Some Negative Remarks on Operational Approaches to Quantum Theory

  title={Some Negative Remarks on Operational Approaches to Quantum Theory},
  author={Christopher A. Fuchs and Blake C. Stacey},
Over the last 10 years there has been an explosion of “operational reconstructions” of quantum theory. This is great stuff: For, through it, we come to see the myriad ways in which the quantum formalism can be chopped into primitives and, through clever toil, brought back together to form a smooth whole. An image of an IQ-Block puzzle comes to mind, There is no doubt that this is invaluable work, particularly for our understanding of the intricate… 
On Relationalist Reconstructions of Quantum Theory
One appealing feature of Carlo Rovelli’s proposal for “Relational Quantum Mechanics” [1] is that it offered a challenge for those who prefer technical work over slinging sentences: the reconstruction
Introducing Quantum Entanglement to First-Year Students: Resolving the Trilemma
While quantum mechanics (QM) is covered at length in introductory physics textbooks, the concept of quantum entanglement is typically not covered at all, despite its importance in the rapidly growing
Husserl, the mathematization of nature, and the informational reconstruction of quantum theory
As is well known, the late Husserl warned against the dangers of reifying and objectifying the mathematical models that operate at the heart of our physical theories. Although Husserl’s worries were
Introducing the Qplex: a novel arena for quantum theory
Abstract We reconstruct quantum theory starting from the premise that, as Asher Peres remarked, “Unperformed experiments have no results.” The tools of quantum information theory, and in particular
Are Non-Boolean Event Structures the Precedence or Consequence of Quantum Probability?
This paper will avail of Pitowsky's program, along with its extensions in the work of Jeffrey Bub and William Demopoulos, to better explicate QBism's aims and goals.
The Completeness of Quantum Mechanics and the Determinateness and Consistency of Intersubjective Experience: Wigner's Friend and Delayed Choice.
A realist psi-epistemic take on QM is provided that saves the absoluteness of observed events and the completeness of QM, without giving up free will or locality and is coupled with a take on neutral monism that eliminates the hard problem of consciousness.
Why the Tsirelson Bound? Bub’s Question and Fuchs’ Desideratum
It is shown that the quantum correlations and quantum states corresponding to the Bell basis states, which uniquely produce the Tsirelson bound for the Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) quantity, can be derived from conservation per no preferred reference frame (NPRF).
No Preferred Reference Frame at the Foundation of Quantum Mechanics
Quantum information theorists have created axiomatic reconstructions of quantum mechanics (QM) that are very successful at identifying precisely what distinguishes quantum probability theory from
Quantum Theory as Symmetry Broken by Vitality
I summarize a research program that aims to reconstruct quantum theory from a fundamental physical principle that, while a quantum system has no intrinsic hidden variables, it can be understood using
The Relativity Principle at the Foundation of Quantum Mechanics
Quantum information theorists have created axiomatic reconstructions of quantum mechanics (QM) that are very successful at identifying precisely what distinguishes quantum probability theory from


Quantum Mechanics as Quantum Information (and only a little more)
In this paper, I try once again to cause some good-natured trouble. The issue remains, when will we ever stop burdening the taxpayer with conferences devoted to the quantum foundations? The suspicion
Information-Theoretic Postulates for Quantum Theory
Why are the laws of physics formulated in terms of complex Hilbert spaces? Are there natural and consistent modifications of quantum theory that could be tested experimentally? This book chapter
Quantum Theory and Beyond: Is Entanglement Special?
Quantum theory makes the most accurate empirical predictions and yet it lacks simple, comprehensible physical principles from which the theory can be uniquely derived. A broad class of probabilistic
Four and a Half Axioms for Finite Dimensional Quantum Mechanics
I discuss a set of strong, but probabilistically intelligible, axioms from which one can almost derive the appratus of finite dimensional quantum theory. Stated informally, these require that systems
Quantum-Bayesian Coherence
It is argued that the Born Rule should be seen as an empirical addition to Bayesian reasoning itself, and how to view it as a normative rule in addition to usual Dutch-book coherence is shown.
Reformulating and Reconstructing Quantum Theory
We provide a reformulation of finite dimensional quantum theory in the circuit framework in terms of mathematical axioms, and a reconstruction of quantum theory from operational postulates. The
Questioning the rules of the game
We know how to use the “rules” of quantum physics to build lasers, microchips, and nuclear power plants, but when students question the rules themselves, the best answer we can give is often, “The
This is a one-to-one translation of a German-written Ph.D. thesis from 1999. Quantum designs are sets of orthogonal projection matrices in finite(b)-dimensional Hilbert spaces. A fundamental
A Quantum-Bayesian Route to Quantum-State Space
In the quantum-Bayesian approach to quantum foundations, a quantum state is viewed as an expression of an agent’s personalist Bayesian degrees of belief, or probabilities, concerning the results of
Properties of QBist State Spaces
Every quantum state can be represented as a probability distribution over the outcomes of an informationally complete measurement. But not all probability distributions correspond to quantum states.