Surrogacy, Compensation, and Legal Parentage: Against the Adoption Model

  title={Surrogacy, Compensation, and Legal Parentage: Against the Adoption Model},
  author={Liezl van Zyl and Ruth Walker},
  journal={Journal of Bioethical Inquiry},
  • L. Zyl, R. Walker
  • Published 2 July 2015
  • Business
  • Journal of Bioethical Inquiry
Surrogate motherhood is treated as a form of adoption in many countries: the birth mother and her partner are presumed to be the parents of the child, while the intended parents have to adopt the baby once it is born. Other than compensation for expenses related to the pregnancy, payment to surrogates is not permitted. We believe that the failure to compensate surrogate mothers for their labour as well as the significant risks they undertake is both unfair and exploitative. We accept that… 
Should Surrogate Pregnancy Arrangements be Enforceable in Aotearoa New Zealand?
Abstract Aotearoa New Zealand has no unified regulatory system governing the ethical and legal issues that arise with surrogate pregnancy arrangements. Accordingly, legal scholars and moral
Determining Legal Parentage: Between Family Law and Contract Law
The last few decades have witnessed dramatic changes affecting the institutions of family and parenthood. If, in the past, the classic family was defined sociologically as a pair of heterosexual
Regulating the international surrogacy market:the ethics of commercial surrogacy in the Netherlands and India
It is argued that, although commodification and exploitation can occur, these problems are not specific to surrogacy but should be understood in the broader context of an unequal world, and commercial surrogacy should be permitted across the globe.
Surrogacy: beyond the commercial/altruistic distinction
  • J. Y. Lee
  • Business
    Journal of medical ethics
  • 2022
In this article, I critique the commonly accepted distinction between commercial and altruistic surrogacy arrangements. The moral legitimacy of surrogacy, I claim, does not hinge on whether it is
The study found that today some issues related to the surrogacy legal nature, conditions and procedure for its implementation remain out of the EU's attention, and it is established that the adoption of a separate regional legal act will fully solve the existing problems.
Is ʻsurrogacyʼ an infertility treatment?
It is argued that it is problematic to construe the debate around the process labelled ‘surrogacy’ as a form for infertility treatment because it opens up a new form of medical desire and creates pressure within health services to respond to the desires of an ever-growing group of patients.
An ethical comparison of living kidney donation and surrogacy: understanding the relational dimension
A comparative analysis of the two practices’ relational dimension with regard to three aspects is provided, i.e. the normative role of relational dynamics, social norms and gender roles, and reciprocity.
Iranian model of decision making to use surrogacy: A grounded theory Study
In this grounded theory study, participants were selected through snowball sampling method and obtaining an informed consent, in-depth interviews were conducted face to face and recorded, and interviews, field notes, and memos were analyzed using Strauss-Corbin 1998 method.
Development and Psychometric Testing of the Nurses' Confidence Scale: Unique Families.
Familiengründung durch Leihmutterschaft – eine ethische Analyse
Als Leihmutter wird eine Frau bezeichnet, die ein Kind mit der Absicht austragt, es nach der Geburt an ein anderes Paar abzugeben. Mit dieser Praxis verknupfen sich grundsatzliche ethische Bedenken.


Beyond Altruistic and Commercial Contract Motherhood: The Professional Model
It is argued that contract motherhood should not be organized according to the norms of the gift relationship, and that contract mothers should be compensated for their labour.
The new surrogacy parentage laws in Australia: cautious regulation or '25 brick walls'?
This article critically analyses recent law reforms that have taken place throughout Australia allowing for the transfer of legal parentage in surrogacy arrangements from the birth mother (and her
Surrogate Motherhood and Abortion for Fetal Abnormality
This work argues in favour of the professional model, which acknowledges the rights and responsibilities of both parties and provides a legal and institutional framework that supports good decision-making in surrogacy.
Who's bringing up baby: Developing a framework for the transfer of legal parenthood in surrogacy arrangements
Surrogacy arrangements defy traditional definitions of parenthood and pose challenges in determining who should be recognised as legal parents. This is exacerbated by the use of assisted reproductive
Procreation Through Art: Why the Adoption Process Should Not Apply
Assisted reproduction should fall within the constitutional purview of protected family privacy and should not be subjected to the greater regulation and screening of adoption law, and the UPA assures greater privacy and less state intrusion than the adoption process.
Rethinking “Commercial” Surrogacy in Australia
It is argued that Australia can learn from commercial surrogacy practices elsewhere, without replicating them, and compensate domestic surrogacy and the introduction of professional intermediaries and mechanisms such as advertising are proposed as a feasible harm-minimisation approach.
Reproductive gifts and gift giving: the altruistic woman.
  • J. Raymond
  • Philosophy
    The Hastings Center report
  • 1990
Noncommercial surrogacy cannot be treated as a mere act of altruism--any valorizing of altruistic surrogacy and reproductive gift-giving must be assessed within the wider context of women's political inequality.
In Defense of Surrogacy Agreements: A Modern Contract Law Perspective
The American public’s attention was first exposed to the practice of surrogacy in 1988 with the drama and verdict of the Baby M case. Over the last twenty-five years the practice of surrogacy has
Surrogate mothers 10 years on: a longitudinal study of psychological well-being and relationships with the parents and child.
The psychological well-being of surrogate mothers did not change 10 years following the birth, with all remaining positive about the surrogacy arrangement and the majority continuing to report good mental health.