Still Rooted in Maastricht: EU External Relations as a ‘Third-generation Hybrid’

  title={Still Rooted in Maastricht: EU External Relations as a ‘Third-generation Hybrid’},
  author={Michael. Smith},
  journal={Journal of European Integration},
  pages={699 - 715}
  • Michael. Smith
  • Published 29 October 2012
  • Political Science
  • Journal of European Integration
Abstract This article argues that EU external relations since the Maastricht Treaty have constituted the Union as a hybrid international actor, reflecting a number of tensions built into the roots of the treaty. These tensions — reflected in the international roles and status of the EU — arise from the logics expressed in institutions and policies, and the ways in which those logics interact with each other when confronted with situations in which diplomatic, economic and security concerns are… 
The EU as a Diplomatic Actor in the Post-Lisbon Era: Robust or Rootless Hybrid?
The past five years have seen the introduction and initial institutionalisation of a new system of diplomatic action in the European Union (EU), following the ratification of the Lisbon Treaty and
How Much of a New Agenda? International Structures, Agency, and Transatlantic Order
This article focuses on the links between transatlantic relations—a structured array of markets, hierarchies, networks, ideas, and institutions—and broader elements of international structure and
The quest for throughput legitimacy: the EEAS, EU delegations and the contested structures of European diplomacy
ABSTRACT The European External Action Service (EEAS) and its EU delegations have developed the notion of “being of service to EU member states” in EU foreign policy making as their unique selling
From the ESS to the EU Global Strategy: external policy, internal purpose
ABSTRACT Security strategies are important sites for narrating the EU into existence as a security actor. The unveiling of a new global strategy on foreign and security policy for the EU immediately
EU-China relations and the limits of economic diplomacy
This paper addresses a key problem in EU-China economic relations: the capacity of the EU to exert leverage through its economic diplomacy in the context of key economic trends, policy dilemmas, and
On ‘ring-fencing’ the Common Foreign and Security Policy in the legal order of the European Union
T European Union’s (EU) ‘unique’ and ‘supranational’ legal order is widely regarded among lawyers to be crucial to its policy successes. If the EU is to become a successful global actor, one would
An Ever More Intergovernmental EU? From Foreign and Security Policy to External Action
This chapter provides the analytical framework of the book by looking at two parallel developments. On the one hand, it reviews the re-emergence of a long-lasting debate between intergovernmentalism
Discursively (de-)constructing European foreign policy: Theoretical and methodological challenges
This article is about European foreign policy, specifically an examination of ways in which discourse analysis and foreign policy analysis can be brought together. The first aim of this article is to
EU Diplomacy and the EU–China strategic relationship: framing, negotiation and management
Abstract This article focuses on the development of the EU’s strategic relationship with China, by exploring the balance amongst three key mechanisms mobilized by the EU: framing, negotiation and
EU Policies towards Latin America
This chapter analyses the main policies that the European Union formulates towards Latin America. While extensive literature has been produced in order to explain the role of the European Union as an


Providing for European-Level Diplomacy after Lisbon: The Case of the European External Action Service
The Lisbon Treaty may well be on ice, may perhaps even be moribund, but there remain compelling reasons to think through the identified shortcomings of the European Union in external relations. Many
The European Union and International Order: European and Global Dimensions
  • Michael Smith
  • Political Science
    European Foreign Affairs Review
  • 2007
This article explores the ambiguous nature of the EU’s relationship to international order and places it within the framework of recent scholarship on the EU’s international relations and
European Union Foreign Policy in a Changing World
The European Union finds itself at a critical juncture; not only has the deepening crisis in the eurozone weakened the EU’s internal structure, it has impacted significantly on its international
Between ‘soft power’ and a hard place: European Union Foreign and Security Policy between the Islamic world and the United States
This paper explores the pressures operating on European Union Foreign and Security Policy in the ‘triangle of forces’ created by the European integration process, developments in the Islamic world
‘Normative’ power Europe: a realist critique
Abstract This article offers a neorealist analysis and critique of liberal-idealist notions of the EU as a ‘normative’ or ‘civilian’ power. It argues that structural realist theory can shed
Upgrading the EU's Role as Global Actor: Institutions, Law and the Restructuring of European Diplomacy. CEPS Paperbacks. January 2011
The international order is experiencing fundamental changes driven by globalisation and the multipolarity emerging from the new balance of power. In response, a new book by a team of experts
An emerging diplomatic system for the EU?: frameworks and issues
This paper addresses the general problems encountered by EU’s diplomacy, and specifically the emergence of the EU ‘diplomatic system’ (EUDS). First, the paper analyses the changing nature of
Normative Power Europe: A Credible Utopia?
Studies on the international identity of the EU have stressed the normative feature of European foreign policy. At the same time, scholars have pointed out that the inconsistency between the EU's
Towards a Social Theory of EU Foreign and Security Policy
This article argues that the study of EU foreign and security policy has been hampered by its conceptualization of the sovereign state. Realist and constructivist scholars share Stanley Hoffmann's