Speed-accuracy tradeoffs in animal decision making.

@article{Chittka2009SpeedaccuracyTI,
  title={Speed-accuracy tradeoffs in animal decision making.},
  author={Lars Chittka and Peter Skorupski and Nigel E. Raine},
  journal={Trends in ecology \& evolution},
  year={2009},
  volume={24 7},
  pages={
          400-7
        }
}
The traditional emphasis when measuring performance in animal cognition has been overwhelmingly on accuracy, independent of decision time. However, more recently, it has become clear that tradeoffs exist between decision speed and accuracy in many ecologically relevant tasks, for example, prey and predator detection and identification; pollinators choosing between flower species; and spatial exploration strategies. Obtaining high-quality information often increases sampling time, especially… Expand

Figures and Topics from this paper

A multi-level approach to quantify speed-accuracy trade-offs in great tits (Parus major)
TLDR
Examination of foraging context in wild-caught great tits finds that great tits exhibit among-individual variation in speed-accuracy trade-offs: some individuals predictably made relatively slow but accurate decisions, whereas others were predictably faster but less accurate. Expand
Decision Making and Behavioral Choice during Predator Avoidance
TLDR
Samples from the current literature on anti-predator decision making in invertebrates are reviewed, from single neurons to complex behaviors, and recent progress in understanding the mechanisms underlying value-based behavioral decisions is discussed. Expand
Speed–accuracy trade-off and its consequences in a scramble competition context
TLDR
This work used group-feeding zebra finches to determine how search speed affects food detection accuracy and how a potential speed–accuracy trade-off influences feeding success, and found that feeding success was positively predicted by an individual's food detection probability, whereas it was unrelated to hopping speed. Expand
Rapid Decision-Making with Side-Specific Perceptual Discrimination in Ants
TLDR
It is suggested that first-order olfactory processing centers (up to the antennal lobes) are likely to play a key role in ant nestmate recognition, and a reappraisal of the mechanisms underlying social recognition in insects is asked. Expand
Evidence for the Speed–Value Trade-Off: Human and Monkey Decision Making Is Magnitude Sensitive
TLDR
The results endorse the idea that neural decision systems make use of the same basic principle of value sensitivity in order to resolve costly deadlocks and thus improve long-term reward intake. Expand
Putting mechanisms in foraging theory: the role of computational mechanisms in optimal decision making
TLDR
This paper uses the classic ‘diet’ model of optimal foraging theory (OFT) to investigate the evolution of decision-making mechanisms at both the computational and the algorithmic level and presents two sequential sampling models, which differ in the way information is internally represented and used. Expand
An Extra Dimension to Decision-Making in Animals: The Three-way Trade-off between Speed, Effort per-Unit-Time and Accuracy
TLDR
It is predicted that the ability to modulate effort levels will be widespread in nature, and testable predictions are laid out that could be used to detect adaptive modulation of effort levels in laboratory and field studies. Expand
Bumblebees Express Consistent, but Flexible, Speed-Accuracy Tactics Under Different Levels of Predation Threat
TLDR
The findings show that while individual bees remain relatively consistent in terms of whether they place greater emphasis on speed or accuracy under predation threat, they can respond flexibly to the additional time costs of detecting predators. Expand
Context-Dependent Urgency Influences Speed–Accuracy Trade-Offs in Decision-Making and Movement Execution
TLDR
It is observed that the vigor of saccades performed during the decision process was higher in fast than in slow blocks, suggesting the influence of a context-dependent global arousal, and SATs for deciding and acting are influenced by a shared urgency/vigor signal. Expand
An Evolutionary Perspective on Information Processing
TLDR
This work discusses work that applies models from fields such as signal detection theory and Bayesian decision theory to animal behavior and uses the case of Bayesian updating to make the distinction between a description of behavior at the level of optimal decisions and a mechanistic account of how decisions are made. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 81 REFERENCES
Diversity of speed-accuracy strategies benefits social insects
TLDR
There is consistent within-colony variance between honeybee workers in their speed-accuracy approach in a flower discrimination task and that varying the proportion of rewarding flowers changes the relationship between foraging strategy and rate of nectar collection. Expand
Visual Search and Decision Making in Bees: Time, Speed, and Accuracy
An insect searching a meadow for flowers may detect several flowers from different species per second, so the task of choosing the right flowers rapidly is not trivial. Here we apply concepts fromExpand
Hastiness, brain size and predation regime affect the performance of wild guppies in a spatial memory task
TLDR
It is shown that the careful observation of an animal's strategy for solving spatial problems may reveal subtle differences that are associated with ecology and brain size, as well as the difference in brain size in relation to predation regime. Expand
Decision-making with multiple alternatives
TLDR
This work measured behavioral and physiological responses of monkeys on a two- and four-choice direction-discrimination decision task and observed a time-dependent rise in firing rates that may impose a deadline for deciding. Expand
Psychophysics: Bees trade off foraging speed for accuracy
TLDR
Bees are the first example of an insect to show between-individual and within-individual speed– accuracy trade-offs, and each bee will sacrifice speed in favour of accuracy when errors are penalized. Expand
Noise, cost and speed-accuracy trade-offs: decision-making in a decentralized system
TLDR
It is concluded that noise and time-cost of assessing alternative choices are likely to be significant for T. albipennis' decision-making mechanism, and proposed that a decentralized control algorithm based on this emigration behaviour may be derived for applications in engineering domains and specify the characteristics of the problems to which it should be suited. Expand
Speed versus accuracy in collective decision making
TLDR
This work shows that Leptothorax albipennis ants can lower their quorum thresholds between benign and harsh conditions to adjust their speed–accuracy trade–off, and that in harsh conditions these ants rely much more on individual decision making than collective decision making. Expand
Speed-Accuracy Tradeoffs and False Alarms in Bee Responses to Cryptic Predators
TLDR
Bumblebees in the cryptic-spider treatment made a functional decision to trade off reduced foraging efficiency via increased inspection times and false-alarm rates against higher potential fitness loss from being injured or eaten. Expand
Timing and Foraging: Gibbon's Scalar Expectancy Theory and Optimal Patch Exploitation
Abstract We present a study that links optimal foraging theory (OFT) to behavioral timing. OFT's distinguishing feature is the use of models that compute the most advantageous behavior for aExpand
Mammalian choices: combining fast-but-inaccurate and slow-but-accurate decision-making systems
TLDR
This work represents the slower (but more accurate) cortical system as the integration of sensory evidence over time until a certain level of confidence is reached, and considers how two such systems should be combined optimally for a range of information linkage mechanisms. Expand
...
1
2
3
4
5
...