Shortlisting Rules and Incentives in an End-to-End Model for Participatory Budgeting

  title={Shortlisting Rules and Incentives in an End-to-End Model for Participatory Budgeting},
  author={Simon Rey and Ulle Endriss and Ronald de Haan},
We introduce an end-to-end model for participatory budgeting grounded in social choice theory. Our model accounts for the interplay between the two stages commonly encountered in real-life partici- patory budgeting. In the first stage participants pro- pose projects to be shortlisted, while in the second stage they vote on which of the shortlisted projects should be funded. Prior work of a formal nature has focused on analysing the second stage only. We in- troduce several shortlisting… Expand
2 Citations
Proportionally Representative Participatory Budgeting with Ordinal Preferences
This study considers PB in which voters may be asymmetric, and they report ordinal preferences over projects, and proposes proportional representation axioms for the setting and clarifies how they fit into other preference aggregation settings. Expand


Participatory Budgeting: Models and Approaches
A mathematical model for participatory budgeting is presented, which charts existing models across different axes including whether the projects are treated as “divisible’ or “indivisible” and whether there are funding limits on individual projects. Expand
The Core of the Participatory Budgeting Problem
This work argues that the classic game theoretic notion of core captures fairness in the setting, and empirically shows that the core can be efficiently computed for utility functions that naturally model data from real participatory budgeting instances. Expand
Knapsack Voting : Voting mechanisms for Participatory Budgeting
We address the question of aggregating the preferences of voters in the context of participatory budgeting. We scrutinize the voting method currently used in practice, underline its drawbacks, andExpand
Participatory Budgeting with Project Interactions
This work augments the standard model of participatory budgeting by introducing a partition over the projects and model the type and extent of project interactions within each part using certain functions, and identifies certain cases that admit efficient aggregation in the presence of such project interactions. Expand
Preference Elicitation For Participatory Budgeting
It is found that threshold approval voting is qualitatively superior, and also performs well in experiments using data from real participatory budgeting elections, and analytically compare four preference elicitation methods: knapsack votes, rankings by value or value for money, and threshold approval votes. Expand
Designing Participatory Budgeting Mechanisms Grounded in Judgment Aggregation
A new approach is introduced for designing rules for participatory budgeting, the problem of deciding on the use of public funds based directly on the views expressed by the citizens concerned, which is embedded into judgment aggregation, a powerful general-purpose framework for modelling collective decision making. Expand
The Lisbon Participatory Budget: results and perspectives on an experience in slow but continuous transformation
Since 2008, Lisbon has been the first European capital to adopt a Participatory Budget (PB) process at a municipal scale to involve its inhabitants in the elaboration and ranking of the proposals toExpand
Approval-Based Shortlisting
This paper axiomatically analyze established and new shortlisting methods and complement this analysis with an experimental evaluation based on biased voters and noisy quality estimates, which lead to recommendations which short listing methods to use, depending on the desired properties. Expand
Proportionally Representative Participatory Budgeting: Axioms and Algorithms
This work observes a rich landscape with respect to the computational complexity of identifying proportional budgets and computing such, and presents budgeting methods that satisfy axioms by identifying budgets that are representative to the demands of vast segments of the voters. Expand
Participatory budgeting: a significant contribution to participatory democracy
This paper describes participatory budgeting in Brazil and elsewhere as a significant area of innovation in democracy and local development. It draws on the experience of 25 municipalities in LatinExpand