Situativity and Symbols: Response to Vera and Simon

@article{Greeno1993SituativityAS,
  title={Situativity and Symbols: Response to Vera and Simon},
  author={James G. Greeno and Joyce L. Moore},
  journal={Cogn. Sci.},
  year={1993},
  volume={17},
  pages={49-59}
}
Vera and Simon (1993) have provided a helpful and welcome challenge in their articulate questioning of the point of view that emphasizes the situated character of action, including cognition and learning. A full discussion of their arguments and examples requires more space than we are allotted for this response, and we are preparing a longer article that will consider the issues they raised in more detail. We also welcome this opportunity to comment briefly on their provocative arguments. 
View via Publisher
onlinelibrary.wiley.com
274 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
4
Background Citations
94
Methods Citations
10
Results Citations
4

274 Citations

Situated action, symbol systems and universal computation
  • A. Wells
  • Psychology
    Minds and Machines
  • 2004
TLDR
It becomes apparent that there are important incompatibilities between the two approaches such that situativity theory cannot be subsumed within the symbol systems approach.
Reconstructing educational psychology: Situated cognition and Deweyian pragmatism
The symbol-processing approach to cognition has been the dominant one in both psychology and education. It has only recently been challenged by those advocating a situated approach based on the…
Communication and Cognition
Summarization is a situationally and communicatively bound cognitive task. In the following, we prepare the discussion of situations where summarization takes place, starting with the communication…
Reconstructing Physical Symbol Systems
TLDR
Another view of representation in connectionist networks is presented and statements about ALVINN by both Vera and Simon and Greeno and Moore are responded to, to reconstruct the PSSH.
THE SITUATIVITY OF KNOWING, LEARNING, AND RESEARCH
The situative perspective shifts the focus of analysis from individual behavior and cognition to larger systems that include behaving cognitive agents interacting with each other and with other…
Representation as Shared Activity: Situated Cognition and Dewey's Cartography of Experience
Dewey described the continuity of experience and the interaction of individuals with their environments as longitude and latitude for locating educative experience. This article examines three…
2 From Practice Fields to Communities of Practice
In writing this chapter, we (a constructivist and a situativity theorist) struggled with the distinction between situativity and constructivism. and the implications in terms of the design of…
Balancing situativity and formality: the importance of relating a formal language to interactive graphics in logic instruction
Directions for an Embodied Cognitive Science
The closed room
The most significant model of reasoning to come out of Cognitive Science began with the early work of Newell and Simon (1972) on human problem solving and has developed into an architecture for…
...
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 43 REFERENCES
Situated Action: A Symbolic Interpretation
TLDR
It is proposed that the goals set forth by the proponents of SA can be attained only within the framework of symbolic systems, and the main body of empirical evidence supporting this view resides in the numerous symbol systems constructed in the past 35 years that have successfully simulated broad areas of human cognition.
Situations and Attitudes.
In this provocative book, Barwise and Perry tackle the slippery subject of "meaning, " a subject that has long vexed linguists, language philosophers, and logicians.
Cognition in practice : mind, mathematics, and culture in everyday life
List of figures List of tables Preface 1. Introduction: psychology and anthropology I Part I. Theory in Practice: 2. Missionaries and cannibals (indoors) 3. Life after school 4. Psychology and…
Cultural psychology: a once and future discipline?
  • M. Cole
  • Psychology
    Nebraska Symposium on Motivation. Nebraska Symposium on Motivation
  • 1989
TLDR
This book discusses cross-Cultural Psychology, Cognitive Development, Culture, and Schooling, and a Multilevel Methodology for Cultural Psychology.
The Liar: An Essay on Truth and Circularity
INTRODUCTION: The Liar Sentences, statements, and Propositions The universe of hypersets RUSSELLIAN PROPOSITIONS AND THE LIAR: Modeling Russellian propositions Truth of Russellian propositions…
The situation in logic
The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception
Contents: Preface. Introduction. Part I: The Environment To Be Perceived.The Animal And The Environment. Medium, Substances, Surfaces. The Meaningful Environment. Part II: The Information For Visual…
Visual guidance of walking through apertures: body-scaled information for affordances.
  • W. H. Warren, S. Whang
  • Biology
    Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance
  • 1987
TLDR
This study videotaped large and small subjects walking through apertures to determine empirically the critical aperture-to-shoulder-width ratio (A/S) marking the transition from frontal walking to body rotation and tested the hypothesis that perceptual judgments of "passability" are based on intrinsic or body-scaled information specifying aperture width as a ratio of the observer's eyeheight.
Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation
TLDR
This work has shown that legitimate peripheral participation in communities of practice is not confined to midwives, tailors, quartermasters, butchers, non-drinking alcoholics and the like.
Logic and information
1. Logic 2. Information 3. Situation theory 4. Meaning and constraints 5. Some logical issues 6. Mental states 7. Perception and action 8. Situation semantics 9. Topics in situation semantics 10.…
...
...