Selling out on nature

@article{McCauley2006SellingOO,
  title={Selling out on nature},
  author={Douglas J. McCauley},
  journal={Nature},
  year={2006},
  volume={443},
  pages={27-28}
}
With scant evidence that market-based conservation works, argues Douglas J. McCauley, the time is ripe for returning to the protection of nature for nature's sake.Back to natureWith scant evidence that market-based conservation works, argues Douglas J. McCauley, the time is ripe for a return to the protection of nature for nature's sake. 
View on Nature
labs.eemb.ucsb.edu
664 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
27
Background Citations
236
Methods Citations
4
Results Citations
2

Topics from this paper

      664 Citations

      Citation Type

      Citation Type

      Nature: the many benefits of ecosystem services
      TLDR
      Commentary in Nature last month argued that with little evidence to show that market-based conservation works, the time was ripe for a return to the protection of nature for nature's sake, and the issues are aired. Expand
      Conservation science: Trade-in to trade-up
      Nature reserves and protected areas enjoy sacred status in conservation — which translates into a 'do not touch' attitude. But selling off some of the less worthy of them would pay conservation… Expand
      Conservation through Commodification?
      During the past decade, we have seen the introduction of market-based mechanisms in biodiversity policy. Biodiversity markets are considered powerful tools to slow down or even stop the ongoing loss… Expand
      Market‐based conservation: Aligning static theory with dynamic systems
      This paper provides a broad evaluation of the implications of market‐based conservation (MBC) strategies from economic, social and ecological perspectives. After reviewing the economic theory that… Expand
      Buying into conservation: intrinsic versus instrumental value.
      TLDR
      After examining what intrinsic value is supposed to be, it is argued that it cannot guide the decision making conservation requires and an adequate ethical basis for conservation must do this, and instrumental value does it best. Expand
      Bulldozing biodiversity: The economics of offsets and trading-in Nature
      Many conservationists have become enamoured with mainstream economic concepts and approaches, described as pragmatic replacements for appeals to ethics and direct regulation. Trading biodiversity… Expand
      Is world conservation at risk of over-reliance on booming PES ?
      Using the article by Muradian et al. (2013) as entry point, I develop a broader framework for the conditions needed to allow PES to emerge and function. It is argued that PES are designed as… Expand
      Ecosystem Services Go Beyond Money and Markets: Reply to Silvertown.
      TLDR
      The paper raises valid concerns about ES monetization, but also points to a supposed ‘dominant neoliberal ideology’ behind the ES concept and characterizes the problem of biodiversity loss as lying ‘deeper in anthropocentrism’. Expand
      Whose conservation?
      • G. Mace
      • Geography, Medicine
      • Science
      • 2014
      TLDR
      Changes in the perception and goals of nature conservation require a solid scientific basis to be sustained, and these shifts mainly relate to how the relationships between people and nature are viewed, with consequences for the science underpinning conservation. Expand
      Ecologists, economics and politics: problems and contradictions in applying neoliberal ideology to nature conservation in Australia
      In a recent Forum Essay in Pacific Conservation Biology, the well known ecologist Harry Recher argued that over the past three decades Australia had experienced a ‘failure of science’ and a… Expand
      ...
      1
      2
      3
      4
      5
      ...

      References

      SHOWING 1-10 OF 18 REFERENCES
      Requiem for Nature
      In Requiem for Nature, John Terborgh examines current conservation strategies and considers the shortcomings of parks and protected areas both from ecological and institutional perspectives. He… Expand
      Economic value of tropical forest to coffee production.
      TLDR
      The value of tropical forest in supplying pollination services to agriculture translates into approximately 60,000 USD per year for one Costa Rican farm during 2000-2003, which is commensurate with expected revenues from competing land uses and far exceeds current conservation incentive payments. Expand
      Restoring Nature, Without Mosquitoes?
      TLDR
      This essay's general theme is that there are pros and cons to restoration or creation of wetlands and that mosquitoes pose practical and theoretical problems. Expand
      Millennium Ecosystem Assessment: Ecosystems and human well-being: a framework for assessment
      The 245-page report lays out the approaches, assumptions, processes, and parameters scientists are using in the study. It offers decision-makers a mechanism to identify options that can better… Expand
      People and Wildlife, Conflict or Co-existence?
      Foreword John G. Robinson 1. The impact of human-wildlife conflict on natural systems Rosie Woodroffe, Simon Thirgood and Alan Rabinowitz 2. The impact of human-wildlife conflict on human lives and… Expand
      Diversity of life
      It is clear that the above can lead to confusion when scientists of different countries are trying to communicate with each other. Another example is the burrowing rodent called a gopher found… Expand
      Climate effects of global land cover change
      There are two competing effects of global land cover change on climate: an albedo effect which leads to heating when changing from grass/croplands to forest, and an evapotranspiration effect which… Expand
      New York Times New York's water supply may need filtering
      • New York Times New York's water supply may need filtering
      • 2006
      From the mountain to the tap: how land use and water management can work for the rural poor
      Geophys. Res. Lett
      • Geophys. Res. Lett
      • 2005
      ...
      1
      2
      ...