Socialism and the Tragedy of the Commons: Reflections on Environmental Practice in the Soviet Union and Russia

  title={Socialism and the Tragedy of the Commons: Reflections on Environmental Practice in the Soviet Union and Russia},
  author={Natalia Mirovitskaya and Marvin S. Soroos},
  journal={The Journal of Environment \& Development},
  pages={110 - 77}
Socialism can be looked upon as a fourth potential strategy for avoiding Garrett Hardin's "tragedy of the commons." The other three are social pressure, regulations, and division of the resource into private sections. In theory, having a common resource used exclusively by a community, rather than by private parties, eliminates the personal profit motive, thereby opening up possibilities for more rational resource management. Exposés on the severe environmental degradation in the former Soviet… Expand
Natural resource institutions in transformation: the tragedy and glory of the private
The present article focuses on continuity and change in natural resource institutions in post-Soviet Kyrgyzstan. Two main trends have characterised the management of water, agricultural land andExpand
Marxism and ecology a comment on Lipietz
Alain Lipietz's essay deals with the historical and methodological relations between Marxism and ecological politics. On the historical level, he blames Marx's world-view for the ecological andExpand
Environmental policy in transition economies : the effectiveness of pollution charges
Most economists and analysts claim that extended use of pollution charges in environmental policy will have substantial efficiency advantages in countries undergoing transition to market economies.Expand
Environmental Policy in Transition Economies: Will Pollution Charges Work?
Many economists and analysts claim that extended use of pollution charges in environmental policy will have substantial efficiency advantages in transition economies. This article challenges thisExpand
Lukács on Science: A New Act in the Tragedy
Abstract The rejection of the ‘dialectics of nature’ has long been thought of as the most fundamental factor distinguishing Western Marxism from official Soviet-style Marxism. Yet, in Tailism and theExpand
The Role of Institutional Policy Congruity for Sustainable Land Use in the Kulunda Steppe
In Russia and likewise in the Kulunda steppe, only recently, environmental-oriented policy measures have been introduced. Yet these are confronted with the prevailing post-socialist institutionalExpand
Missing the Forest for the Profits: The Role of Multinational Corporations in the International Forest Regime
The international community has placed great hope and invested considerable time in exploring a global forest convention through the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development'sExpand
Nature, labor and gender: Marx, Lipietz and political ecology
I greatly appreciated the insights to be found in "Political Ecology and the Future of Marxism." There has been an interesting usage of the term "political ecology" in France. Bruno Latour hasExpand
Marx and nature : a red and green perspective
Preface Acknowledgements Introduction PART I: NATURE AND HISTORICAL MATERIALISM Requirements of a Social Ecology Nature, Labor, and Production The Natural Bias of Labor Productivity and Surplus LaborExpand
Pollution Charges in a Transition Economy: The Case of Russia
After the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, its legal successor, the Russian Federation, initiated a transformation from a command based to a market-oriented economy. As part of this process, tExpand


Worker/Public Protection: The Double Standard
Abstract This article is the first in a series which will explore the differences in protection from hazards provided to workers and the general public. In this article, the authors explore theExpand
Soviet and post-Soviet economic structure and performance
The administrative-command economy economic history of Russia to 1917 war, communism and the new economic policy (1918-1928) the Soviet industrialization debate (1924-1928) creating theExpand
Russia and America : the roots of economic divergence
This book accounts for the divergence, not conventionally by emphasising the political differences, but by highlighting a longer, more gradual process of interaction between physical humanExpand
The Roots of Modern Environmentalism
An historical, philosophical and ideological background to environmentalism, this book offers an interpretation of the mass of information available to the student.
Troubled Lands: The Legacy Of Soviet Environmental Destruction
The air the water the land solid and hazardous wastes government institutions and environmental policy the environmental movement and "green" politics constraints on protecting the environment.
Chernobyl's lengthening shadow
This article reviews the April 26, 1986 nuclear disaster at Chernobyl. The information presented was gathered through talks between the author and scientists, citizens, and hospital workers inExpand
The tragedy of the commons.
  • G. Hardin
  • Political Science, Sociology
  • Science
  • 1968
The population problem has no technical solution; it requires a fundamental extension in morality.
Ecocide in the USSR: Health And Nature Under Siege
This study describes the ecological damage that occurred in the former USSR during the period of Communist rule and its consequences for both the environment as a whole and for the health of theExpand
Siberia's threatened forests
Will Siberian forests be spared the wholesale destruction suffered by the world's tropical rainforests? The enormous changes now occurring in the former Soviet Union offer opportunities as well asExpand
Kolgarov, Tragedia Socializma (The Tragedy of Socialism), Moscow: 1992. See also Nodari A. Simonia, Socialism in Russia: Theory and Practice, Westport: Conn
  • Transaction Publishers,
  • 1994