Self-Report of Right-Left Confusion in College Men and Women

@article{Hannay1990SelfReportOR,
  title={Self-Report of Right-Left Confusion in College Men and Women},
  author={H. Julia Hannay and P J Ciaccia and Jeanne Wald Kerr and Daniel Barrett},
  journal={Perceptual and Motor Skills},
  year={1990},
  volume={70},
  pages={451 - 457E}
}
Self-report questionnaires of difficulty in right-left discrimination and handedness were given to 575 male and 607 female undergraduates. Significantly more men and lefthanders reported having right-left confusion frequently or all the time. The validity of such self-report measures in predicting actual performance on right-left discrimination tasks is questioned since the results, at least as a function of handedness, depended on the question asked. 

Tables and Topics from this paper

Problems in Left-Right Discrimination in a High-Iq Population 1
The prevalence of difficulties in left-right discrimination was investigated in a group of 2,720 adult members of the high-IQ societies Mensa and Intertel. Over-all, 7.2% of the men and 18.8% of the
Problems in left-right discrimination in a high-IQ population.
  • M. Storfer
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Perceptual and motor skills
  • 1995
TLDR
The prevalence of difficulties in left-right discrimination was investigated in a group of 2,720 adult members of the high-IQ societies Mensa and Intertel, with participants who were relatively ambidextrous experienced problems more frequently than did those who were more strongly left- or right-handed.
The Impact of Handedness, Sex, and Cognitive Abilities on Left–Right Discrimination: A Behavioral Study
TLDR
An advantage of left-handers in both identifying left hands and in verifying “left” propositions and a negative correlation of LRD reaction time with visuo-spatial and verbal long-term memory was found independently of sex, providing new insights into the relationship between cognitive skills and performance on LRD.
Sex Differences in Left/Right Confusion
TLDR
It is concluded that self-ratings on left/right confusion questions, although they yield reliable sex differences, are poor predictors of actual performance on spatial tasks that involve left/ right judgements.
Sex differences in left–right confusion depend on hemispheric asymmetry
TLDR
Both tasks consistently revealed that women were more susceptible to left-right confusion than men, which suggests that the impact of functional verbal asymmetries on LRC is mediated by sex.
Individual differences in degree of handedness and somesthetic asymmetry predict individual differences in left-right confusion
TLDR
Results suggest that individuals who reveal a stronger internal bias between both sides of the body show less left-right confusion than people with less salient bodily asymmetry.
Mental rotation does not account for sex differences in left–right confusion
TLDR
To rule out the possibility that sex Differences in LRC are confounded by sex differences in mental rotation, male and female participants were matched for mental rotation performance, resulting in a sample of 46 matched participants that showed robustSex differences in favour of men in all LRC measurements.
The neural correlates of sex differences in left–right confusion
TLDR
It is concluded that there are sex differences in the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying LRD, and the hypothesis that more left-right confusion is due to more bilateral activation (in women) can be rejected.
Dichotic listening and left–right confusion
TLDR
It is concluded that atypical ear asymmetries, as in certain clinical populations, cannot be explained by associated deficits in left-right discrimination, and LRC can negatively affect task performance, even when participants do not have to make explicit "left" versus "right" decisions.
Right-left discrimination: effects of handedness and educational background.
  • S. Ofte
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Scandinavian journal of psychology
  • 2002
TLDR
The main finding was that the medical students performed better than the psychology students for all figure orientation subtests and for all arm positions.
...
1
2
3
4
5
...

References

SHOWING 1-6 OF 6 REFERENCES
University Professors' Self-Descriptions of Left-Right Confusability: Sex and Handedness Differences
In a group of 364 university faculty members, frequency of self-reported confusion in left-right orientation was related to sex and handedness: among women, reports were statistically more common
Difficulties in right-left discrimination in a normal population.
  • S. Wolf
  • Psychology, Medicine
    Archives of neurology
  • 1973
In a group of physicians and their spouses, 17.5% of 382 women, and 8.8% of 408 men stated that they experienced frequent confusion in right-left orientation. Right-left confusion occurs often in
Tactile perception of direction in relation to handedness and familial handedness
TLDR
Perception of direction was significantly more accurate on the left hand than on the righthanded subjects, underscoring the importance of familial background as a determinant of performances reflecting asymmetry in hemispheric function.
Self-report of right-left confusion in college men and women
  • Perceptual and Motor Skills
  • 1990
Significantly more women and left-handers reported having right-left confusion occasionally, frequently, or all the time
  • Perceptual and Motor Skills
  • 1990
Residual vision in cortically blind hemiphields