Sidney W. Mintz Lecture for 1995: Controlling Processes Tracing the Dynamic Components of Power

@article{Nader1997SidneyWM,
  title={Sidney W. Mintz Lecture for 1995: Controlling Processes Tracing the Dynamic Components of Power},
  author={Laura Nader},
  journal={Current Anthropology},
  year={1997},
  volume={38},
  pages={711 - 738}
}
  • L. Nader
  • Published 1 December 1997
  • Sociology
  • Current Anthropology
Ideas about culture are interwoven with notions of control and the dynamics of power. To show how controlling processes work to construct and institutionalize culture, I examine three ethnographic examples of different types of control‐‐‐(1) moving people to see harmony rather than justice as desirable, (2) inducing women to undergo body‐altering surgery under the illusion of free choice, and (3) dismissing the context of scientific work by emphasizing an idealized version of science. The… 
View on U Chicago Press
cloudfront.escholarship.org
146 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
5
Background Citations
43
Methods Citations
3

146 Citations

Capitalism and the Politics of Resignation

Anthropologists since the 1990s have paid greater attention to the state and governmentality than to one of the most consequential forms of power in our time, the corporation. The lack of attention…

The continuum of complicity: “Studying up”/studying power as a feminist, anti-racist, or social justice venture

Practicing Harmony Ideology: Ethnographic Reflections on Community and Coercion

Twenty-five years ago, drawing on her fieldwork among the Zapotec, the legal anthropologist Laura Nader proposed the term harmony ideology to characterize postcolonial systems of justice. She found…

A relational approach to the ethnographic study of power in the context of the city of London

The immersive ethnographic tradition has strong potential to contribute to a deeper sociological understanding of the construction, maintenance and processes of powerful groups. However, ethnography…

Toward a Critical Anthropology of Human Rights

Some 17 years after the end of the cold war, the international and transnational human rights regimes that emerged in the wake of the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights are at a crossroads.…

Culture and mediation: A contemporary processual analysis from southwestern Gambia

Feminism and International Law: Theory, Methodology, and Substantive Reform

The purposes of this article are to analyze the claims, advanced by feminists, that international law disfavors women's interests and viewpoints conceptually, procedurally, and substantively; to…

Redefining roles and identities in higher education: the liminal experiences of a university spinout company

Across many developed economies, policy foregrounds the role of innovation in stimulating economic recovery and underpinning growth. Higher education is expected to contribute significantly to the…

Resocializing Suffering

An ethnographic account of the putative shift away from state-sponsored violence and the emergence of new patterns of violence in postwar Guatemala challenges liberal political and moral models that…

Slow ethnography: A hut with a view

Informed by the snail's pace of the Zapatista “caracol” process and the Slow Food movement, this contribution explores the liberatory potential of “slow ethnography” over two decades in the Maya…
...

References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 125 REFERENCES

Marxism and Literature

Marxism is a body ofideas which sees all human history as the history of class struggle. In particular, it is concerned to analyse the dynamics and contradictions of the capitalist system, and to…

Culture, Genuine and Spurious

  • E. Sapir
  • Sociology
    American Journal of Sociology
  • 1924
Varying definitions of culture. The ethnologist's or culture-historian's use of the term. Individual culture as a traditional ideal. The general spirit of the "genius" of a national civilization;…

Are There Histories of Peoples Without Europe? A Review Article

  • T. Asad
  • Economics
    Comparative Studies in Society and History
  • 1987
Wolf's book is a stimulating one from which every reader will derive some profit. His project is to demonstrate that the societies typically studied by anthropologists have been continuously changed…

Naturalizing Power : Essays in Feminist Cultural Analysis

This collection of essays analyzes relations of social inequality that appear to be logical extensions of a "natural order" and in the process demonstrates that a revitalized feminist anthropology of…

The Future of Capitalism : How Today's Economic Forces Shape Tomorrow's World

"Survival of the fittest" capitalism stands alone and apparently trimphant. Communism has collapsed and the social welfare state is breaking down everywhere. But technology and ideology are shaking…

ANTHROPOLOGISTS VIEW AMERICAN CULTURE

Anthropologists, including Franz Boas (7), have written about American culture since the beginning of the discipline. The 1940s witnessed an explosion of interest, expressed well in the popular books…

Legal Evolution and Societal Complexity

Comparative cross-cultural data suggest that legal characteristics occur in a standard sequential order. Mediation, police, and counsel are scaled in a sample of fifty-one societies; and their…

Methods of Study of Culture Contact

Discussions on culture contact are liable to be unprofitable because there is no general agreement as to what culture contact is. I have used the fashionable label in my title, but do not wish to…

The Kpelle Moot: A Therapeutic Model for the Informal Settlement of Disputes

Opening Paragraph Africa as a major culture area has been characterized by many writers as being -marked by a high development of law and legal procedures. In the past few years research on African…

The Anthropology of Authenticity: Everyman His Own Anthropologist

Anthropology, the contributors to the recent volume Reinventing Anthropology tell us, is suffering from severe hardening of the intellectual arteries. In order for it to be revitalized, they say, the…
...