Sensory Measurements: Coordination and Standardization

  title={Sensory Measurements: Coordination and Standardization},
  author={Ann-Sophie Barwich and Hasok Chang},
  journal={Biological Theory},
Do sensory measurements deserve the label of “measurement”? We argue that they do. They fit with an epistemological view of measurement held in current philosophy of science, and they face the same kinds of epistemological challenges as physical measurements do: the problem of coordination and the problem of standardization. These problems are addressed through the process of “epistemic iteration,” for all measurements. We also argue for distinguishing the problem of standardization from the… 
From successful measurement to the birth of a law: Disentangling coordination in Ohm's scientific practice.
  • M. Luchetti
  • Medicine, Computer Science
    Studies in history and philosophy of science
  • 2020
This paper argues for a distinction between two scales of coordination in scientific inquiry, and argues that Ohm's assumption that tension is equally distributed in the circuit is best understood as part of the general coordination between Ohn's law and the empirical regularity that it expresses.
Hubris to humility: Tonal volume and the fundamentality of psychophysical quantities.
It is argued the return of fundamentality follows from a trend toward increasing epistemic humility, illustrated by following the trajectory of research on a particular candidate attribute: tonal volume.
Up the nose of the beholder? Aesthetic perception in olfaction as a decision-making process
Abstract Is the sense of smell a source of aesthetic perception? Traditional philosophical aesthetics has centered on vision and audition but eliminated smell for its subjective and inherently
How to be rational about empirical success in ongoing science: The case of the quantum nose and its critics.
  • A. Barwich
  • Medicine
    Studies in history and philosophy of science
  • 2018
It is argued that normative appeals to empirical success in the evaluation of competing scientific explanations can result in unreliable conclusions, especially when the authors are looking at the changeability of direction in unsettled investigations.
How incoherent measurement succeeds: Coordination and success in the measurement of the earth's polar flattening.
A dynamic revision of coherentism is called for, which allows to judge the success of a metric based on both its coherence and fruitfulness, and aims to coordinate theoretical definitions and produce novel data and theoretical insights.
Computing Odor Images.
This perspective examines psychophysical methods that may reveal the algorithms that encode odor images by integrating current data from sensory measurement into a computational model of odor
What is so special about smell? Olfaction as a model system in neurobiology
  • A. Barwich
  • Biology, Medicine
    Postgraduate Medical Journal
  • 2015
Research on the OR binding site investigates what amino acid sequences determine the receptor-binding capacity, and promises a better understanding of how the basic genetic makeup of GPCRs relates to their diversification in ligand-binding capacities.
The Evidence for the accelerating universe: endorsement and robust consistency
The 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics was awarded to researchers from the Supernova Cosmology Project and the High- z Supernova Search Team for the discovery of the accelerating expansion of the universe.
La philosophie morale expérimentale est-elle expérimentale ?
La philosophie morale experimentale telle qu’elle se developpe depuis vingt ans a pour ambition d’apporter des arguments aux debats philosophiques par l’utilisation de methodes experimentales issues


A Sense So Rare: Measuring Olfactory Experiences and Making a Case for a Process Perspective on Sensory Perception
This article challenges the standard categories through which most arguments in this debate have been framed to date and argues for an understanding of perception through a process view, rather than one pertaining to objects and properties of objects.
The Psychophysics of Sensory Function.
properly with psychophysics, the hundred-year-old discipline con cerned with the responses that organisms make to the energies of the environment. We live in a restless world of energetic forces,
Assessment of the Sniff Magnitude Test as a clinical test of olfactory function
It is concluded that the Sniff Magnitude Test has significant potential as a clinical measure of olfactory function, and that further testing and development of this method are warranted.
Old and New Problems in Philosophy of Measurement
The philosophy of measurement studies the conceptual, ontological, epistemic, and technological conditions that make measurement possible and reliable. A new wave of philosophical scholarship has
Cross-Cultural Administration of an Odor Discrimination Test
This study compares the discrimination scores of 169 Polish people with the scores of 99 Tsimane’, Bolivian Amerindians and suggests that when a discrimination task is chosen as the form of olfactory testing, some additional variables need to be controlled.
Different odor tests contribute differently to the evaluation of olfactory loss.
Combined testing of several components of olfaction, especially including assessment of thresholds, provides the most significant approach to the diagnosis of smell loss.
Human olfactory psychophysics
Human olfactory psychophysics, the study of how humans perceive odors, is possible because humans have acquired language and there are of course many things that cannot be done in humans, but these types of approaches are successfully used in animal models.
The number of olfactory stimuli that humans can discriminate is still unknown
It is shown that this claim is the result of a fragile estimation framework capable of producing nearly any result from the reported data, including values tens of orders of magnitude larger or smaller than the one originally reported in (Bushdid et al., 2014).
Epistemic and methodological iteration in scientific research
A number of scholars have recently drawn attention to the importance of iteration in scientific research. This paper builds on these previous discussions by drawing a distinction between epistemic
Temporal Integration of Olfactory Perceptual Evidence in Human Orbitofrontal Cortex
It is established that odor evidence integration in the human olfactory system enhances discrimination on a two-alternative forced-choice task, highlighting a key role for the orbitofrontal cortex in resolving sensory uncertainty and providing substantiation for accumulator models of human perceptual decision-making.