Some Historical Issues and Paradoxes Regarding the Concept of Infinity: An Apos Analysis: Part 2

  title={Some Historical Issues and Paradoxes Regarding the Concept of Infinity: An Apos Analysis: Part 2},
  author={Ed Dubinsky and Kirk Weller and Michael A. McDonald and Anne Brown},
  journal={Educational Studies in Mathematics},
This is Part 2 of a two-part study of how APOS theory may be used to provide cognitive explanations of how students and mathematicians might think about the concept of infinity. We discuss infinite processes, describe how the mental mechanisms of interiorization and encapsulation can be used to conceive of an infinite process as a completed totality, explain the relationship between infinite processes and the objects that may result from them, and apply our analyses to certain mathematical… 

Glimpses of Infinity: Intuitions, Paradoxes, and Cognitive Leaps

This dissertation examines undergraduate and graduate university students' emergent conceptions of mathematical infinity. In particular, my research focuses on identifying the cognitive leaps

Totality as a Possible New Stage and Levels in APOS Theory

It seems clear that explicit pedagogical strategies are needed to help most students construct each of the stages in APOS Theory and that levels which describe the progressions from one stage to another may point to such strategies.

How to Act? A Question of Encapsulating Infinity

This article investigates some of the specific features involved in accommodating the idea of actual infinity as it appears in set theory. It focuses on the conceptions of two individuals with

From Piaget’s Theory to APOS Theory: Reflective Abstraction in Learning Mathematics and the Historical Development of APOS Theory

The aim of this chapter is to explain where APOS Theory came from and when it originated. A discussion of the main components of APOS Theory—the mental stages or structures of Action, Process,

In search of $$\aleph _{0}$$ℵ0: how infinity can be created

A philosophical account of actual mathematical infinity that does not demand ontologically or epistemologically problematic assumptions is developed, based on a simple metaphor that is valid in terms of mathematical practice, as well as in line with empirical data on arithmetical cognition.

Mental Structures and Mechanisms: APOS Theory and the Construction of Mathematical Knowledge

The focus of this chapter is a discussion of the characteristics of the mental structures that constitute APOS Theory, Action, Process, Object, and Schema, and the mechanisms, such as

Being mathematical : an exploration of epistemological implications of embodied cognition

In this thesis I explore epistemological implications of embodied cognition in the hope of developing my apprehension of what it means to think mathematically. I allow my understanding of embodied


The present study aims to examine elementary school teachers’ perceptions about the notion of infinity. In particular, the two aspects of the concept- as a process or as an object- were examined


  • Ami Mamolo
  • Mathematics
    The Mathematics Enthusiast
  • 2009
This study examines undergraduate students' emerging conceptions of infinity as manifested in their engagement with geometric tasks. Students' attempts to reduce the level of abstraction of infinity



Some Historical Issues and Paradoxes Regarding the Concept of Infinity: An Apos-Based Analysis: Part 1

This paper applies APOS Theory to suggest a new explanation of how people might think about the concept of infinity. We propose cognitive explanations, and in some cases resolutions, of various

Infinity: A Cognitive Challenge

Dealing with infinity, an inherently abstract concept which defies concrete representation, involves distinct cognitive difficulties. I first review the research on the development of children's

Tacit Models and Infinity

The paper analyses several examples of tacit influences exerted by mental models on the interpretation of various mathematical concepts in the domain of actual infinity. The influences of the

Young Peoples' Ideas of Infinity

This paper considers views of infinity of young people prior to instruction in the methods mathematicians use in dealing with infinity. To avoid overlap with other papers in this special issue on

Infinity and the Mind: The Science and Philosophy of the Infinite

In Infinity and the Mind, Rudy Rucker leads an excursion to that stretch of the universe he calls the "Mindscape, " where he explores infinity in all its forms: potential and actual, mathematical and

Finite and infinite sets: definitions and intuitions

The study explores the intuitive methods different-aged students use to determine whether a given set is finite or infinite; it also examines the relationship between these methods and the accepted,

Conflicts and Catastrophes in the Learning of Mathematics

The catastrophe theory model is explained in greater detail and the results of a test performed on first-year university students at Warwick University in collaboration with Rolph Schwarzenberger are reported.

A constructive response to `Where mathematics comes from'

Lakoff and Nuñez's bookWhere mathematics comes from: How the embodied mind brings mathematics into being (2000) provided many mathematics education researchers with a novel, and perhaps startling

Rabbi Hasdai Crescas (1340-1410) on Numerical Infinities

IN EVALUATING GALILEO'S STUDY of the paradoxes of the infinite, Carl Boyer declares that his "role was that of a Moses who led his readers within sight of the promised land, but who could not himself

Natural and Formal Infinities

Concepts of infinity usually arise by reflecting on finite experiences and imagining them extended to the infinite. This paper will refer to such personal conception as natural infinities.Research