Some comments on "Energy psychology: A review of the evidence": Premature conclusions based on incomplete evidence?

@article{Pignotti2009SomeCO,
  title={Some comments on "Energy psychology: A review of the evidence": Premature conclusions based on incomplete evidence?},
  author={Monica G. Pignotti and Bruce A. Thyer},
  journal={Psychotherapy},
  year={2009},
  volume={46 2},
  pages={
          257-61
        }
}
A review of the evidence on energy psychology (EP) was published in this journal (see record 2008-07317-008). Although Feinstein's stated intention of reviewing the evidence is one we support, we noted that important EP studies were omitted from the review that did not confirm the claims being made by EP proponents. We also identify other problems with the review, such as the lack of specific inclusion and exclusion criteria, misportrayal of criticism of EP, incorrectly characterizing one of… 

The current status of energy psychology: Extraordinary claims with less than ordinary evidence

Proponents of energy psychology techniques, such as Thought Field Therapy and Emotional Freedom Techniques, have sought "empirically supported therapy" status despite an unsupported and implausible

Facts, paradigms, and anomalies in the acceptance of energy psychology: A rejoinder to McCaslin's (2009) and Pignotti and Thyer's (2009) comments on Feinstein (2008a).

TLDR
The exchange is shown to reflect a paradigmatic clash within the professional community, with energy psychology having become a lightning rod for this controversy.

Distinguishing Scientific From Pseudoscientific Psychotherapies: Evaluating the Role of Theoretical Plausibility, With a Little Help From Reverend Bayes

[Clin Psychol Sci Prac 18: 105–112, 2011] In their stimulating article, David and Montgomery (2011) underscore the importance of identifying pseudoscientific and potentially harmful

A narrative systematic review of the effectiveness of Emotional Freedoms Technique (EFT)

TLDR
EFT was shown to be effective in treating Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, Fibromyalgia, Phobias, test anxiety and athletic performance, and may be an efficient and effective intervention for a range of psychological disorders.

Evidence-Based Practices Do Not Exist

The original process model of evidence-based practice (EBP) is described, and contrasted with the empirically supported treatments (EST) initiative which designated selected interventions as meeting

Development and psychometric evaluation of a clinical beliefs questionnaire for licensed psychologists

TLDR
A questionnaire to appraise specific clinical knowledge domains and attitudes toward science among licensed, doctoral-level practitioners of clinical psychology was developed to detect the presence of knowledge pertaining to legitimate and questionable treatment techniques used in contemporary clinical practice.

Novel Unsupported and Empirically Supported Therapies: Patterns of Usage Among Licensed Clinical Social Workers

TLDR
Survey of Licensed Clinical Social Workers across the United States found that NUST usage was related to female gender and trauma specialization, and even within the group of LCSWs with a CBT orientation, clinical experience was rated more highly than research evidence.

What Does Energy Have to Do with Energy Psychology

An obstacle to professional acceptance of the growing body of research supporting the effi cacy of energy psychology is the vague use of the term energy in the fi eld’s name and explanatory

The efficacy of acupoint stimulation in the treatment of psychological distress: A meta-analysis.

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 31 REFERENCES

Energy psychology: A review of the preliminary evidence.

TLDR
Although the evidence is still preliminary, energy psychology has reached the minimum threshold for being designated as an evidence-based treatment, with one form having met the APA Division 12 criteria as a "probably efficacious treatment" for specific phobias; another for maintaining weight loss.

Systematic Reviews in the Social Sciences: A Practical Guide

Such diverse thinkers as Lao-Tze, Confucius, and U.S. Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld have all pointed out that we need to be able to tell the difference between real and assumed knowledge. The

Moving from empirically supported treatment lists to practice guidelines in psychotherapy: the role of the placebo concept.

TLDR
The use of placebos is the "gold standard" in studies of investigational drugs, and of other medical procedures as well, but they are not necessary in psychotherapy research.

Sakai et al. is not an adequate demonstration of TFT effectiveness.

  • J. Lohr
  • Psychology
    Journal of clinical psychology
  • 2001
TLDR
A review of the theory and research on TFT efficacy indicates that the theoretical basis for the specific treatment is unfounded and that adequately controlled efficacy research has yet to be conducted.

Credentialed Persons, Credentialed Knowledge

The vast experimental literature on human error agrees with history of medicine, folklore, and superstition In discrediting knowledge claims based solely on anecdotal impressions. Since clinical

Evaluation of a meridian-based intervention, Emotional Freedom Techniques (EFT), for reducing specific phobias of small animals.

TLDR
It is suggested that a single treatment session using EFT to reduce specific phobias can produce valid behavioral and subjective effects.

A systematic clinical demonstration of promising PTSD treatment approaches.

Traumatic Incident Reduction, Visual-Kinesthetic Disassociation, Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing, and Thought Field Therapy were investigated through a systematic clinical demonstration

Thought Field Therapy

Thought Field Therapy (TFT) is a novel therapy that employs finger tapping on purported acupressure points. Over the past decade, TFT, promoted on the Internet and through testimonials of fast cures,

Thought Field Therapy clinical applications: utilization in an HMO in behavioral medicine and behavioral health services.

TLDR
Paired t-tests of pre- and posttreatment SUD were statistically significant in 31 categories reviewed, and within-session decreases of SUD are preliminary data that call for controlled studies to examine validity, reliability, and maintenance of effects over time.

A close look at therapeutic touch.

TLDR
Twenty-one experienced TT practitioners were unable to detect the investigator's "energy field." Their failure to substantiate TT's most fundamental claim is unrefuted evidence that the claims of TT are groundless and that further professional use is unjustified.