State Capitalism versus Communism: What Happened in the USSR and the PRC?

  title={State Capitalism versus Communism: What Happened in the USSR and the PRC?},
  author={Satyananda J. Gabriel and Stephen A. Resnick and Richard D. Wolff},
  journal={Critical Sociology},
  pages={539 - 556}
Since 1917 analysts have debated what kind of economic system existed in the USSR and the PRC. They mostly juxtaposed `socialism' there to `capitalism' in Western Europe and the USA. The two sides were defined chiefly in terms of private versus state property and markets versus planning. We challenge this debate by means of Marx's focus on the organization of surplus labor. That is, we distinguish capitalism, socialism, and communism according to how these systems differently organize the… 

Introduction and Overview: Actors, Obstacles and Social Change in European and Asian State Capitalist Societies

The social history of state capitalist analysis emerged at least four decades before the Bolshevik-led October Revolution. Despite this analytic tradition, epistemic communities using state

Placing the Analysis of Contemporary State Capitalism within an Evolutionary Discourse

Using Russia's state capitalist economy as an illustration, this paper discusses possible roles that the emergent regime of state capitalism could play in shaping societal evolution along more

Finding a Positive Vision for State Capitalism

Using Russia's state capitalist economy as a case study, this paper discusses the beneficial role that state capitalism could play in moving market economies toward greater equality and social

The Role of Economic Class in Understanding Social Provisioning Processes in the Post-Soviet Transition: The Case of Ukraine

Abstract: Economic class, defined in relation to its actual control over the economy’s productive assets, is the most useful lens for examining power distribution in the post-Soviet transition and

Chinese Capitalism and the Development of the ASEAN Economic Community: A Perspective of Desecuritization

  • Hsing-Chou Sung
  • Economics
    The Sociology of Chinese Capitalism in Southeast Asia
  • 2018
This chapter provides a literature review of the rise of China in Southeast Asia using a framework of desecuritization to investigate China’s desecuritization strategies for reshaping its external

Re-centering Class in Critical Theory

In this paper we pay tribute to Stephen Resnick (1938-2013), a major contributor to the Marxian theoretical tradition. We present a brief introduction to the works of Stephen Resnick and trace his

Justice, Inequality, and the Market: Soviet Sociology in the Transition to Capitalism

This essay examines the role played by Soviet sociology in the USSR’s transition to capitalism. It analyzes the discipline’s contribution to the critique of Soviet socio-economic life during the



Capital: A Critique of Political Economy

Unfinished at the time of Marx's death in 1883 and first published with a preface by Frederick Engels in 1894, the third volume of "Das Kapital" strove to combine the theories and concepts of the two

Does China have an apartheid pass system?

This article makes and defends the claim that China's contemporary household registration system can reasonably be described as a quasi‐apartheid pass system. The historical and ideological

Rural China Takes Off: Institutional Foundations of Economic Reform

In this incisive analysis of one of the most spectacular economic breakthroughs in the Deng era, Jean C. Oi shows how and why Chinese rural-based industry has become the fastest growing economic

Class Theory and History: Capitalism and Communism in the USSR

Introduction Part I: Communism 1. A General Class Theory The Classical Tradition Our Basic Terms Utopia and Communism: A Brief Digression A Concrete Communism Communist Class Structures:

The Rural-Urban Divide: Economic Disparities and Interactions in China

This book describes and explains the remarkably large rural-urban divide in economic well-being that exists in China. How did it come about? How is it maintained, in the face of equilibrating market

Sources of Chinese Economic Growth, 1978-1996

This analysis of the political economy of growth in the era of Deng Xiaoping takes issue with the growth-accounting methodologies and market-centred explanations which characterize so much of the

Restructuring the Soviet Economic Bureaucracy

In Restructuring the Soviet Economic Bureaucracy, Paul R. Gregory takes an inside look at how the system worked and why it has traditionally been so resistant to change. Gregory's findings shed light

The political economy of rural development in China: reflections on current rural policy

The paper examines some of the main political economy dynamics of the policy initiatives on rural development that have been taken since 2003, and provides an overview of the main issues that they

The political economy of development in India

Pranab Bardhan warns readers that he is painting a "vast panorama" in a "few quick, impetuous brush-strokes" (p. vii). Would that his fellow economists might follow this plunge into realism, even if

Chinese Capitalism and the Modernist Vision

Contents List of Acronyms 1 Theory Matters 1 2 Social Contracts and the Rural-Urban Divide 41 3 Working for Capitalism: Labor Market Reform 103 4 State Capitalism in Rural China 188 5 State