Systematic errors in current quantum state tomography tools.

  title={Systematic errors in current quantum state tomography tools.},
  author={Christian Schwemmer and Lukas Knips and Daniel Richart and Harald Weinfurter and Tobias Moroder and Matthias Kleinmann and Otfried G{\"u}hne},
  journal={Physical review letters},
  volume={114 8},
Common tools for obtaining physical density matrices in experimental quantum state tomography are shown here to cause systematic errors. For example, using maximum likelihood or least squares optimization to obtain physical estimates for the quantum state, we observe a systematic underestimation of the fidelity and an overestimation of entanglement. Such strongly biased estimates can be avoided using linear evaluation of the data or by linearizing measurement operators yielding reliable and… 

Figures from this paper

Practical and reliable error bars for quantum process tomography
This work provides a solution to the problem of reliable estimation of essentially any figure of merit for quantum processes on few qubits, including the diamond distance to a specific noise model, the entanglement fidelity, and the worst-case entanglements, by identifying error regions which contain the true state with high probability.
Joint quantum-state and measurement tomography with incomplete measurements
Estimation of quantum states and measurements is crucial for the implementation of quantum information protocols. The standard method for each is quantum tomography. However, quantum tomography
Systematic errors in direct state measurements with quantum controlled measurements
  • Le Bin Ho
  • Physics
    Journal of Physics B: Atomic, Molecular and Optical Physics
  • 2020
The von Neumann measurement framework describes a dynamic interaction between a target system and a probe. In contrast, a quantum controlled measurement framework uses a qubit probe to control the
Quantum tomography for quantum systems optimization
Debugging quantum states transformations is an important task of modern quantum computing. The use of quantum tomography for these purposes significantly expands the range of possibilities. However,
True experimental reconstruction of quantum states and processes via convex optimization
This work uses a constrained convex optimization (CCO) method to experimentally characterize arbitrary quantum states and unknown quantum processes on a two-qubit NMR quantum information processor, and assumes Markovian system dynamics to completely characterize the noise processes present in the NMR system.
Detecting entanglement of unknown quantum states with random measurements
This work investigates the use of random local measurements, from which entanglement witnesses are then constructed via semidefinite programming methods, and proposes a scheme of successively increasing the number of measurements until the presence ofEntanglement can be unambiguously concluded.
Distinguishing between statistical and systematic errors in quantum process tomography
It is generally assumed that every process in quantum physics can be described mathematically by a completely positive map. However, experimentally reconstructed processes are not necessarily
Error regions in quantum state tomography: computational complexity caused by geometry of quantum states
The result does not yet imply that the practical task of quantum uncertainty quantification is intractable, but it does show that there exists a non-trivial trade-off between optimality and computational efficiency for error regions.
Experimental Estimation of Quantum State Properties from Classical Shadows
This work shows on experimental data how this procedure outperforms conventional state reconstruction in fidelity estimation from a limited number of measurements, and investigates its performance in the quantum optical experiment with high-dimensional spatial states of photons.
Statistical Methods for Quantum State Verification and Fidelity Estimation
The efficient and reliable certification of quantum states is essential for various quantum information processing tasks as well as for the general progress on the implementation of quantum


Direct fidelity estimation from few Pauli measurements.
A simple method for certifying that an experimental device prepares a desired quantum state ρ, and it provides an estimate of the fidelity between ρ and the actual (arbitrary) state in the lab, up to a constant additive error.
Permutationally invariant quantum tomography.
We present a scalable method for the tomography of large multiqubit quantum registers. It acquires information about the permutationally invariant part of the density operator, which is a good
Reliable quantum state tomography.
This work shows that quantum state tomography, together with an appropriate data analysis procedure, yields reliable and tight error bounds, specified in terms of confidence regions-a concept originating from classical statistics.
Errors in quantum tomography: diagnosing systematic versus statistical errors
It is shown that the chi-squared goodness-of-fit test statistic deviates noticeably from expectations for states lying near the boundaries of physical state space, severely undermining its usefulness as a quantitative tool precisely in the region which is of most interest in quantum information processing tasks.
Diagnosis, prescription, and prognosis of a bell-state filter by quantum process tomography.
The quantum process tomography results indicate a large asymmetry in the process and the required operation to correct for this asymmetry, and residual errors and decoherence of the filtering operation after this modification are quantified.
Imperfect measurement settings: Implications for quantum state tomography and entanglement witnesses
Reliable and well-characterized quantum resources are indispensable ingredients in quantum information processing. Typically, in a realistic characterization of these resources, apparatuses come with
Self-Consistent Quantum Process Tomography
This work shows that the standard approach of process tomography is grossly inaccurate in the case where the states and measurement operators used to interrogate the system are generated by gates that have some systematic error, a situation all but unavoidable in any practical setting.
Prescription for experimental determination of the dynamics of a quantum black box
Abstract We give an explicit way to experimentally determine the evolution operators which completely describe the dynamics of a quantum-mechanical black box: an arbitrary open quantum system. We
Full characterization of a three-photon Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state using quantum state tomography.
This work has performed the first experimental tomographic reconstruction of a three-photon polarization state using a "maximum-likelihood" reconstruction method to reconstruct the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state.
Precision-guaranteed quantum tomography.
It is proved that the (always physical) estimates will be close to the true prepared state with a high probability, and the first result directly applicable to the problem of evaluating the precision of estimation and preparation in quantum tomographic experiments.