Structural explanations in Minkowski spacetime: which account of models?

@inproceedings{Dorato2010StructuralEI,
  title={Structural explanations in Minkowski spacetime: which account of models?},
  author={Mauro Dorato and Laura Felline},
  year={2010}
}
In this paper we argue that structural explanations are an effective way of explaining well-known relativistic phenomena like length contraction and time dilation, and then try to understand how this can be possible by looking at the literature on scientific models. In particular, we ask whether and how a model like that provided by Minkowski spacetime can be said to represent the physical world, in such a way that it can successfully explain physical phenomena structurally. We conclude by… Expand

Figures from this paper

How to be a realist about Minkowski spacetime without believing in magical explanations
The question about the relation between spacetime structure and the symmetries of laws has received renewed attention in a recent discussion about the status of Minkowski spacetime in SpecialExpand
Forthcoming in Synthese Dynamical versus structural explanations in scientific revolutions 1
By briefly reviewing three well-known scientific revolutions in fundamental physics (the discovery of inertia, of special relativity and of general relativity), I claim that problems that wereExpand
Dynamical versus structural explanations in scientific revolutions
TLDR
This claim is meant to give more substance to Kuhn’s view that revolutions are accompanied by a shift in what needs to be explained, while suggesting at the same time the existence of a pattern that is common to all of the discussed case-studies. Expand
Mechanisms meet structural explanation
  • L. Felline
  • Mathematics, Computer Science
  • Synthese
  • 2015
TLDR
It is argued that some phenomena in the domain of fundamental physics, although mechanically brute, are structurally explained and can be reconciled within a unified account of general scientific explanation. Expand
Minkowski spacetime and Lorentz invariance: The cart and the horse or two sides of a single coin?
Abstract Michel Janssen and Harvey Brown have driven a prominent recent debate concerning the direction of an alleged arrow of explanation between Minkowski spacetime and Lorentz invariance ofExpand
Geometrical Constructivism and Modal Relationalism: Further Aspects of the Dynamical/Geometrical Debate
ABSTRACT I draw together some recent literature on the debate between dynamical versus geometrical approaches to spacetime theories, in order to argue that (i) there exist defensible versions of theExpand
THE CART AND THE HORSE OR TWO SIDES OF A SINGLE COIN?1
Michel Janssen and Harvey Brown have driven a prominent recent debate concerning the direction of an alleged arrow of explanation between Minkowski spacetime and Lorentz invariance of dynamical lawsExpand
The Dynamical Approach as Practical Geometry February
  • 2014
This essay introduces Harvey Brown and Oliver Pooley’s ‘dynamical approach’ to special relativity and argues that it is best construed as a relationalist form of Einstein’s ‘practical geometry’,Expand
Physics’ silence on time
In this paper I argue that physics is, always was, and probably always will be voiceless with respect to tense and passage, and that, therefore, if, as I believe, tense and passage are the essence ofExpand
Conjuring Cognitive Structures: Towards a Unified Model of Cognition
  • M. D. Beni
  • Psychology
  • Model-Based Reasoning in Science and Technology
  • 2019
There are different philosophical views on the nature of scientific theories. Although New Mechanistic Philosophy (NMP) and Structural Realism (SR) are not rival theories strictly speaking, theyExpand
...
1
2
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 61 REFERENCES
Relativity Theory between Structural and Dynamical Explanations
In this review article I discuss Harvey Brown’s recent book Physical Relativity (OUP, 2005) by presenting and criticizing some of his main arguments in favour of a dynamical underpinning of rodsExpand
Scientific Explanation and Scientific Structuralism
An interpretation of the formalism of quantum mechanics that can be regarded as uncontroversial is currently not available. Consequently, philosophers have often contrasted the poor explanatory powerExpand
Why Constructive Relativity Fails
  • J. Norton
  • Philosophy
  • The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
  • 2008
Constructivists, such as Harvey Brown, urge that the geometries of Newtonian and special relativistic spacetimes result from the properties of matter. Whatever this may mean, it commitsExpand
Theories, Models, and Representations
I argue against an account of scientific representation suggested by the semantic, or structuralist, conception of scientific theories. Proponents of this conception often employ the term “model” toExpand
The devil in the details : asymptotic reasoning in explanation, reduction, and emergence
Batterman examines a form of scientific reasoning called asymptotic reasoning, which he argues has important consequences for our understanding of the scientific process as a whole. He argues thatExpand
Reinflating the Semantic Approach
Abstract The semantic, or model‐theoretic, approach to theories has recently come under criticism on two fronts: (i) it is claimed that it cannot account for the wide diversity of models employed inExpand
Chapter 5: The Irrelevance of the Presentist/Eternalist Debate for the Ontology of Minkowski Spacetime
In this paper I argue that the debate between the so-called “presentists” – according to whom only the present is real – and the “eternalists”, according to whom past present and future are equallyExpand
Scientific Explanation between Principle and Constructive Theories
The aim of this article is to analyze the role of the distinction between principle and constructive theories in the question of the explanatory power of special relativity. We show how theExpand
The Ontology Of Spacetime
The sixteen papers collected in this volume are expanded and revised versions of talks delivered at the Second International Conference on the Ontology of Spacetime, organized by the InternationalExpand
Relativity, Dimensionality, and Existence
The main purpose of this paper is to demonstrate that the analysis of the kinematical effects of special relativity holds the key to answering the question of the dimensionality of the world. It isExpand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...