughout biology, as a context for understanding how students think about evolution, as well. Examples can be found in molecular biology, physiology, ecology, and taxonomy, at least. Recent research documents a deep human psychological tendency to attribute purpose or intent (and thus normative meaning) to natural phenomena. We present a possible evolutionary explanation. Still, these cognitive habits help foster scientific errors… 
Metaphor and Meaning in the Teleological Language of Biology
TLDR
It is concluded that, since teleological concepts cannot be abstracted away from biological explanations without loss of meaning and explanatory power, life is inherently teleological.
Do What Darwin Did
We argue that teleological thinking plays a central role in biology and, more specifically, in theory of natural selection, and, therefore, the didactic goal cannot be its unnuanced elimination. In
Why Do Platypuses Fluoresce? or Why Darwin Did Not Believe in “Evolution”
  • D. Allchin
  • Psychology
    The American Biology Teacher
  • 2021
SACRED BOVINES 553 Popular wisdom (seemingly well beyond question – hence this month’s Sacred Bovine), says that Charles Darwin established and championed the scientific principle of evolution. But
How we Think About Human Nature: Cognitive Errors and Concrete Remedies
Appeals to human nature are ubiquitous, yet historically many have proven ill-founded. Why? How might frequent errors be remedied towards building a more robust and reliable scientific study of human
Cannus stannous: Understanding Chance & Necessity in Natural Selection
Abstract This classroom activity highlights how evolution by natural selection is nonteleological—that is, not guided by need, by organismal intent, by inherent progress, by an external ideal, or by
Teleology and evolution education: introduction to the special issue
TLDR
Teachers and their students should be cognizant about the different types of teleology in order to develop robust evolutionary understanding and agree that teleological thinking is deeply entrenched in biology and is not limited to student thinking.
Cinema, doença infecciosa e teoria da evolução: uma estratégia possível ao Ensino Médio
Nosso objetivo é fomentar a articulação entre o ensino de doenças infectocontagiosas e de evolução, a partir do filme (como estratégia de ensino) “O despertar de uma paixão” (2006), que retrata uma

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 104 REFERENCES
The Role of Teleological Thinking in Learning the Darwinian Model of Evolution
TLDR
The challenges of teaching evolution in biology education have been revised, and improved methodological strategies aimed at a better comprehension of the Darwinian evolution model are suggested.
How We Think about Human Nature: The Naturalizing Error
History is littered with scientifically ill-founded claims about human nature. They frequently appear in normative contexts, projecting ideology or values onto nature (what we call the naturalizing
Function, goals and intention: children’s teleological reasoning about objects
  • D. Kelemen
  • Philosophy
    Trends in Cognitive Sciences
  • 1999
The Biology and Evolution of the Three Psychological Tendencies to Anthropomorphize Biology and Evolution
TLDR
This tripartite framework shed some light on how to better deal with the over-reactive stances in bio-education, by organizing previous pedagogical strategies and by suggesting new possibilities to be tested.
Ambiguous, circular and polysemous: students' definitions of the “balance of nature” metaphor
The “balance of nature” metaphor has been used to explain the functioning of natural systems from ancient times and continues to be invoked in popular culture, in spite of controversy regarding its
What is Innateness
In behavioral ecology some authors regard the innateness concept as irretrievably confused whilst others take it to refer to adaptations. In cognitive psychology, however, whether traits are 'innate'
Darwin's Dangerous Idea: Evolution and the Meanings of Life
In this groundbreaking and very accessible book, Daniel C. Dennett, the acclaimed author of Consciousness Explained, demonstrates the power of the theory of natural selection and shows how Darwin's
Cultural influences on the teleological stance: evidence from China
ABSTRACT Recent research has suggested that humans have a robust tendency to default to teleological (i.e., purpose-based) explanations of natural phenomena. However, because samples have previously
...
...