• Corpus ID: 12523868

Some Guidelines for the Critical Reviewing of Conceptual Papers *

  title={Some Guidelines for the Critical Reviewing of Conceptual Papers *},
  author={A Senior},
* I am deeply indebted to Heinz Klein for the many discussions we had on critical paper reviewing. His thoughts and ideas significantly helped shape this article. I would also like to thank Kalle Lyytinen, Jeff Parsons, Juhani Iivari, and Frank Land for their numerous comments and suggestions. am often asked about the section; in particular about the kinds of papers that are or are not appropriate, how we decide what is and is not appropriate, and, specifically, how we evaluate the submissions… 
Viewpoint: Information systems research strategy
  • G. Gable
  • Computer Science
    The Journal of Strategic Information Systems
  • 2020
The ongoing quest for the IT artifact: Looking back, moving forward
An up-to-date image of contemporary IS research is obtained, and how the IS field has evolved since the 1990s is assessed, on a more recent and broader set of articles.
Why Are Papers Desk Rejected at PAJAIS?: A Practical Guide to Avoiding Rejection
The aim of this editorial is to suggest and provide future authors with the reasons and actions commonly-related to this regard so as to minimize the possibility of getting a desk rejection.
A framework for comparing is research paradigms: how is design science related to other research paradigms?
This paper proposes a framework that can be used to compare IS research paradigms and elucidate and illuminate key differences and issues in their respective perspectives, with particular focus on DSR and its main activities.
Teacher cognition: A powerful phenomenon developing and governing habits of teaching
Teaching has a complex feature being both a cognitive activity as well as a social behavior; thus, it is highly crucial to monitor how teachers develop and govern their habits and behavioral
Creative thinking develops from students' potential; however, the level of ability to think creatively is different for every human being. Many scientists argue that the higher person's education
The Contradiction of Agile Measures: Customer as Focus, but Process as Measured?
The review shows that the focus was on process measurements, while, despite the rhetoric about customer focus and agility, product measurements appear less important, which opens the way for future research to explore the consequences of adopting performance measures related to this high emphasis on the process.
Principles for "Purposefully Constructed Activity Systems" - A Step toward a Body of Knowledge for Information Systems
This paper proposes 20 intrinsic principles and 7 observability principles that apply to any PCAS and that support contextually-focused normative principles from different sources that support a body of knowledge for information systems.
The e-learning persuasion through gamification: an elaboration likelihood model perspective
Purpose The purpose of this theoretical paper is to introduce a conceptual model to investigate e-learning persuasion through gamification elements using the social psychology theory of elaboration
Differentiated Instruction in Chinese Primary and Secondary Schools: A Systematic Literature Review
This study aims to probe into the concepts and use of differentiated instruction (DI) in Chinese primary and secondary schools by means of a systematic literature review from 1995 to 2019. Outcomes


How to review a paper.
The purpose of this article is to define how best to peer review an article and discuss some of the main elements of a good manuscript review, the basic responsibilities of a reviewer, and the rewards and responsibilities that accompany this process.
Crisis in the IS Field? A Critical Reflection on the State of the Discipline
If IS as a field can overcome its internal communications deficits, it might ultimately contribute to the societal challenge of developing a deliberative cyber democracy and thereby help to address the social communication deficit which is a feature of modern mass societies.
Studying Information Technology in Organizations: Research Approaches and Assumptions
It is suggested that much can be gained if a plurality of research perspectives is effectively employed to investigate information systems phenomena and that there exist other philosophical assumptions that can inform studies of the relationships between information technology, people, and organizations.
A Set of Principles for Conducting and Evaluating Interpretive Field Studies in Information Systems
A set of principles for the conduct and evaluation of interpretive field research in information systems is proposed, along with their philosophical rationale, and the usefulness of the principles is illustrated by evaluating three publishedinterpretive field studies drawn from the IS research literature.
Nothing At The Center?: Academic Legitimacy in the Information Systems Field
It is suggested that to remain successful, the IS field needs intellectual discipline in boundary spanning across a “market of ideas” concerning the application of information technology in human enterprise.
Reviewing a manuscript for publication
Social Analyses of Computing: Theoretical Perspectives in Recent Empirical Research
The roles of computer technologies in the workplace, in decision making, in altering power relationships, and in influencing personal privacy are examined and two broad perspectives are contrasted.
The Legacy of LEO: Lessons Learned from an English Tea and Cake Company's Pioneering Efforts in Information Systems
  • R. Mason
  • Business
    J. Assoc. Inf. Syst.
  • 2004
LEO is the acronym for the Lyons Electronic Office, a business-oriented computer system created by J. Lyons & Co. Ltd. Founded in 1887, the company’s teashops had become a British institution. It was
A Program for Research on Management Information Systems
It is argued that most research and development to date on MIS has assumed only one underlying psychological type, one class of problem types, one or two methods of generating evidence, and, finally, one mode of presentation.
A Framework for Research in Computer-Based Management Information Systems
The paper presents a comprehensive framework for research in Management Information Systems MIS, useful not only in understanding and classifying MIS research but also in generating potential hypotheses for future research.