Some proposals for reviving the philosophy of mathematics

  title={Some proposals for reviving the philosophy of mathematics},
  author={R. Hersh},
  journal={Advances in Mathematics},
  • R. Hersh
  • Published 1979
  • Mathematics
  • Advances in Mathematics
By “philosophy of mathematics” I mean the working philosophy of the professional mathematician, the philosophical attitude toward his work that is assumed by the researcher, teacher, or user of mathematics. What I propose needs reviving is the discussion of philosophical issues by working mathematicians, especially the central issue-the analysis of truth and meaning in mathematical discourse. The purpose of this article is, first, to describe the philosophical plight of the working… Expand
Making room for mathematicians in the philosophy of mathematics
ConclusionWe began this essay with the concept of mathematician and the realization that a concept of mathematician could be idealized in various ways. We drew an elementary distinction betweenExpand
Remarks on the history and philosophy of mathematics
The history and philosophy of mathematics bear only on the periphery of the work of most mathematicians whether they are teachers or researchers. As a consequence there builds up a ' received view'Expand
Foundations and Philosophy of Mathematics
Philosophy of mathematics does not coincide as such with the research on the foundations of mathematics. This confluence, however, occurred at the beginning of the twentieth century, in the frameworkExpand
Empirical Methods in Mathematics
Philosophy of mathematics has changed considerably during the last few years. The classical distinction between logicism, formalism and intuitionism, a major topic a few decades ago, has become lessExpand
Fourteen Arguments in Favour of a Formalist Philosophy of Real Mathematics
The formalist philosophy of mathematics (in its purest, most extreme version) is widely regarded as a “discredited position”. This pure and extreme version of formalism is called by some authorsExpand
Fourteen Arguments in Favour of a Formalist Philosophy of Real Mathematics
The formalist philosophy of mathematics (in its purest, most extreme version) is widely regarded as a "discredited position". This pure and extreme version of formalism is called by some authorsExpand
Philosophy of mathematics: an outlook
It is concluded that mathematics, in order to be a vibrant living discipline, cannot be devoid of human experts, such as, mathematicians or computer scientists or philosophers, at least for the foreseeable future. Expand
Meaning and Formalism in Mathematics
  • E. Dubinsky
  • Computer Science
  • Int. J. Comput. Math. Learn.
  • 2000
Although using formalism to construct meaning is a very difficult method for students to learn, it may be that this is the only route to learning large portions of mathematics at the upper high school and tertiary levels and a pedagogical strategy for helping students travel this route is outlined. Expand
Anti-foundationalist Philosophy of Mathematics and Mathematical Proofs
Abstract The Euclidean ideal of mathematics as well as all the foundational schools in the philosophy of mathematics have been contested by the new approach, called the “maverick” trend in theExpand
Mathematics as Problem Solving
Contrary to the belief of several mathematicians that philosophy is irrelevant to mathematics, this chapter argues that philosophy is relevant to it, because it may expose the inadequacy of someExpand


A Renaissance of Empiricism in the Recent Philosophy of Mathematics*
  • I. Lakatos
  • Philosophy
  • The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
  • 1976
According to logical empiricist orthodoxy, while science is a posteriori, contentful and (at least in principle) fallible, mathematics is a priori, tautologous and infallible. It may therefore comeExpand
Mathematics, Matter, And Method
Introduction 1. Truth and necessity in mathematics 2. The thesis that mathematics is logic 3. Mathematics without foundations 4. What is mathematical truth? 5. Philosophy of physics 6. An examinationExpand
Fidelity in mathematical discourse: is one and one really two?
The discovery of mathematical logic convinced many mathematicians and philosophers that this was the royal road to foundations and Gottlob Frege in his masterpiece The Foundations of Arithmetic not only sketched the logical deduction of arithmetic but inveighed against psychologism andhistoricism in philosophy. Expand
Developments in Mathematical Education: Modern mathematics: does it exist?
The future historian of mathematics will not fail to be amazed by the extent of the movement of the 1960s known as Modern Mathematics. This movement now appears to have reached its zenith, and theExpand
The Work of Nicholas Bourbaki
Thank you for your kind words on my behalf. I must admit that it is a great pleasure for me to escape from my duties as dean and spend a week in such a warm and friendly atmosphere. The tradition ofExpand
The Locus of Mathematical Reality: An Anthropological Footnote
  • L. White
  • Mathematics
  • Philosophy of Science
  • 1947
"He's [the Red King's] dreaming now," said Tweedledee: "and what do you think he's dreaming about?" Alice said, "Nobody can guess that." "Why, about you!" Tweedledee exclaimed, clapping his handsExpand
  • I. Lakatos
  • Mathematics
  • The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
  • 1963
Introduction § 1. A Problem and a Conjecture. §2. A Proof. § 3. Criticism of the Proof by Counterexamples which are Local but not Global. § 4. Criticism of the Conjecture by Global Counterexamples.Expand
Fidelity in mathematical discourse
  • Amer. Math. Monthly
  • 1972
Visual geometry, computer graphics, and theorems of perceived type, in ‘‘Influence of Computing on Mathematical Research and Education,”
  • Proc. Symp. Appl. Math.,
  • 1974