Stepping in for the Polluters? Climate Justice under Partial Compliance

  title={Stepping in for the Polluters? Climate Justice under Partial Compliance},
  author={Sabine Hohl and Dominie Roser},
  journal={Analyse \& Kritik},
  pages={477 - 500}
Abstract Not all countries do their fair share in the effort of preventing dangerous climate change. This presents those who are willing to do their part with the question whether they should ‘take up the slack’ and try to compensate for the non-compliers’ failure to reduce emissions. There is a pro tanto reason for doing so given the human rights violations associated with dangerous climate change. The article focuses on fending off two objections against a duty to take up the slack: that it… 

Figures from this paper

Carbon Sink Conservation and Global Justice: Benefitting, Free Riding and Non-compliance
It is often assumed that in order to avoid the most severe consequences of global anthropogenic climate change we have to preserve our existing carbon sinks, such as for instance tropical forests.
Climate change and individual duties
Tackling climate change has often been considered the responsibility of national governments. But do individuals also have a duty to act in the face of this problem? In particular, do they have a
Who Should Intervene?
The objective of this paper is to develop a novel account of how the duty to undertake humanitarian intervention should be assigned to states. It takes as its point of departure two worries about the
Carbon Leakage and the Argument from No Difference
Critics of carbon mitigation often appeal to what Jonathan Glover has called 'the argument from no difference': that is, 'if I don't do it, someone else will'. Yet even if this justifies continued
The weight of fairness
  • S. Bajaj
  • Business
    Politics, Philosophy & Economics
  • 2019
Many philosophers argue that individuals have duties to do their fair shares of the demands of achieving important common ends. But what happens when some individuals fail to do their fair shares?
Non-ideal climate justice
Abstract Based on three recently published books on climate justice, this article reviews the field of climate ethics in light of developments of international climate politics. The central problem
Buying Low, Flying High: Carbon Offsets and Partial Compliance
Many companies offer their customers voluntary carbon ‘offset’ certificates to compensate for greenhouse gas emissions. Voluntary offset certificates are cheap because the demand for them is low,
How legitimate expectations matter in climate justice
Expectations play an important role in how people plan their lives and pursue their projects. People living in highly industrialized countries share a way of life that comes with high levels of
Why Be Cautious with Advocating Private Environmental Duties? Towards a Cooperative Ethos and Expressive Reasons
This article start from two opposing intuitions in the environmental duties debate. On the one hand, if our lifestyle causes environmental harm, then we have a duty to reduce that impact through
Do parents have a special duty to mitigate climate change?
This article argues that parents have a special, shared duty to organize for collective action on climate change mitigation and adaptation, but not for the reason one might assume. The apparently


Cosmopolitan Justice, Responsibility, and Global Climate Change
  • S. Caney
  • Philosophy
    Leiden Journal of International Law
  • 2005
It is widely recognized that changes are occurring to the earth's climate and, further, that these changes threaten important human interests. This raises the question of who should bear the burdens
The Possibility of a Joint Communiqué: My Response to Hourdequin
This article is a response to Marion Hourdequin, 'Climate, Collective Action and Individual Ethical Obligations', Environmental Values 19 (2010): 443-464. As Hourdequin argues, we have an obligation
Do I Make a Difference
Let’s start with a story from the “good old days.” Imagine that I used to run a factory, from which I periodically released some of the poisonous waste (by-products of the manufacturing process) into
Energy E  ciency and Consumption  the Rebound E  ect  a Survey , in :
  • Is No One Responsible for Global Environmental Tragedy ? Climate Change as a Challenge to Our Ethical Concepts , in :
  • 2011