• Corpus ID: 151724218

Statistical Spin: Linguistic Obfuscation—The Art of Overselling the CBT Evidence Base

@inproceedings{Dalal2015StatisticalSL,
  title={Statistical Spin: Linguistic Obfuscation—The Art of Overselling the CBT Evidence Base},
  author={Farhad Dalal},
  year={2015}
}
This paper takes a close look at two interlinked studies on mindfulness based cognitive therapy (MBCT), Teasdale and colleagues, 2000 and Ma and Teasdale, 2004. The second study corroborates the findings of the first study to claim that MBCT is a cost-effective treatment that prevents the recurrence of depression in 50% of the population. A close reading of the statistical and linguistic manipulations reveals that the outcomes are closer to 25%, and then too for a very limited population. In… 

Figures from this paper

Mindfulness: The Bottled Water of the Therapy Industry
The rise of mindfulness in the Western world as both therapy and instrument of personal development in recent decades has little to do with its superior merits—which fade under critical analysis.
The Future Revisited
45 1 Formerly Consultant Psychotherapist, Cassel, St. George’s, and Maudsley Hospitals and Tavistock Clinic. Correspondence should be addressed to Malcolm Pines, MRCP, MRCPsych, DPM, 21 Dealtry Road,
Psychology in the Age of Austerity
Researchers have established the detrimental influence of austerity measures on the mental health practices. What is relatively unexplored, however, is the manner in which austerity policies and
Introduction: Towards a Vital Feminist Politics
Moving beyond entrenched biology-culture, structure-agency impasses this chapter opens up our exploration of the entanglement of biopsychosocial forces that shape the gendered phenomenon of
An exploration of Clinical Psychologist and Educational Psychologist constructs of mental health in the context of secondary school aged children
Over the past decade, Mental Health (MH) has increasingly appeared on the ‘school agenda’, both in terms of rising levels of MH difficulties in the student population, and also the expectation that
Group Analysis in the Time of Austerity: Neo-liberalism, Managerialism and Evidence-Based Research
In the current climate of cuts and austerity, efficiencies and evidence, targets and outcomes, has group analysis anything to offer and can it survive? This article looks closely at the assumptions
Reconfiguring Recovery Beyond Linearity
Promoting habits of coping through cognitive behaviour therapy has become a standard policy response to depression, yet such neoliberal appeals to self-care ignore the performative demands of gender

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 16 REFERENCES
Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy for depression: replication and exploration of differential relapse prevention effects.
TLDR
MBCT is an effective and efficient way to prevent relapse/recurrence in recovered depressed patients with 3 or more previous episodes and in patients with only 2 episodes, suggesting that these groups represented distinct populations.
Prevention of relapse/recurrence in major depression by mindfulness-based cognitive therapy.
This study evaluated mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT), a group intervention designed to train recovered recurrently depressed patients to disengage from dysphoria-activated depressogenic
Publication decisions revisited: the effect of the outcome of statistical tests on the decision to p
TLDR
Evidence that published results of scientific investigations are not a representative sample of results of all scientific studies is presented and practice leading to publication bias have not changed over a period of 30 years is indicated.
Antidepressants and the placebo response
  • I. Kirsch
  • Medicine, Psychology
    Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences
  • 2009
TLDR
Because they do not incur drug risks, exercise and psychotherapy, which show at benefits at least equal to those of antidepressants, may be a better treatment choice for depressed individuals.
Cognitive behavioural therapy.
TLDR
Cognitive behavioural therapy’s strength lies in that it is a psychological treatment that was developed through scientific research, which means that psychologists have tested ‘what works’ for specific problems, such as anxiety disorders or depression, using scientific studies.
Selective publication of antidepressant trials and its influence on apparent efficacy.
TLDR
A systematic literature search found that among 74 FDA-registered studies, 31%, accounting for 3449 study participants, were not published, and the increase in effect size ranged from 11 to 69% for individual drugs and was 32% overall.
Publication Decisions and their Possible Effects on Inferences Drawn from Tests of Significance—or Vice Versa
Abstract There is some evidence that in fields where statistical tests of significance are commonly used, research which yields nonsignificant results is not published. Such research being unknown to
How many subjects with major depressive disorder meet eligibility requirements of an antidepressant efficacy trial?
TLDR
The majority of subjects with major depressive disorder who apply to participate in an antidepressant efficacy trial do not meet eligibility requirements, and clinicians should bear in mind that the results of these trials may only be directly applicable to a small subset of patients treated in clinical practice.
External validity of randomised controlled trials in asthma: to whom do the results of the trials apply?
TLDR
The proportion of individuals with asthma who would have been eligible for the major asthma RCTs cited in the GINA guidelines may have limited external validity as they have been performed on highly selected patient populations.
...
...