Self-reported medication non-compliance in the elderly


Objective: To assess self-reported compliance with prescribed medications in a population of elderly patients prior to their hospital admission in an attempt to understand further the factors which influence drug-taking patterns. Methods: Information which, based on personal clinical experience and published research, may impact on compliance was collected for patients by way of a chart review within 3 days of hospital admission, a search of patient computerised hospital records and an interview. All crude data were coded and entered into a computerised relational database. Each patient's data were assessed using the Naranjo algorithm and the score was recorded. Chi-square analysis highlighted those factors which significantly influenced compliance, sub-divided into under-compliance (taking less medicine than prescribed) and over-compliance (taking more medicine than prescribed). Inter-relationships between variables were investigated using multiple-regression analysis. Results: Overall, 13.7% of the population (n=512) reported non-compliance, with 10.7% reporting under-compliance and 4.3% reporting over-compliance. A number of patients reported both under- and over-compliance. Being prescribed bronchodilators, for example, was found to be associated with under-compliance, while being prescribed analgesics (excluding non-steroidal anti-inflammatories) was associated with over-compliance using Chi-square analysis. A five-variable non-compliance risk model was obtained from logistic regression analysis. This model had a specificity of 88.9% and a sensitivity of 33.3%. The factors shown to influence compliance were the type of drug being taken (diuretics, bronchodilators and benzodiazepines), independence when taking medicines and the number of non-prescription drugs being taken. All other laboratory/test data, diseases/diagnoses, reasons for hospital admission and socio-demographic factors were not significant risk factors for self-reported non-compliance in the present model. Conclusions: Although it is accepted that self-reporting of poor compliance is generally lower than actual poor compliance, the present risk model provides further insight into the drug-taking habits of elderly patients.

DOI: 10.1007/s002280050358

7 Figures and Tables


Citations per Year

211 Citations

Semantic Scholar estimates that this publication has 211 citations based on the available data.

See our FAQ for additional information.

Cite this paper

@article{McElnay1997SelfreportedMN, title={Self-reported medication non-compliance in the elderly}, author={James C. McElnay and Catriona McCallion and F. Al-Deagi and Mitchell G . Scott}, journal={European Journal of Clinical Pharmacology}, year={1997}, volume={53}, pages={171-178} }