Special Section: The Problem of Psychology and the Integration of Human Knowledge

@article{Henriques2008SpecialST,
  title={Special Section: The Problem of Psychology and the Integration of Human Knowledge},
  author={Gregg R. Henriques},
  journal={Theory \& Psychology},
  year={2008},
  volume={18},
  pages={731 - 755}
}
  • G. Henriques
  • Published 1 December 2008
  • Psychology
  • Theory & Psychology
The central thesis of this essay is that the problem of psychology lies at the very heart of the difficulties associated with integrating human knowledge. The startling consequence of this insight is that it means the solution to psychology's epistemological woes opens up a new pathway for achieving unified knowledge. A brief overview of the fragmentation of knowledge will be offered and special attention will be paid to Wilson's (1998) proposal. The problem of psychology, Wilson's failure to… 

Figures from this paper

Unifying Psychology: Shared Ontology and the Continuum of Practical Assumptions

Critics have described psychology as a science impaired by disunity. The most recent special issue of Review of General Psychology sought to specifically address this concern, seeking perspectives

Special Section: The Critical Role of the Dialectic in Viable Metatheory

Henriques (2008) persuasively argues that his Tree of Knowledge (ToK) System provides a more viable alternative to Wilson's (1998) consilience model as a framework for integrating knowledge generated

The Tree of Knowledge System: A New Map for Big History

TLDR
The article suggests that there is potential for a fruitful synergy between the historical emphasis of BH with the more psychological focus of the ToK System, and compares and contrasts its depiction of cosmic evolution as four “dimensions of existence” with Big History’s eight thresholds of complexity.

Defining Behavior and its Relationship to the Science of Psychology

TLDR
A “Periodic Table of Behavior” derived from Henriques’ Tree of Knowledge System is introduced to map the different kinds of behaviors that are described and examined by different sciences and argues how the basic science of psychology can be effectively defined as the science of mental behavior going forward.

Toward a Metaphysical Empirical Psychology

  • G. Henriques
  • Psychology, Philosophy
    Re-envisioning Theoretical Psychology
  • 2019
As evidenced by textbook definitions and descriptions, modern academic psychology emphasizes the empirical side of the field, that is the experimental and data driven analysis that allow one to

The neurosciences and the search for a unified psychology: the science and esthetics of a single framework

  • H. Stam
  • Psychology
    Front. Psychol.
  • 2015
TLDR
It is argued that psychology is in fact reasonably unified around its methods and its commitment to functional explanations, an indeterminate functionalism.

Toward a Cultural Evolutionary Psychology: Why the Evolutionary Approach does not Imply Reductionism or Determinism.

TLDR
This target article argues why the pre-paradigmatic status of psychology is a problem rather than a richness of perspectives, and why evolutionary meta-theory is not incompatible with subjectivity.

On the Possibility of Unification

In this article it is argued that—in spite of contrary semantic and substantive criticisms that have been put forward—the crisis in psychology is a real problem facing the discipline. The crisis is

The Theoretical and Empirical Foundations of the Sociocultural-Interdeterminist Dialogical Metatheory of the Integration of Psychological Knowledge

This article examines the problem of finding the theoretical and empirical foundations of the integration of psychological knowledge in the context of a sociocultural-interdeterminist dialogical

The role of mechanisms, integration, and unification in science and psychology

I assume the importance of unifying theories in science but suggest that psychologists do not understand the concept. To clarify, I distinguish unification from both mechanisms and from integration.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 62 REFERENCES

The Tree of Knowledge System and the Theoretical Unification of Psychology

TLDR
A new view suggests that psychology can be thought of as existing between the central insights of B. F. Skinner and Sigmund Freud, and Skinner's fundamental insight is merged with cognitive neuroscience to understand how mind emerges out of life.

The Psychology of Psychology

Rhetorical calls for disciplinary unity and vision currently lack any grounding in historically informed analysis of Psychology's character and functions, while the historians of Psychology providing

Toward a useful mass movement.

TLDR
This article articulate how the foundation can be laid for the development of a useful mass movement that could transform the discipline of psychology in a manner that unleashes its constructive potential, while at the same time it attempts to address many of the concerns about the proposal raised by the contributors to these two special issues.

Psychology defined.

TLDR
A new form of knowledge technology is used to diagnose psychology's epistemological woes and provide a solution to the difficulties that divides the field into two broad, logically consistent domains.

Pluralism in the sciences is not easily dismissed.

  • W. Viney
  • Psychology
    Journal of clinical psychology
  • 2004
The unification scheme proposed by Henriques in his article "Psychology Defined" (this issue) holds promise as a coherent and comprehensive approach to psychology and as a helpful way to think about

Defining psychology: what can it do for us?

  • D. Haaga
  • Psychology
    Journal of clinical psychology
  • 2004
TLDR
Henriques' argument that psychology, though unified and coherent, actually spans two realms-psychological formalism and human psychology ("the science of human behavior at the individual level"), seems likely to improve the clarity of the concept.

Justifying the Justification Hypothesis: scientific-humanism, Equilintegration (EI) Theory, and the Beliefs, Events, and Values Inventory (BEVI).

  • C. Shealy
  • Philosophy
    Journal of clinical psychology
  • 2005
TLDR
Two complementary parts are divided into consideration of justification dynamics and exemplars from a scientific-humanist perspective and an examination of how justification systems and processes have been studied vis-a-vis research and theory on beliefs and values as well as an extant model--Equilintegration (EI) Theory--and method--the Beliefs, Events, and Values Inventory (BEVI).

Integrative Pluralism

The `fact' of pluralism in science is nosurprise. Yet, if science is representing andexplaining the structure of the oneworld, why is there such a diversity ofrepresentations and explanations in

Testing the limits of Henriques' proposal: Wittgensteinian lessons and hermeneutic dialogue.

  • B. Slife
  • Psychology
    Journal of clinical psychology
  • 2005
The limits of Henriques' "overarching conceptions" approach to defining psychology is first tested by comparing and contrasting his conceptions to two burgeoning movements within psychology:

Toward a consilient science of psychology.

TLDR
The hybrid interdisciplinary domain of cognitive neuroscience is described, which provides an empirically testable metatheory and a promising consilient bridge between psychology and the natural sciences.
...