Statistics As Principled Argument

  title={Statistics As Principled Argument},
  author={R. Abelson},
Contents: Preface. Abelson's Laws. Making Claims With Statistics. Elementary Arguments and the Role of Chance. Magnitude of Effects. Styles of Rhetoric. On Suspecting Fishiness. Articulation of Results: Ticks and Buts. Generality of Effects. Interestingness of Argument. Credibility of Argument. 
Null hypothesis tests and theory corroboration: Defending NHSTP out of context
Chow's defense of NHSTP ignores the fact that in psychology it is used to test substantive hypotheses in theory-corroborating research. In this role, NHSTP is not only inadequate, but damaging to theExpand
Types of Arguments When Dealing with Chance Experiments.
This paper contributes to the discourse in stochastic education of how young students deal with learning settings that allow a data-based approach to probability. By using the micro-structure ofExpand
Statistical inference and Aristotle's Rhetoric.
  • R. R. Macdonald
  • Mathematics, Medicine
  • The British journal of mathematical and statistical psychology
  • 2004
It is proposed that statistical tests work in the same way--in that they are based on examples, invoke the analogy of a model and use the size of the effect under test as a sign that the chance hypothesis is unlikely. Expand
Spencer-Brown vs. Probability and Statistics: Entropy's Testimony on Subjective and Objective Randomness
The role of entropy in Bayesian statistics is analyzed, focusing on its use as a tool for detection, recognition and validation of eigen-solutions in cognitive constructivism epistemological framework. Expand
Inference and the introductory statistics course
This article sets out some of the rationale and arguments for making major changes to the teaching and learning of statistical inference in introductory courses at our universities by changing from aExpand
Spencer-Brown vs. Probability and Statistics: The Testimony of Entropy on Subjective and Objective Randomness
This article analyses the role of entropy in Bayesian Statistics, focusing on its use as a tool for detection, recognition and validation of eigen-solutions. "Objects as eigen-solutions" is a keyExpand
A framework for thinking about informal statistical inference
Informal inferential reasoning has shown some promise in developing students’ deeper understanding of statistical processes. This paper presents a framework to think about three key principles ofExpand
In defense of the subtle prejudice concept: a retort
Responds to Coenders et al (see record 2001-06995-005) experiment replication and comments on the article by T. F. Pettigrew and R. W. Meertens' (see record 1995-28884-001) which investigated blatantExpand
Verstehen (causal/interpretative understanding), Erklären (law-governed description/prediction), and Empirical Legal Studies
“For empirical work in social science to carry weight, the research must be able to show that the researcher knows the concepts the actors are using. [:::] Do the subjects have the same understandingExpand
Limits of Econometrics
In the social and behavioral sciences, far-reaching claims are often made for the superiority of advanced quantitative methods by those who manage to ignore the far-reaching assumptions behind theExpand


The discourses of science
Preface Introduction: The Cartesian Syndrome 1: The Paradox of Scientific Method 2: From Method to Rhetoric 3: The Rhetoric of Science 4: Scientific Dialectics 5: The Dialectical Model of Science 6:Expand
Knowledge and Persuasion in Economics
Is economics a science? Deidre McCloskey says 'Yes, but'. Yes, economics measures and predicts, but - like other sciences - it uses literary methods too. Economists use stories as geologists do, andExpand
International Peace Project in the Middle East
This prospective social experiment tests a new theory and technology for alleviating violent conflict through reducing societal stress in an underlying field of “collective consciousness.” It wasExpand
The nature of mathematical knowledge