Situated Action: A Symbolic Interpretation

@article{Vera1993SituatedAA,
  title={Situated Action: A Symbolic Interpretation},
  author={Alonso H. Vera and Herbert A. Simon},
  journal={Cogn. Sci.},
  year={1993},
  volume={17},
  pages={7-48}
}
The congeries of theoretical views collectively referred to as “situated action” (SA) claim that humans and their interactions with the world cannot be understood using symbol-system models and methodology, but only by observing them within real-world contexts or building nonsymbolic models of them. [] Key Result The main body of empirical evidence supporting our view resides in the numerous symbol systems constructed in the past 35 years that have successfully simulated broad areas of human cognition.

Response to Vera and Simon's Situated Action: A Symbolic Interpretation

TLDR
I take it that the article by Vera and Simon (1993) is inspired by their sense of a need to respond to recent challenges from within cognitive science, and in formulating their article as a response to these challenges, they have grouped together a diverse, often incommensurate set of positions under the label SA.

Situated Action : A Neuropsychologiwl Interpretation Response to Vera and

Situated cognition research rejects the hypothesis that neurological structures and processes are similar in kind to the symbols we create and use in our everyday lives. The symbolic approach, as

The Symbolic Worldview: Reply to Vera and Simon

Vera and Simon (1993) wish to choose up sides between two schools of research in cognitive science, their own symbolic approach versus a loosely associated group of authors concerned with "situated

The Symbolic Worldview : Reply to Vera and

Vera and Simon (1993) wish to choose up sides between two schools of research in cognitive science, their own symbolic approach versus a loosely associated group of authors concerned with "situated

Plans and Situated Actions: A Retro-Review

Three important books appeared in 1986, Mind Over Machine by Hubert and Stuart Dreyfus, Understanding Computers and Cognition by Terry Winograd and Fernando Flores, and Plans and Situated Actions by

Semantics, experience and time

Epistemological Approach to the Process of Practice

TLDR
This paper will investigate how the process of practise relates to deeper forms of contextual representations of knowledge and argues that the omission of these higher forms of context is one of the fundamental problems in the application and interpretation of symbolic knowledge.

Integrating, Not Debating, Situated Action and Computational Models: Taking the Environment Seriously

  • M. Byrne
  • Psychology
    Proceedings of the Sixteenth Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society
  • 2019
TLDR
A framework of building models of the environment and having models of cognitive agents work with those models is proposed, from which a smooth integration of SA and symbol processing is not only possible, but desirable.

Plans and Situated Action Ten Years On

The title of Lucy Suchman's celebrated Plans and SituatedAction does not state an opposition between plans and situated action. It is not plans versus situated action, though this is perhaps the way

Representation as Shared Activity: Situated Cognition and Dewey's Cartography of Experience

Dewey described the continuity of experience and the interaction of individuals with their environments as longitude and latitude for locating educative experience. This article examines three
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 41 REFERENCES

Understanding computers and cognition - a new foundation for design

TLDR
It is argued that what AI needs is not so much a hermeneutic approach as a better appreciation of biology and psychology.

Naming and Necessity

I hope that some people see some connection between the two topics in the title. If not, anyway, such connections will be developed in the course of these talks. Furthermore, because of the use of

The instability of graded structure: implications for the nature of concepts

TLDR
This chapter reviews empirical findings showing that the graded structure of a category is unstable, varying widely across contexts, and it is concluded that graded structures do not represent invariant structural characteristics of Categories.

Penguins Can Make Cake

TLDR
The structure of Blockhead elucidates the relationship between planning, universal plans, and Pengi and concludes that planning and universal plans are computationally intractable because of the representational assumptions they make.

Intelligence without Representation

In search of insight

Cognition in practice : mind, mathematics, and culture in everyday life

List of figures List of tables Preface 1. Introduction: psychology and anthropology I Part I. Theory in Practice: 2. Missionaries and cannibals (indoors) 3. Life after school 4. Psychology and

The Sciences of the Artificial

Continuing his exploration of the organization of complexity and the science of design, this new edition of Herbert Simon's classic work on artificial intelligence adds a chapter that sorts out the

Towards real-time GOMS: a model of expert behaviour in a highly interactive task

TLDR
An analysis of an expert performing a highly interactive computer task uses GOMS models, specifying the Goals, Operators, Methods, and Selection rules used by the expert, and results are presented, including the discrepancy between the models.

Models of Thought

Nobel Laureate Herbert A. Simon has in the past quarter century been in the front line of the information-processing revolution; in fact, to a remarkable extent his and his colleagues' contributions