THE THEORY AND PRACTICE OF ‘SUPRA-CONSTITUTIONAL’ LIMITS ON CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS

@article{Roznai2013THETA,
  title={THE THEORY AND PRACTICE OF ‘SUPRA-CONSTITUTIONAL’ LIMITS ON CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS},
  author={Yaniv Roznai},
  journal={International and Comparative Law Quarterly},
  year={2013},
  volume={62},
  pages={557 - 597}
}
  • Yaniv Roznai
  • Published 1 July 2013
  • Law
  • International and Comparative Law Quarterly
Abstract This article examines whether there are any limitations on constitutional amendment powers that are external to the constitutional system and above it—‘supra-constitutional’ limits. It considers the theory and practice of the relationship between natural law, international law or other supranational law, and domestic constitutional law in a comparative prism. After considering the alleged supremacy of supranational law over constitutional amendments, the author explores the problem of… 
Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments - The Migration and Success of a Constitutional Idea
Can a constitutional amendment be unconstitutional? Prima facie, this seems like a paradox. This vexing issue has attracted increased attention in recent years. Whereas the definition of the nature
Constitutional amendments and constitutional core values: the Brazilian case in a comparative perspective
  • V. Scotti
  • Law
    Revista de Investigações Constitucionais
  • 2018
The debate over the exercise of primary and secondary constituent power is a long-lasting one and is grounded on positions diverging according to the interpretation of constitutionalism and
'We, the People' Entitlement Within Constitutional Change
In recent years, scholars have produced literature in constitutional amendments, in particular in analyzing the unamendability phenomenon and its relationship with democracy, abusive and populist
Amending constitutional amendment rules
No part of a constitution is more important than the rules that govern its amendment and its entrenchment against it. Given the important functions served by formal constitutional amendment rules, we
A new typology of judicial review of legislation
Abstract The distinction between strong and weak judicial review occupies a privileged place in comparative constitutional law. This article argues that it is necessary to generate a new typology
Constitutionalizing Secession in Order to Harmonize Constitutionality and Democracy in Territorial Decentralized States Like Spain
This text aims to analyze whether constitutionalizing a secession procedure is an adequate way to harmonize the roles of constitutional legality and democracy in regard to the secular territorial
The Hegemonic Preservation Thesis Revisited: The Example of Turkey
This paper offers a critical rereading of the history of judicial review of constitutional amendments in Turkey. We argue that, contrary to appearances, the claim to a power of amendment review on
Necrocracy or Democracy? Assessing Objections to Constitutional Unamendability
Unamendability is a growing trend in global constitutionalism. Yet, unamendability, as a constitutional mechanism, raises various challenges and objections. Mainly, by perpetuating certain
Conventionality Control and Amendment 95/2016 - A Brazilian Case of Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendment
This article presents reflections on Brazilian Constitutional Amendment 95/2016, which established the New Tax Regime and consequently the ceiling of public spending in Brazil for a period of twenty
EVER CLOSER REMOTENESS OF THE PEOPLES OF EUROPE? LIMITS ON THE POWER OF AMENDMENT AND NATIONAL CONSTITUENT POWER
  • M. Cahill
  • Sociology
    The Cambridge Law Journal
  • 2016
Abstract It might seem counter-intuitive to suggest that the chasm between Europe and her citizens is partially caused by the weakening of constituent power at the national level. Nonetheless, this
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 223 REFERENCES
How Supreme is the Supreme Law of the Land? A Comparative Analysis of the Influence of International Human Rights Conventions Upon the Interpretation of Constitutional Texts by Domestic Courts
International human rights law bears substantial resemblance to constitutional law as both bodies of law share similar social functions and goals. Still, courts in a number of influential legal
External Review of Constitutional Amendments? International Law as a Norm of Reference
This article is built around three general observations. The first is that, in the current stage of the development of constitutional theory and practice, there is a need to create procedures
Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments - The Migration and Success of a Constitutional Idea
Can a constitutional amendment be unconstitutional? Prima facie, this seems like a paradox. This vexing issue has attracted increased attention in recent years. Whereas the definition of the nature
An unconstitutional constitutional amendment—The Turkish perspective: A comment on the Turkish Constitutional Court’s headscarf decision
In June 2008, the Turkish Constitutional Court annulled amendments to the Constitution regarding the principle of equality and the right to education, which had been enacted by parliament in order to
The Politics of Constitutional Review in France and Europe
To the question “ Is constitutional review by a Constitutional Court law or politics? ” this article responds with a survey of various notions of the “ political, ” providing illustrations drawn from
International Law in its Relation to Constitutional Law
The traditional treatment of international law has almost if not wholly dissociated it from constitutional law. International law has been con­ ceived as concerned only with the abstractions known as
Democracy and Constitutionalism in India: A Study of the Basic Structure Doctrine
This book presents a completely reconfigured understanding of the judicial role in Indian constitutional law. The author presents a completely reconfigured understanding of the judicial role in
International Law as a Resource in Constitutional Interpretation
I. Despite recent polemics, the use of international law in constitutional interpretation, as one factor among others, is highly traditional and eminently proper. Some international law is too
The Prohibition of Torture as an International Norm of jus cogens and Its Implications for National and Customary Law
The article explores the validity of the Furundzija dictum in accordance with which jus cogens has to bind the state in its treaty relations and with respect to acts of the legislature, executive and
Statutory Lawlessness and Supra-Statutory Law (1946)
By means of two maxims, 'An order is an order' and 'a law is a law', National Socialism contrived to bind its followers to itself, soldiers and jurists respectively. The former tenet was always
...
...